Opinion
April 18, 1944.
April 21, 1944.
Appeals — Jurisdiction — Superior Court — Unlawful use of names — Subject of controversy — Statutory limitation — Acts of March 2, 1923, P.L. 3.
1. The Superior Court does not have jurisdiction on an appeal involving the alleged unlawful use of a name and involving no property or property rights.
2. The Superior Court has jurisdiction on appeal from the courts of common pleas only "if the subject of the controversy be either money, chattels, real or personal, or the possession of or title to real property": Act of March 2, 1923, P.L. 3, section 1.
3. The jurisdiction of the Superior Court is limited to matters expressly conferred by statute.
Before KELLER, P.J., BALDRIGE, RHODES, HIRT, KENWORTHEY, RENO and JAMES, JJ.
Appeal, No. 66, April T., 1944, from decree of C.P., Lawrence Co., June T., 1942, No. 4, in case of Societa di Mutuo Soccorso, Christoforo Colombo v. Stella D. Lombardo et al. Appeal certified to Supreme Court.
Bill in equity. Before LAMOREE, J.
Decree entered dismissing bill. Plaintiff appealed.
Alvah M. Shumaker, for appellant. John S. Powers, with him Charles V. Ross and Joseph Solomon, for appellees.
Argued April 18, 1944.
In this case the appellant, Society of Mutual Help Christopher Columbus, sought an injunction to prohibit the appellees, an unincorporated association, from using the name "Christopher Columbus Auxiliary". No property or property rights are involved.
The appeal was erroneously taken to this court. We have jurisdiction on appeal from the courts of common pleas only "if the subject of the controversy be either money, chattels, real or personal, or the possession of or title to real property": Act of March 2, 1923, P.L. 3, § 1, 17 Pa.C.S.A. § 184. Our jurisdiction is limited to matters expressly conferred by statute: Weinbach's Appeal, 316 Pa. 333, 175 A. 500. Appeals involving alleged unlawful use of names have uniformly been heard by the Supreme Court: See Pocono Pines Assembly v. Miller, 229 Pa. 33, 77 A. 1094; Peoples Trust Co. of Pittsburgh v. Safe Deposit Trust Co. of Pittsburgh, 259 Pa. 62, 102 A. 412.
The appeal is certified to the Supreme Court.