From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Rocker v. Cardinal B. L. Assn

Court of Errors and Appeals
Oct 26, 1937
194 A. 865 (N.J. 1937)

Opinion

Submitted October 29, 1935;Re-argued as Nos. 2/3, May 29, 1936 —

Decided October 26, 1937.

On appeal from the Supreme Court.

For the appellant, John J. Stamler.

For the respondent, Harold Simandl, John Warren, David T. Wilentz, attorney-general, amicus curiae ( Louis J. Cohen, assistant attorney-general, of counsel).


These appeals are, in all respects, identical with that of Busci v. Longworth Building and Loan Association (No. 57, May term, 1935, re-argued as No. 1, May term, 1936, decided October 26th, 1937), 119 N.J.L. 120, except that in the former the action was to recover the withdrawal value of installment shares, and in the latter the principal and interest of paid up shares. This is of no consequence. Pamph. L. 1925, ch. 65, pp. 223, 224, § 74, under the title of "status of shares, provides, inter alia," * * * and all members shall occupy the same relative status as to debts and losses of such association * * *" and "no agreement or understanding shall be made or entered into whereby the time for surrendering paid up shares to such association and withdrawing the value thereof shall be postponed and paid up shares shall only be surrendered and withdrawn on the same terms and under the same conditions as provided in the constitution for the surrender and withdrawal of installment shares * * *."

The judgments under review will be affirmed, with costs.

For affirmance — THE CHANCELLOR, CHIEF JUSTICE, BODINE, DONGES, PERSKIE, DEAR, WELLS, WOLFSKEIL, RAFFERTY, JJ. 9.

For reversal — PARKER, LLOYD, CASE, HEHER, JJ. 4.


Summaries of

Rocker v. Cardinal B. L. Assn

Court of Errors and Appeals
Oct 26, 1937
194 A. 865 (N.J. 1937)
Case details for

Rocker v. Cardinal B. L. Assn

Case Details

Full title:IDA ROCKER, PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT, v. CARDINAL BUILDING AND LOAN ASSOCIATION…

Court:Court of Errors and Appeals

Date published: Oct 26, 1937

Citations

194 A. 865 (N.J. 1937)
194 A. 865

Citing Cases

Veix v. Seneca Building & Loan Ass'n

We have held likewise when the owner of installment shares gave notice of withdrawal prior to the date when…

Hinchliffe v. Nat'l Dyeing & Printing Co.

There are a number of cases in this state which hold that amendments of the Act of 1896 apply to corporations…