From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Schamber v. Boyd

Supreme Court of Hawaii
Jan 4, 1937
34 Haw. 64 (Haw. 1937)

Opinion

No. 2242.

Filed August 21, 1936.

Decided January 4, 1937.

PETITION FOR REHEARING.

COKE, C.J., BANKS, J., AND CIRCUIT JUDGE BUCK IN PLACE OF PETERS, J., DISQUALIFIED.

Smith, Wild, Beebe Cades for petition for rehearing.

Anderson, Marx, Wrenn Jenks for petition for amendment of decision.


This is a petition by Eugene H. Schamber, plaintiff, defendant in error, for a rehearing. All the grounds upon which the petition is based are the alleged failure of the court to consider numerous portions of the testimony which if they had been considered it is claimed would have resulted in a different conclusion from that expressed in the opinion.

The petitioner is mistaken in his hypothesis that the evidence referred to was overlooked. On the contrary the entire evidence was considered and a rehearing of the case would serve no purpose. The petition is denied without argument under the rule.

Joseph T. Boyd, defendant, plaintiff in error, is dissatisfied with the conclusion of the court that the case be remanded for further proceedings not inconsistent with the opinion and petitions the court to enter in lieu thereof a judgment dismissing the plaintiff's case or instructing the court below to dismiss it. This question was considered when the opinion was written and we adhere to the conclusion originally reached. The petition is denied.


Summaries of

Schamber v. Boyd

Supreme Court of Hawaii
Jan 4, 1937
34 Haw. 64 (Haw. 1937)
Case details for

Schamber v. Boyd

Case Details

Full title:EUGENE H. SCHAMBER v. JOSEPH T. BOYD, DEFENDANT, AND WILLIAMS MORTUARY…

Court:Supreme Court of Hawaii

Date published: Jan 4, 1937

Citations

34 Haw. 64 (Haw. 1937)