From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Scurry v. Friberg

Supreme Court of Texas
Nov 26, 1930
119 Tex. 463 (Tex. 1930)

Opinion

Application No. 17820.

Decided November 26, 1930.

Jurisdiction of Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court has appellate jurisdiction to review decisions of the Courts of Civil Appeals only in cases where the latter exercise appellate jurisdiction. It has none to grant a writ of error where a Court of Civil Appeals, in the exercise of its original jurisdiction, has issued a writ of mandamus.

Scurry and others apply for writ of error to the Court of Civil Appeals for the Second District upon their order issuing a writ of mandamus in exercise of their original jurisdiction.

Fischer Fischer, for plaintiff in error.


This suit is pending before us on application for writ of error to the Court of Civil Appeals for the Second District. The application shows that the case is an original suit filed in the Court of Civil Appeals, asking that court for a writ of mandamus against the plaintiffs in error, who were members of the Democratic Executive Committee of Wichita County, to require them to place the names of certain parties on the primary ballot as candidates for nomination to office at such primary. Upon hearing of the application and answer, the Court of Civil Appeals directed the issuance of the writ of mandamus. This application for writ of error is made by the plaintiffs in error because of that action by the Court of Civil Appeals.

The law is well settled that this Court has no jurisdiction of the subject matter of this suit. The Supreme Court has appellate jurisdiction to review decisions of the Courts of Civil Appeals only in cases where the latter exercise appellate jurisdiction. It has none to grant a writ of error where a Court of Civil Appeals in the exercise of its original jurisdiction, as in this case, has issued a writ of mandamus. The judgment of a Court of Civil Appeals in original actions of this character is final, in so far as the appellate jurisdiction of this Court is concerned. Schintz v. Morris, 89 Tex. 648; City of Houston v. City of Palestine, 114 Tex. 306. The petition for writ of error is accordingly dismissed for want of jurisdiction.


Summaries of

Scurry v. Friberg

Supreme Court of Texas
Nov 26, 1930
119 Tex. 463 (Tex. 1930)
Case details for

Scurry v. Friberg

Case Details

Full title:EDGAR SCURRY v. J. F. FRIBERG ET AL

Court:Supreme Court of Texas

Date published: Nov 26, 1930

Citations

119 Tex. 463 (Tex. 1930)
32 S.W.2d 637

Citing Cases

Woodruff v. Woodruff

Article 1728, Texas Revised Civil Statutes Annotated, provides for writ of error review only in 'cases when…

Jacolos v. State

The judgment of a Court of Civil Appeals in original actions of this character is final, so far as the…