From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State Board of Equalization v. Trailer Train Company

Supreme Court of Georgia
Oct 1, 1984
253 Ga. 449 (Ga. 1984)

Opinion

41248, 41249.

DECIDED OCTOBER 1, 1984. REHEARING DENIED OCTOBER 29, 1984.

Composition of public body; constitutional question. Fulton Superior Court. Before Judge Eldridge.

Michael J. Bowers, Attorney General, Warren R. Calvert, Assistant Attorney General, for appellants.

Powell, Goldstein, Frazer Murphy, James D. Levine, Nickolas P. Chilivis, Terrence J. Benshoof, David C. Garrett III, James R. Schulz, for appellees.


The State Board of Equalization and the Department of Revenue appeal from a judgment holding that former OCGA § 48-2-18 (which provided that the Board shall be composed of three officeholders from the executive branch and two from the legislative branch) violated the separation of powers provision of the 1983 Georgia Constitution, Art. I, Sec. II, Par. III.

This constitutional issue was not raised before the agency, but on appeal to the superior court.

We have required litigants to raise the constitutionality of applicable zoning classifications before that body having authority to rezone. DeKalb County v. Post Properties, 245 Ga. 214, 218 ( 263 S.E.2d 905) (1980); Board of Commrs. v. Agri-Bio Corp., 249 Ga. 112, 113 ( 288 S.E.2d 206) (1982). This same rule has been applied to constitutional challenges first raised in the superior courts, rather than in the state agency in which proceedings commenced. Waller v. State Constr. Indus. Licensing Bd., 250 Ga. 529, 530 ( 299 S.E.2d 554) (1983). The reason for this requirement is to give to the appropriate body — at the first instance — an opportunity to "rectify the situation." Post Properties, supra at 218.

That rationale is equally as applicable to constitutional challenges to the composition of a public body as it is to other constitutional attacks.

As the constitutional issue had not been raised before the Board of Equalization, it was beyond the reach of the superior court.

Judgment reversed. All the Justices concur, except Bell, J., who dissents.

DECIDED OCTOBER 1, 1984 — REHEARING DENIED OCTOBER 29, 1984.


Summaries of

State Board of Equalization v. Trailer Train Company

Supreme Court of Georgia
Oct 1, 1984
253 Ga. 449 (Ga. 1984)
Case details for

State Board of Equalization v. Trailer Train Company

Case Details

Full title:STATE BOARD OF EQUALIZATION et al. v. TRAILER TRAIN COMPANY et al

Court:Supreme Court of Georgia

Date published: Oct 1, 1984

Citations

253 Ga. 449 (Ga. 1984)
320 S.E.2d 758

Citing Cases

Outdoors Systems, Inc. v. Cobb County

It is true that a challenge to the constitutionality of an ordinance cannot be mounted for the first time in…

Soerries v. City of Columbus

Moreover, Soerries' failure to raise the statutory issues before the Council precluded his raising them for…