From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Royal Ins. v. Eagle Valley Constr., Inc.

Supreme Court of Nevada
Feb 4, 1994
110 Nev. 119 (Nev. 1994)

Summary

holding that attorney fees and costs incurred in bringing a case cannot be relied upon to satisfy the jurisdictional threshold

Summary of this case from Crowley v. Burke

Opinion

No. 23322

February 4, 1994

Appeal from the First Judicial District Court, Carson City; Michael E. Fondi, Judge.

Beckley, Singleton, DeLanoy, Jemison List and Stephen S. Kent, Reno, for Appellants.

Perry Spann, Reno, for Respondent.


OPINION


This is an appeal from an order of the district court dismissing appellants' complaint for damages sustained in a traffic accident. The district court sua sponte dismissed appellants' complaint based on a lack of subject matter jurisdiction. Appellants claimed in their complaint $4,208.74 in damages. At the time appellants filed their action, however, NRS 4.370(1)(b) provided that the district court only had jurisdiction over suits involving more than $5,000 in damages.

This appeal was previously dismissed in an unpublished order of this court. On November 18, 1993, the district court requested this court to publish as an opinion our previous unpublished order. Cause appearing, we grant the request. Accordingly, we issue this opinion in place of our order dismissing this appeal filed September 29, 1993.

In 1993, the legislature amended NRS 4.370 and raised the jurisdictional limit of the district court to suits involving more than $7,500.

Appellants contend on appeal that attorney's fees and costs are included in the jurisdictional limit under NRS 4.370. Appellants thus argue that the attorney's fees and costs incurred in this case raise the amount in controversy above the jurisdictional threshold of the district court. Appellants' contention is without support. We have previously ruled that "[a] court which is the creation of statute has only the authority given to it by the statute." McKay v. City of Las Vegas, 106 Nev. 203, 205, 789 P.2d 584, 585 (1990). In this case, the justices' court has exclusive jurisdiction "if the damage claimed does not exceed $5,000." NRS 4.370(1)(b) (emphasis added). Because appellants only claim $4,208.74 in damages, the district court properly dismissed appellants' complaint for lack of jurisdiction. Accordingly, we affirm the decision of the district court.


Summaries of

Royal Ins. v. Eagle Valley Constr., Inc.

Supreme Court of Nevada
Feb 4, 1994
110 Nev. 119 (Nev. 1994)

holding that attorney fees and costs incurred in bringing a case cannot be relied upon to satisfy the jurisdictional threshold

Summary of this case from Crowley v. Burke

holding that attorney fees and costs cannot be added to a damages claim to raise the damages amount above the statutory minimum

Summary of this case from Edwards v. Direct Access, LLC

explaining that attorney fees, costs, and interest are not included when calculating the amount in controversy for the purpose of establishing jurisdiction

Summary of this case from Luckett v. Mohamed

In Royal Insurance v. Eagle Valley Construction, Inc., 110 Nev. 119, 120, 867 P.2d 1146, 1147 (1994), the district court's jurisdictional limit was not met because the claimed damages were less than the jurisdictional amount as set forth in NRS 4.370(1)(b), and attorney fees and costs would not be considered in order to raise the amount in controversy above the jurisdictional limit of the district court.

Summary of this case from Morrison v. Beach City LLC

In Royal Insurance, the district court dismissed a claim for lack of subject matter jurisdiction because the claimed damages in the complaint, exclusive of costs and attorney fees, were less than the jurisdictional threshold.

Summary of this case from Morrison v. Beach City LLC
Case details for

Royal Ins. v. Eagle Valley Constr., Inc.

Case Details

Full title:ROYAL INSURANCE, A DELAWARE CORPORATION, AND CARSON READY MIX, INC., A…

Court:Supreme Court of Nevada

Date published: Feb 4, 1994

Citations

110 Nev. 119 (Nev. 1994)
867 P.2d 1146

Citing Cases

Nev. Checker Cab Corp. v. Eighth Judicial Dist. Court of State

" Nev. Const. art. 6, § 6. NRS 4.370(l)(a) (2013) grants jurisdiction to justice courts for cases in which…

Morrison v. Beach City LLC

This court has previously determined jurisdiction solely on the basis of damages claimed in the complaint. In…