Opinion
Case No.: 11-CV-2226 SI
10-26-2011
POSITIVE TECHNOLOGIES, INC., Plaintiff, v. SONY ELECTRONICS, INC., ACER AMERICA CORPORATION, GATEWAY, INC., DELL, INC., ASUS COMPUTER INTERNATIONAL, MSI COMPUTER CORPORATION, AMAZON.COM, INC., BARNES & NOBLE, INC., AND KOBO INC., Defendants, and CHUNGHWA PICTURE TUBES, LTD., Intervenor.
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF POSITIVE TECHNOLOGIES, INC. Perry R. Clark LAW OFFICES OF PERRY R. CLARK J. Scott Denko (Pro Hac Vice) (Texas State Bar No. 00792457) Bradley D. Coburn (Pro Hac Vice) (Texas State Bar No. 24036377) Steven J. Lauff (Pro Hac Vice) (Texas State Bar No. 24013011) DENKO COBURN & LAUFF LLP R. James George, Jr. (Pro Hac Vice) (Texas State Bar No. 07810000) GEORGE & BROTHERS LLP ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT SONY ELECTRONICS, INC. Kevin P.B. Johnson Jim Glass QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART & SULLIVAN ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT ACER AMERICA CORPORATION Kevin Jones Qudus Olaniran FREITAS, TSENG, BAIK & KAUFMAN LLP ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT GATEWAY, INC. Kevin Jones Qudus Olaniran FREITAS, TSENG, BAIK & KAUFMAN LLP ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT DELL, INC. Thomas M. Dunham (pro hac vice) J. Michael Woods (pro hac vice) NOVAK DRUCE + QUIGG LLP ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT ASUS COMPUTER INTERNATIONAL Karen I. Boyd Joshua M. Masur Steven W. Flanders TURNER BOYD LLP ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT MSI COMPUTER CORPORATION William James Brown , Jr Janet S. Park BROWN WEGNER BERLINER ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT AMAZON.COM, INC. Stephen J. Joncus John D. Vandenberg Philip Warrick KLARQUIST SPARKMAN, LLP Edward C. Duckers Craig A. Carnes, jr. STOEL RIVES LLP ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT BARNES & NOBLE, INC. Krista Marie Carter Christopher Hu DICKSTEIN SHAPIRO ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT KOBO INC. Robert Thomas Haslam , III COVINGTON & BURLING LLP Bhanu K Sadasivan COVINGTON AND BURLING LLP ATTORNEYS FOR INTERVENOR CHUNGWA PICTURE TUBES, LTD. James M. Godner Russ Emerson Steven M. Levitan HAYNES AND BOONE, LLP
Perry R. Clark (California Bar No. 197101)
LAW OFFICES OF PERRY R. CLARK
J. Scott Denko (Pro Hac Vice) (Texas State Bar
No. 00792457)
Bradley D. Coburn (Pro Hac Vice) (Texas
State Bar No. 24036377)
Steven J. Lauff (Pro Hac Vice) (Texas State
Bar No. 24013011)
DENKO COBURN & LAUFF LLP
Counsel for Plaintiff
POSITIVE TECHNOLOGIES, INC.
Thomas M. Dunham (pro hac vice)
J. Michael Woods (pro hac vice)
NOVAK DRUCE + QUIGG LLP
Stephanie R. Wood (State Bar No. 242572)
NOVAK DRUCE + QUIGG LLP
Attorneys for Defendant
DELL INC.
ADDITIONAL COUNSEL LISTED ON
SIGNATURE PAGE
STIPULATION TO EXTEND DEADLINE
FOR SERVICE OF DEFENDANTS'
INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS AND
ACCOMPANYING DOCUMENTS
AND [PROPOSED] ORDER
Defendants Sony Electronics, Inc., Acer America Corporation, Gateway, Inc., Dell Inc., ASUS Computer International, MSI Computer Corporation, Amazon.com, Inc., Barnes & Noble, Inc., Kobo Inc., and Intervenor Chunghwa Picture Tubes, Ltd. (cumulatively "Defendants") and Plaintiff Positive Technologies Inc. ("PTI") hereby stipulate and agree to extend the date for Defendants to serve their Invalidity Contentions and document production accompanying their Invalidity Contentions pursuant to N.D. California Patent Local Rules 3-3 and 3-4 by two business days from the Court ordered deadline of October 24, 2011 [Dkt. No. 209 entered September 9, 2011] to October 26, 2011.
PTI timely served its Disclosure of Asserted Claims Infringement Contentions by U.S. Mail. Service by U.S. Mail resulted in varying dates of receipt by Defendants. In light of the differing dates of receipt, Plaintiff offered to extend the date for Defendants to serve their Invalidity Contentions and document production accompanying their Invalidity Contentions by two business days.
This is the first extension to the Court's Scheduling Order Dkt. No. 209 sought by the parties. This extension will have no effect upon any of the other deadlines or the case schedule.
Respectfully Submitted,
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF POSITIVE
TECHNOLOGIES, INC.
Perry R. Clark
LAW OFFICES OF PERRY R. CLARK
J. Scott Denko (Pro Hac Vice)
(Texas State Bar No. 00792457)
Bradley D. Coburn (Pro Hac Vice)
(Texas State Bar No. 24036377)
Steven J. Lauff (Pro Hac Vice)
(Texas State Bar No. 24013011)
DENKO COBURN & LAUFF LLP
R. James George, Jr. (Pro Hac Vice)
(Texas State Bar No. 07810000)
GEORGE & BROTHERS LLP
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT SONY
ELECTRONICS, INC.
Kevin P.B. Johnson
Jim Glass
QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART &
SULLIVAN
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT ACER
AMERICA CORPORATION
Kevin Jones
Qudus Olaniran
FREITAS, TSENG, BAIK & KAUFMAN LLP
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT
GATEWAY, INC.
Kevin Jones
Qudus Olaniran
FREITAS, TSENG, BAIK & KAUFMAN LLP
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT DELL,
INC.
Thomas M. Dunham (pro hac vice)
J. Michael Woods (pro hac vice)
NOVAK DRUCE + QUIGG LLP
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT ASUS
COMPUTER INTERNATIONAL
Karen I. Boyd
Joshua M. Masur
Steven W. Flanders
TURNER BOYD LLP
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT MSI
COMPUTER CORPORATION
William James Brown , Jr
Janet S. Park
BROWN WEGNER BERLINER
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT
AMAZON.COM, INC.
Stephen J. Joncus
John D. Vandenberg
Philip Warrick
KLARQUIST SPARKMAN, LLP
Edward C. Duckers
Craig A. Carnes, jr.
STOEL RIVES LLP
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT BARNES
& NOBLE, INC.
Krista Marie Carter
Christopher Hu
DICKSTEIN SHAPIRO
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT KOBO
INC.
Robert Thomas Haslam , III
COVINGTON & BURLING LLP
Bhanu K Sadasivan
COVINGTON AND BURLING LLP
ATTORNEYS FOR INTERVENOR
CHUNGWA PICTURE TUBES, LTD.
James M. Godner
Russ Emerson
Steven M. Levitan
HAYNES AND BOONE, LLP
PURSUANT TO STIPULATION, IT IS SO ORDERED.
CERTIFICATION BY STEPHANIE WOOD PURSUANT TO GENERAL RULE. NO. 45,
SECTION X, RE E-FILING ON BEHALF OF MULTIPLE SIGNATORIES
1. I am an attorney licensed to practice law in the state of California, and an associate in the law firm of Novak Druce + Quigg LLP, counsel for defendant Dell Inc. The statements herein are made on my personal knowledge and if called as a witness I could and would testify thereto. 2. The above e-filed document contains multiple signatures. I declare that concurrence has been obtained from each of the other signatories to file this jointly prepared document with the Court. Pursuant to General Rule No. 45, I shall maintain records to support this concurrence for subsequent production for the Court if so ordered, or for inspection upon request by a party until one year after final resolution of the action (including appeal, if any). I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed this 24th day of October 2011, at San Francisco, California.
Stephanie R. Wood (State Bar No. 242572)