Poola v. Unemp. Comp. Bd. of Review

Full title: Mary J. POOLA, Appellant, v. COMMONWEALTH of Pennsylvania, UNEMPLOYMENT…

Court: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Date published: Mar 8, 1989

555 A.2d 97 (Pa. 1989)

555 A.2d 97

Opinion

Argued: September 28, 1988.

Decided: March 8, 1989.^_

_ This decision was considered and rendered prior to March 7, 1989.

Appeal from the Commonwealth Court, No. 1309 C.D. 1984.

John Stember, James P. O'Connell, Neighborhood Legal Services Ass'n, Pittsburgh, Pa., for appellant.

James Bradley, Asst. Counsel, Unemployment Compensation Bd. of Review, Clifford F. Blaze, Deputy Chief Counsel, Harrisburg, for appellee.

Before NIX, C.J., and LARSEN, FLAHERTY, McDERMOTT, ZAPPALA, PAPADAKOS and STOUT, JJ.

OPINION OF THE COURT

STOUT, Justice.

This is an appeal from the affirmance by the Commonwealth Court of the denial of benefits under the Unemployment Compensation Act [Act], Pa.Stat.Ann. tit. 43, §§ 751-882 (Purdon 1964 Purdon Supp.Pamph. 1988). The benefits were denied on the theory that Appellant lacked the qualifications required to secure compensation under section 801(a) of the Act which provided, among other things, that the claimant meet the financial eligibility requirements of section 804(c) of the Act.¹

1 Section 801(a) of the Act provides in pertinent part:
Compensation shall be payable to any employe who is or becomes unemployed, and who —
(a) Has, within his base year, been paid wages for employment as required by section [804(c) ] of this act . . .
At the time material to this case, section 804(c) provided in pertinent part that such wages must have been earned during eighteen to twenty-three "credit weeks" during a claimant's "base year." Section 804(c) has been amended to require sixteen credit weeks.
A "credit week" is defined in section 753(g.1) as: any calendar week in an individual's base year with respect to which he was paid in employment as defined in this act, remuneration of not less than fifty dollars ($50). Only one credit week can be established with respect to any one calendar week.
Section 753(a) of the Act defines "base year" to mean: ". . . the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters immediately preceding the first day of an individual's benefit year."

Appellant, Mary J. Poola, had been an employee of the Beaver County Job Training Partnership Agency for over seven years. In October 1982, Appellant was laid off. On October 22, 1982, her employer paid her a lump sum of $2,026.00. She subsequently received unemployment compensation benefits for one year and, on October 2, 1983, she filed a claim for benefits for a second year establishing July 1, 1982, to June 30, 1983, as the base year period. Appellant's base year, therefore, consisted of the last two quarters of 1982 and the first two quarters of 1983 with earnings for the entire fourth quarter of 1982 having been paid in a lump sum. At the hearing before the Referee, the employer explained the lump sum as follows:

Q. Could you explain this breakdown that we have marked as Exhibit Number Six?

A. Yes, what we did was give them two weeks a sort of like severance pay after the date of their termination. Like she terminated on the 4th and then we gave them the next two weeks as severance pay. And they were paid for any vacation that they had already accumulated and she had three weeks. And then we paid them for accrued vacation from the point and time of their anniversary until their termination date, their lay-off date which came out to 43 and three-quarters hours which is a little over a week.

Q. Are you saying that she had three weeks of accumulated vacation?

A. Yes, she had already worked for that.

Q. And she had one week accrued vacation.

A. Right and then she got sick time and her comp time. And all that was paid, I have a pay date of October 22nd.

Q. Alright [sic] anything else that you can add to this?

A. No, that's [sic].

Q. That was all paid in one check, a lump sum payment.

A. Right[.]

Q. So the two weeks continuation that was severance pay. That's on the employer's. That's how the employer classified it.

A. I don't think they ever classified it as severance, you know, as such but they were given two weeks pay.

Q. But they didn't work those two weeks.

A. No[.]

N.T. 12-5-83 at 4-5.

Appellant testified that she always took one week of vacation in May and one week at Thanksgiving, id. at 3, and that her employer permitted the scheduling of vacations with twenty-four hours advance notification. Id.

The sole issue before the Referee was whether Appellant's unscheduled vacation weeks could be computed as credit weeks for purposes of determining benefit eligibility. The Referee allowed thirteen credit weeks for the thirteen weeks of work in the third quarter of 1982 but computed only one credit week in the fourth quarter of 1982 after making a finding of fact that: "Claimant did not have any particular weeks of vacation scheduled at the time of her separation from work."² Referee's Decision at 1. According to the Referee's calculations, Appellant had only fourteen weeks in her base year instead of the requisite eighteen weeks. Appellant, however, contests this computation and claims that she should have been credited four weeks for the final quarter of 1982. We agree and, therefore, we reverse the decision of the Commonwealth Court.

2 The Referee made four other findings of fact:
1. Claimant filed an Application for benefits effective October 2, 1983, and established a base year period from July 1, 1982 to June 30, 1983.
2. During her base year claimant had total base year wages of [$5,273] with high quarter wages of $3,247.
3. Claimant, during said base year, worked 14 calendar weeks in which she was paid remuneration in excess of $50.00 per week.
4. Claimant received four weeks of vacation pay in a lump sum payment on October 22, 1982.
Referee's Decision at 1.

In support of his allowance of only one credit week for the accrued, but unscheduled, four-week vacation, the Referee reasoned:

Under the . . . definition of "credit week" claimant has 14 such weeks in her base year. This is insufficient to qualify her for benefits under the provisions of section [804(c)] of the Law. Claimant here argues that the lump sum payment she received should be counted for credit weeks. The Referee recognizes claimant's argument that if her lump sum payment was allocated over a four-week period it would then allow her to have credit for 18 weeks of wages. In the opinion of the Referee the claimant's request that the lump sum vacation pay allocated to the fourth quarter of 1982 will entitle claimant only [to] one credit week of wages. Under these circumstances claimant cannot be determined financially eligible under the provisions of Section [804(c)] of the Law.

Id. There is no statutory basis for this method of computation. Unemployment Compensation Bulletin No. 871, Supp. No. 8B, dated April 26, 1983, contains the following statement which is designated "Policy:"

If no pre-arranged vacation pay period was scheduled by either the claimant or employer and approved by the employer prior to the last day of work, the claimant's vacation pay shall be considered to represent payment for accrued vacation leave. In this case, one credit week would be assignable to the week in which the vacation payment was made to the claimant. If the employer chooses to make this payment in several installments in accordance with his/her customary pay period, only one credit week is assignable to the first pay period in which the vacation payment was made.

Lopata v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 507 Pa. 570, 493 A.2d 657 (1985), however, taught that this Bulletin provision must be considered a regulation rather than merely a statement of policy. As such it does not comply with the Commonwealth Document Law [Document Law], Pa.Stat.Ann. tit. 45, §§ 1101-1602 (Purdon Supp.Pamph. 1988),³ and it may not form the basis for Referee or Board decisions. It cannot, therefore, dictate the denial of benefits.

3 45 Pa.Stat.Ann. § 1102(12) defines a "regulation" as:
. . . any rule or regulation, or order in the nature of a rule or regulation, promulgated by an agency under statutory authority in the administration of any statute administered by or relating to the agency, or prescribing the practice or procedure before such agency.
45 Pa.Stat.Ann. § 1208 provides:
An administrative regulation or change therein promulgated after the effective date of this act shall not be valid for any purpose until filed by the Legislative Reference Bureau, as provided in section 409.
(footnotes omitted).
It is conceded that the document in question has neither been filed with the Legislative Reference Bureau nor has met the other requirements of the Document Law.

As we did in Lopata, we next consider whether the decision here may be upheld as a valid exercise of the Board's adjudicative function. This requires a determination of whether the Board's adjudication effectuates the legislative intent underlying the definition and application of "credit weeks" as a condition of eligibility. We are guided by the wisdom of Mr. Justice McDermott who, in Lopata, wrote:

We have previously articulated the legislative intent underlying financial eligibility requirements as being a means to demonstrate a claimant's genuine attachment to the work force. See generally Martin v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 502 Pa. 282, 466 A.2d 107 (1983). We have also consistently recognized the remedial nature of the Unemployment Compensation Law, and have striven to give its provisions broad and liberal construction. Renne v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, (Renne), 499 Pa. 299, 453 A.2d 318 (1982); Gladieux Food Services, Inc. v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 479 Pa. 324, 388 A.2d 678 (1978). Moreover, this Court has held that, absent a specific disqualification in the Law, a presumption of eligibility attaches to involuntarily unemployed claimants. Penn Hills School District v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, (Penn Hills), 496 Pa. 620, 437 A.2d 1213 (1981); Sturdevant v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 158 Pa. Super. 548, 45 A.2d 898 (1946).

507 Pa. at 576-577, 493 A.2d at 661.

Neither the Referee's determination, nor the affirmance thereof by the Board and the Commonwealth Court, effectuated the legislative intent underlying the definition and application of "credit week" as a condition of eligibility.⁴ Such a construction of the Act is neither broad nor liberal. See Lopata, 507 Pa. at 579, 493 A.2d at 662. Since the Act is remedial, so narrow a construction cannot stand. Moreover, there are only two statutory limitations in the definition of a "credit week." It must be a calendar week in which a claimant is paid in employment not less than fifty dollars and only one credit week can be established with respect to any one calendar week. There is nothing in the Act which directs that the allocation of credit weeks for vacation time depends on whether the vacation was scheduled or unscheduled.

4 The Commonwealth Court affirmed the Board's decision, in finding that Appellant did not preschedule any vacation time and that the pertinent Board regulation is found in 34 Pa. Code § 65.94. The regulation provides:
For purposes of this Subchapter, the term "vacation period" shall mean the following:
(1) A period designated or approved by the claimant's employer as his vacation.
(2) The period of any plant-wide or departmental closing for vacation except to the extent that the employer of the claimant has granted him a separate vacation period in substitution, in whole or in part, for the general shutdown.
(emphasis added). This regulation by its terms is applicable to Subchapter C of the Act which involves the allocation of vacation pay to arrive at a weekly rate of compensation and is not related to the determination of financial eligibility.

We hold, therefore, that for every week of vacation time, scheduled or unscheduled, earned during a base year, a "credit week" must be allocated. A contrary holding would not comport with reason, with the letter of the law, or with its underlying policy. See Pane v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 95 Pa. Commw. 40, 504 A.2d 958 (1986) (Applicability of an offset provision cannot properly be predicated upon when an employee schedules his or her vacations. Such result has the effect of needlessly penalizing certain employees and is impermissibly arbitrary.)

The Order of the Commonwealth Court is reversed and the case is remanded for the computation of benefits.

DISPOSITIONS OF PETITIONS FOR ALLOWANCE OF APPEAL 549 A.2d 131-139 Appeal from the Superior Court

Allocatur Disposition Lower Court Docket and Appeal Docket or Title Date Number Docket Citation

Addison v. United Services Auto. Ass'n .............. 8/18/88 971 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 626, (1987) 536 A.2d 819

Arcieri v. Nissenbaum 9/12/88 363 E.D. Denied No. 455 (1988) Philadelphia 1988

Armstrong, Appeal of . 9/19/88 093 M.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 661, (1988) 541 A.2d 1158

Austin J. Richards, Inc., Petition of .. 8/29/88 182 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 269, (1988) 538 A.2d 11

Austin J. Richards, Inc. v. McClafferty 8/29/88 182 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 269, (1988) 538 A.2d 11

Baldauff v. Baldauff . 9/7/88 35 W.D. Granted 374 Pa. Super. 636, (1988) (75 W.D. 538 A.2d 934 1988)

Belviso v. Belviso ... 9/7/88 85 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 636, (1988) 538 A.2d 934

Bemis v. Gumbeski .... 9/8/88 12 W.D. Denied 369 Pa. Super. 101, (1988) 534 A.2d 1099

Brandon v. S.T. Hudson Engineers, Inc ..... 8/29/88 347 E.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 647, (1988) 541 A.2d 1147

Brown v. Horgan ...... 8/29/88 216 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 647, (1988) 541 A.2d 1147

Burke v. Pope ........ 8/31/88 601 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 467, (1988) 543 A.2d 566

Burke v. Pope ........ 8/31/88 821 E.D. Denied 366 Pa. Super. 488, (1987) 531 A.2d 782

Christo v. Tuscany, Inc. ............... 9/8/88 558 W.D. Granted 368 Pa. Super. 9, (1987) (78 W.D. 533 A.2d 461 1988)

Claudio v. Dykes ..... 8/30/88 81 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 628, (1988) 536 A.2d 820

Coachman v. Energy Consultants, Inc. .. 9/6/88 218 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 665, (1988) 541 A.2d 1160

Com. v. Alward ....... 8/29/88 352 E.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 635, (1988) 541 A.2d 788

Com. v. Barbee ....... 8/5/88 205 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 648, (1988) 541 A.2d 1148

Com. v. Barksdale .... 8/30/88 169 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 648, (1988) 541 A.2d 1148

Com. v. Bartlebaugh .. 8/30/88 69 W.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 613, (1988) 541 A.2d 25

Com. v. Bartow ....... 7/29/88 042 M.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 613, (1988) 541 A.2d 25

Com. v. Becker ....... 8/16/88 993 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 629, (1987) 536 A.2d 821

Com. v. Bennett ...... 8/30/88 547 E.D. Denied No. 1091 (1985) Philadelphia 1983

Com. v. Benz ......... 8/18/88 572 W.D. Granted 373 Pa. Super. 629, (1987) (67 W.D. 536 A.2d 821 (1988)

Com. v. Benz ......... 8/18/88 574 W.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 629, (1987) 536 A.2d 821

Com. v. Benz ......... 8/18/88 574 W.D. Quashed 373 Pa. Super. 629, (1987) 536 A.2d 821

Com. v. Biggs ........ 9/19/88 586 W.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 629, (1987) 536 A.2d 821

Com. v. Brooks ....... 9/8/88 4 W.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 630, (1988) 536 A.2d 822

Com. v. Brown ........ 8/16/88 993 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 629, (1987) 536 A.2d 821

Com. v. Brozik ....... 8/24/88 578 W.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 631, (1987) 536 A.2d 822

Com. v. Buono ........ 8/18/88 232 E.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 637, (1988) 541 A.2d 790

Com. v. Centeno ...... 8/16/88 331 E.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 636, (1988) 541 A.2d 789

Com. v. Chaney ....... 9/22/88 018 M.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 639, (1988) 538 A.2d 937

Com. v. Chisholm ..... 9/12/88 416 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 644, (1988) 544 A.2d 1039

Com. v. Clark ........ 8/16/88 398 E.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 649, (1988) 541 A.2d 1149

Com. v. Cook ......... 9/6/88 100 M.D. Denied No. 617 (1988) Harrisburg 1986

Com. v. Davidson ..... 9/16/88 240 W.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 645, (1988) 544 A.2d 1040

Com. v. Davis ........ 9/12/88 224 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 649, (1988) 541 A.2d 1149

Com. v. DeSumma ...... 9/8/88 969 E.D. Granted 367 Pa. Super. 634, (1987) (124 E.D. 533 A.2d 453 1988)

Com. v. Dilts ........ 8/22/88 237 W.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 645, (1988) 544 A.2d 1040

Com. v. Dittenhafer .. 9/19/88 125 M.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. 645, (1988) 544 A.2d 1040

Com. v. Douglas ...... 8/30/88 91 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 640, (1988) 538 A.2d 937

Com. v. Fabec ........ 8/23/88 245 W.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 646, (1988) 544 A.2d 1040

Com. v. Flarkey ...... 9/22/88 121 M.D. Denied 99 Harrisburg (1988) 1988

Com. v. Frankenfield . 8/18/88 254 M.D. Denied 372 Pa. Super. 638, (1987) 534 A.2d 1118

Com. v. Frazier ...... 9/7/88 15 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 616, (1988) 541 A.2d 28

Com. v. Fresh ........ 9/19/88 295 W.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 646, (1988) 544 A.2d 1040

Com. v. Garrett ...... 9/29/88 280 M.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 633, (1987) 536 A.2d 824

Com. v. Gilliam ...... 8/30/88 55 W.D. Granted 374 Pa. Super. 641, (1988) (69 W.D. 538 A.2d 938 1988)

Com. v. Gonzalez ..... 9/19/88 59 M.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 616, (1988) 541 A.2d 28

Com. v. Gray ......... 9/2/88 465 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 646, (1988) 544 A.2d 1041

Com. v. Grimes ....... 8/16/88 944 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 634, (1987) 536 A.2d 824

Com. v. Grube ........ 8/30/88 101 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 634, (1988) 536 A.2d 824

Com. v. Hall ......... 8/29/88 134 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 333, (1988) 538 A.2d 43

Com. v. Hayman ....... 7/25/88 200 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 617, (1988) 541 A.2d 28

Com. v. Holden ....... 8/24/88 620 W.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 635, (1987) 536 A.2d 825

Com. v. Hopkins ...... 9/6/88 401 E.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 652, (1988) 541 A.2d 1151

Com. v. Howard ....... 7/25/88 184 E.D. Denied 362 Pa. Super. 636, (1988) 520 A.2d 1214

Com. v. Jones ........ 7/29/88 269 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 618, (1988) 541 A.2d 29

Com. v. Jones ........ 8/29/88 458 E.D. Denied 367 Pa. Super. 648, (1987) 528 A.2d 257

Com. v. Kendall ...... 8/31/88 498 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 648, (1988) 544 A.2d 1042

Com. v. Koprivnak .... 9/8/88 9 W.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 644, (1988) 538 A.2d 940

Com. v. Lutzman ...... 8/26/88 186 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 619, (1988) 541 A.2d 29

Com. v. Lyons ........ 9/8/88 220 M.D. Denied 366 Pa. Super. 172, (1987) 530 A.2d 1345

Com. v. McAleese ..... 8/18/88 872 E.D. Granted 371 Pa. Super. 645, (1987) (106 E.D. 534 A.2d 132 1988)

Com. v. McClure ...... 9/19/88 137 M.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 649, (1988) 544 A.2d 1043

Com. v. McLain ....... 9/19/88 180 W.D. Granted No. 584 Pittsburgh (1988) (79 W.D. 1987 (1988)

Com. v. Martinson .... 9/7/88 959 E.D. Granted 368 Pa. Super. 130, (1987) (123 E.D. 533 A.2d 750 1988)

Com. v. Miller ....... 9/12/88 421 E.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 654, (1988) 541 A.2d 1152

Com. v. Moore ........ 9/19/88 107 M.D. Denied 105 M.D. No. 2 (1988)

Com. v. Moore ........ 9/20/88 129 E.D. Granted 375 Pa. Super. 620, (1988) 126 E.D. 541 A.2d 30 (1988)

Com. v. Moyer ........ 8/16/88 993 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 629, (1987) 536 A.2d 821

Com. v. Myers ........ 7/25/88 229 E.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 640, (1988) 541 A.2d 792

Com. v. Novitski ..... 8/29/88 043 M.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 621, (1988) 541 A.2d 31

Com. v. Nygard ....... 8/29/88 355 E.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 654, (1988) 541 A.2d 1153

Com. v. Odem ......... 9/12/88 265 W.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 650, (1988) 544 A.2d 1043

Com. v. Patrick ...... 5/10/88 20 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 647, (1988) 538 A.2d 942

Com. v. Poindexter ... 8/29/88 366 E.D. Denied 372 Pa. Super. 566, (1988) 539 A.2d 1341

Com. v. Potter ....... 9/19/88 105 M.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 641, (1988) 541 A.2d 793

Com. v. Rashed ....... 7/11/88 335 E.D. Denied 366 Pa. Super. 641, (1987) 526 A.2d 1235

Com. v. Raspatello ... 9/12/88 242 W.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 651, (1988) 544 A.2d 1044

Com. v. Romansky ..... 5/12/88 136 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 623, (1988) 541 A.2d 32

Com. v. Rowley ....... 9/6/88 253 W.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 651, (1988) 544 A.2d 1044

Com. v. Salem ........ 9/6/88 111 M.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 642, (1988) 541 A.2d 793

Com. v. Salmon ....... 9/20/88 106 W.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 623, (1988) 541 A.2d 33

Com. v. Sawyer ....... 9/8/88 601 W.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 639, (1987) 536 A.2d 828

Com. v. Scovers ...... 9/12/88 385 E.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 656, (1988) 541 A.2d 1154

Com. v. Seim ......... 8/31/88 128 M.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 652, (1988) 544 A.2d 1045

Com. v. Simpkins ..... 8/16/88 354 E.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 656, (1988) 541 A.2d 1154

Com. v. Sitler ....... 8/29/88 048 M.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 624, (1988) 541 A.2d 33

Com. v. Smith ........ 9/12/88 466 E.D. Denied No. 168 (1988) Philadelphia 1988

Com. v. Speelman ..... 8/29/88 082 M.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 643, (1988) 541 A.2d 794

Com. v. Stein ........ 8/29/88 112 E.D. Denied 369 Pa. Super. 409, (1988) 535 A.2d 616

Com. v. Tallent ...... 8/18/88 137 M.D. Denied 368 Pa. Super. 644, (1987) 531 A.2d 35

Com. v. Taylor ....... 8/18/88 184 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 657, (1988) 541 A.2d 1155

Com. v. Terry ........ 9/12/88 244 W.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 653, (1988) 544 A.2d 1045

Com. v. Travaglia .... 8/30/88 189 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 658, (1988) 541 A.2d 1155

Com. v. Vaughn ....... 8/19/88 305 E.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 644, (1988) 541 A.2d 794

Com. v. Wallace ...... 9/21/88 133 M.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 653, (1988) 544 A.2d 1046

Com. v. Washington ... 8/8/88 15 W.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 651, (1988) 538 A.2d 945

Com. v. Weber ........ 8/24/88 22 W.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 651, (1988) 538 A.2d 946

Com. v. Wilson ....... 8/24/88 72 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 651, (1988) 538 A.2d 946

Com. v. Wofford ...... 9/8/88 21 W.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 651, (1988) 538 A.2d 946

Com. v. Woods ........ 9/12/88 325 E.D. Denied No. 843 (1988) Philadelphia 1986

Com. v. Woodward ..... 8/31/88 016 E.D. Denied 368 Pa. Super. 363, (1988) 534 A.2d 478

Deutsch v. Deitsch ... 8/23/88 583 W.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 642, (1987) 536 A.2d 831

Doyle by Doyle v. Valois ............. 9/9/88 598 E.D. Denied No. 1008 (1987) Philadelphia 1987

Eberenz v. Com........ 8/16/88 288 E.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 637, (1988) 541 A.2d 790

Engle v. Cassell ..... 5/3/88 595 E.D. Denied No. 1838 (1987) Philadelphia 1987

Fierst v. Commonwealth Land Title Ins. Co.. 9/13/88 53 W.D. Denied 369 Pa. Super. 355, (1988) 535 A.2d 196

Folino v. Young ...... 9/22/88 47 E.D. Granted 368 Pa. Super. 220, (1988) (130 E.D. 533 A.2d 1034 1988)

Fox Chapel Mews, Inc., Petition of ........ 9/8/88 190 W.D. Denied 365 Pa. Super. 650, (1987) 526 A.2d 818

Fox Chapel Mews, Inc. v. Simons .......... 9/8/88 190 W.D. Denied 365 Pa. Super. 650, (1987) 526 A.2d 818

Fox Chapel Mews Ass'n v. Fox Chapel Mews, Inc. ............... 9/8/88 190 W.D. Denied 365 Pa. Super. 650, (1987) 526 A.2d 818

Gardner v. State Farm Ins. Co ....... 6/22/88 984 E.D. Denied^_ 372 Pa. Super. 644

_ Supplemental Petition for Allowance of Appeal denied 6/22/88

(1987) 534 A.2d 1122

Gestewitz v. Shope ... 8/23/88 006 E.D. Denied No. 137 (1988) Philadelphia 1987

Ginader, Brojack, Jones Co. v. Continental Cas. Co 8/16/88 199 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 628, (1988) 541 A.2d 36

Goodge, Petition of .. 8/23/88 261 W.D. Denied 372 Pa. Super. 343, (1988) 539 A.2d 826

Graham v. Helwig ..... 9/12/88 099 M.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 660, (1988) 541 A.2d 1157

Hamerly v. Wagner .... 5/5/88 49 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 643, (1988) 536 A.2d 831

Hill v. Williamson ... 9/19/88 282 W.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 655, (1988) 544 A.2d 1047

Houston v. H.J. Tanner, Inc. ....... 9/27/88 080 M.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 399, (1988) 538 A.2d 502

Hummel/Huenerberg v. Com. of Pa., Dept. of Trans ........... 8/18/88 019 M.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 628, (1988) 541 A.2d 36

Hummel/Huenerberg v. Sacks .............. 8/18/88 019 M.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 628, (1988) 541 A.2d 36

Industrial Valley Bank and Trust Co. v. Howard .......... 8/16/88 1017 E.D. Denied 368 Pa. Super. 263, (1987) 533 A.2d 1055

Iorfida v. Mary Robert Realty Co., Inc................. 8/30/88 372 E.D. Denied 372 Pa. Super. 170, (1988) 539 A.2d 383

Keith-Henes v. Henes . 8/23/88 996 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 645, (1987) 536 A.2d 832

Kershbaumer v. Stricek ............ 8/30/88 200 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 662, (1988) 541 A.2d 1158

Kolbe v. Aegis Ins. Co ................. 8/29/88 160 W.D. Denied 370 Pa. Super. 539, (1988) 537 A.2d 7

Kreuger v. Mears ..... 8/16/88 174 W.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 648, (1988) 541 A.2d 797

Laird v. Moran ....... 8/23/88 580 W.D. Denied 365 Pa. Super. 95, (1987) 528 A.2d 1379

Lal v. Dorsey ........ 9/6/88 387 E.D. Denied No. 136 (1988) Philadelphia 1988

LeFevre v. LeFevre ... 9/12/88 123 M.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 656, (1988) 544 A.2d 1048

Leofsky v. Wawa, Inc.. 8/23/88 920 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 645, (1987) 536 A.2d 832

McClafferty v. Nernberg ........... 8/29/88 182 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 269, (1988) 538 A.2d 11

McDonough v. Berkshire Agency, Inc......... 9/12/88 368 E.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 663, (1988) 541 A.2d 1159

Mirth v. Wannisky .... 8/12/88 289 E.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 648, (1988) 541 A.2d 798

Nernberg v. Davis .... 8/29/88 182 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 269, (1988) 538 A.2d 11

Nutz, Petition of .... 9/6/88 218 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 665, (1988) 541 A.2d 1160

Painter v. Pennsylvania Elec. Co............ 9/9/88 582 W.D. Denied 368 Pa. Super. 334, (1987) 534 A.2d 110

Phenneger v. Allison . 8/16/88 117 M.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 657, (1988) 544 A.2d 1048

Quinn, In re Estate of .......... 9/19/88 093 M.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 661, (1988) 541 A.2d 1158

R.A. Burkholder, Inc. v. Schlenbaker ........ 9/29/88 020 M.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 950, (1988) 538 A.2d 950

Reilly v. Stroehmann Bros. Co. .......... 9/22/88 534 W.D. Granted 367 Pa. Super. 411, (1987) (80 W.D. 532 A.2d 1988) 1212

Schur v. Snyder ...... 9/2/88 522 W.D. Denied 372 Pa. Super. 646, (1987) 534 A.2d 1123

Sheetz v. Allen ...... 8/17/88 236 E.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 649, (1988) 541 A.2d 799

Sherman v. Forest Home Systems, Inc. . 8/18/88 091 M.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 649, (1988) 541 A.2d 799

Simmons v. St. Clair Memorial Hosp. ..... 8/24/88 28 W.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 658, (1988) 538 A.2d 950

Simons v. Cost Bros., Inc. .............. 9/8/88 190 W.D. Denied 365 Pa. Super. 650, (1987) 526 A.2d 818

Smith v. Barker ...... 9/13/88 25 E.D. Denied 368 Pa. Super. 472, (1988) 534 A.2d 533

S.N.T. Industries, Inc. v. Geanopulos ......... 9/7/88 286 W.D. Denied 363 Pa. Super. 97, (1987) 525 A.2d 736

Snyder, Petition of ................. 9/2/88 522 W.D. Denied 372 Pa. Super. 646, (1987) 534 A.2d 1123

Soxman v. Goodge ..... 8/23/88 261 W.D. Denied 372 Pa. Super. 343, (1988) 539 A.2d 826

Spang Industries Inc., In re ........ 9/13/88 72 W.D. Denied 363 Pa. Super. 646, (1988) 522 A.2d 665 Spang Industries Inc., Petition of ................. 9/13/88 72 W.D. Denied 363 Pa. Super. 646, (1988) 522 A.2d 665

Stover by Stover v. Kremer ............. 9/2/88 144 W.D. Granted 375 Pa. Super. 631, (1988) (76 W.D. 541 A.2d 38 1988)

Stricek, Petition of ................. 8/30/88 200 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 662, (1988) 541 A.2d 1158

Tassey v. Tassey ..... 8/31/88 495 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 658, (1988) 544 A.2d 1049

Taylor v. Taylor ..... 5/2/88 547 W.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 648, (1987) 536 A.2d 834

Torres v. Com. ....... 9/7/88 298 E.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 643, (1988) 541 A.2d 794

Trace v. Gestewitz ... 8/23/88 006 E.D. Denied No. 137 (1988) Philadelphia 1987

Valois, Petition of ................. 9/9/88 598 E.D. Denied No. 1008 (1987) Philadelphia 1987

Verner v. Coachman ... 9/6/88 218 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 655, (1988) 541 A.2d 1160

Wannisky, Petition of ................. 8/12/88 289 E.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 648, (1988) 541 A.2d 798

Wannisky v. Hathaway Homes, Inc. ........ 8/12/88 289 E.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 648, (1988) 541 A.2d 798

White v. Southeastern Pennsylvania Transp. Authority .......... 9/8/88 853 E.D. Denied 366 Pa. Super. 16, (1987) 530 A.2d 870

Young, Petition of ................. 9/22/88 47 E.D. Granted 368 Pa. Super. 220, (1988) (130 E.D. 533 A.2d 1034 1988)

Appeal from the Commonwealth Court

Allocatur Disposition Lower Court Docket and Appeal Docket or Title Date Number Docket Citation

Benoff v. Zoning Bd. of Adjustment of City of Philadelphia ....... 8/29/88 285 E.D. Denied No. 3556 C.D. 1986 (1988)

Com. v. Croissant .... 9/16/88 227 W.D. Denied 539 A.2d 492 (1988)

Com. Dept. of Revenue, Petition of ........ 8/30/88 202 W.D. Denied 112 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 173, 535 A.2d 255

Connecticut General Life Ins. v. Chartiers Valley School Dist. ....... 9/2/88 39 W.D. Denied 110 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 171, 532 A.2d 41

Connecticut General Life Ins. Co. v. Chartiers Valley School Dist. ....... 9/2/88 37 W.D. Granted 110 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (74 W.D. 171, 1988) 532 A.2d 41

Dallap v. Sharon City School Dist. .............. 9/12/88 323 W.D. Denied 105 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 346, 524 A.2d 546

Danwell Corp. v. Zoning Hearing Bd. of Plymouth Tp. .... 8/18/88 947 E.D. Denied 108 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 531, 529 A.2d 1215

DeStefino, Petition of ................. 9/19/88 286 W.D. Denied 537 A.2d 926 (1988)

Equi v. Board of Educ. of School Dist. of Philadelphia ....... 8/23/88 878 E.D. Denied 109 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 264, 530 A.2d 1044

Faggins-Epps v. Township of Middletown ......... 9/8/88 42 E.D. Denied No. 808 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Fiorillo v. Tunis .... 9/12/88 431 E.D. Denied No. 1371 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Fritchman v. Com., Unemployment Compensation Bd. of Review ............. 9/12/88 102 M.D. Denied 112 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 394, 535 A.2d 716

G.A. F.C. Wagman, Inc. v. Manchester Twp. ............... 8/29/88 026 M.D. Denied 112 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 357, 535 A.2d 702

Galdieri v. Duffy .... 8/29/88 290 E.D. Denied No. 105 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Hatt v. W.C.A.B. ..... 9/6/88 371 E.D. Denied No. 1224 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Herpak, Petition of ................. 9/22/88 29 W.D. Granted No. 1038 C.D. 1986 (1988) (81 W.D. 1988)

Ira S. Davis, Inc. v. W.C.A.B. (Richardson) ....... 8/1/88 254 E.D. Denied No. 3531 C.D. 1986 (1988)

Kuhl v. Board of Sup'rs of Greene Tp. ................ 9/16/88 238 W.D. Denied 112 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 624, 536 A.2d 836

Labar v. Com. Dept. of Transp. Bur. of Traffic Safety ..... 8/29/88 248 E.D. Denied No. 63 T.D. 1986 (1988) Lubovinsky v. Pa. Unemp. Compensation Bd. of Review ...... 9/19/88 506 W.D. Denied No. 2237 C.D. 1987 (1987)

Manolakos, In re Estate of .......... 8/30/88 202 W.D. Denied 112 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 173, 535 A.2d 255

Metropolitan Property and Liability Ins. Co. v. Insurance Com'r of Com. of Pa. ................ 8/1/88 201 E.D. Granted 537 A.2d 53 (1988) (98 E.D. 1988)

Miller v. W.C.A.B. (Pocono Hosp.) ..... 8/19/88 375 E.D. Denied 539 A.2d 18 (1988)

Northwood Nursing and Convalescent Home, Inc., v. Commonwealth Dept. of Public Welfare ............ 9/22/88 41 E.D. Granted 110 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (128 E.D. 40, 1988) 531 A.2d 873

Shadyside Action Coalition v. Zoning Bd. of Adjustment of City of Pgh. ............... 9/19/88 286 W.D. Denied 537 A.2d 926 (1988)

Shaler Area School Dist. v. Elmendorf .......... 8/24/88 614 W.D. Denied No. 288 C.D. 1986 (1987)

Smith v. W.C.A.B. (Jerry's Diamond Market) ............ 9/9/88 233 W.D. Denied No. 1188 C.D. 1987 (1988)

South Whitehall Tp. Police Service v. South Whitehall Tp. ................ 9/20/88 121 E.D. Granted 112 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (125 E.D. 223, 1988) 535 A.2d 276

Staffieri v. W.C.A.B. (Rorer) ............ 8/18/88 945 E.D. Denied 110 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 642, 532 A.2d 1283

Stop-Go-Food Stores v. W.C.A. Bd. (Herpak) ........... 9/22/88 29 W.D. Granted No. 1038 C.D. 1986 (1988) (81 W.D. 1988)

Tirotta v. Zoning Hearing Bd. of Borough of Yeadon ............. 8/23/88 922 E.D. Denied 110 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 501, 532 A.2d 937

DISPOSITIONS OF PETITIONS FOR ALLOWANCE OF APPEAL 549 A.2d 914-917 Appeal from the Superior Court

Allocatur Disposition Lower Court Docket and Appeal Docket or Title Date Number Docket Citation

Children and Youth Services of Allegheny County, Petition of ....... 10/13/88 110 W.D. Granted 375 Pa. Super. 628, (1988) (87 W.D. 541 A.2d 36 1988)

Collier v. Hackman ... 9/19/88 31 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 628, (1988) 536 A.2d 820

Com. v. Anderson ..... 9/26/88 155 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 613, (1988) 541 A.2d 25

Com. v. Bazabe ...... 10/17/88 154 M.D. Denied 379 Pa. Super. 654, (1988) 545 A.2d 380

Com. v. Blackburn .... 9/21/88 123 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 614, (1988) 541 A.2d 26

Com. v. Brown ........ 9/19/88 8 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 631, (1988) 536 A.2d 822

Com. v. Carr ........ 10/19/88 140 M.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 644, (1988) 544 A.2d 1039

Com. v. Chin ......... 9/16/88 480 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 163, (1988) 540 A.2d 573

Com. v. Christmas .... 9/29/88 151 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 639, (1988) 538 A.2d 937

Com. v. Cohen ........ 10/5/88 72 M.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 558, (1988) 538 A.2d 582

Com. v. Conway ....... 9/22/88 111 E.D. Denied 368 Pa. Super. 488, (1988) 534 A.2d 541

Com. v. Cubbage ...... 9/21/88 501 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 645, (1988) 544 A.2d 1039

Com. v. Curran ...... 10/12/88 71 M.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 637, (1988) 541 A.2d 789

Com. v. Davenport .... 10/5/88 085 M.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 649, (1988) 541 A.2d 1149

Com. v. Eyer ........ 10/19/88 109 M.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 646, (1988) 544 A.2d 1040

Com. v. Garner ....... 9/23/88 335 E.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 408, (1988) 538 A.2d 506

Com. v. Griffiths ... 10/18/88 045 M.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 617, (1988) 541 A.2d 28

Com. v. Harris ....... 9/29/88 5 W.D. Denied 368 Pa. Super. 84, (1988) 533 A.2d 727

Com. v. Hawkins ...... 9/19/88 165 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 617, (1988) 541 A.2d 28

Com. v. Hill ......... 10/5/88 272 W.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 647, (1988) 544 A.2d 1041

Com. v. Jones ........ 9/19/88 103 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 643, (1988) 538 A.2d 940

Com. v. Klinger ..... 10/18/88 50 M.D. Denied 369 Pa. Super. 526, (1988) 535 A.2d 1060

Com. v. Lopez ....... 10/20/88 482 E.D. Granted 378 Pa. Super. 648, (1988) (141 E.D. 544 A.2d 1042 1988)

Com. v. McNally ...... 9/29/88 65 W.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 646, (1988) 538 A.2d 941

Com. v. McNally ...... 9/29/88 66 W.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 646, (1988) 538 A.2d 941

Com. v. McNeely ...... 9/29/88 82 E.D. Denied 368 Pa. Super. 517, (1988) 534 A.2d 778

Com. v. Molosky ...... 9/20/88 118 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 646, (1988) 538 A.2d 942

Com. v. Powell ....... 9/19/88 281 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 622, (1988) 541 A.2d 32

Com. v. Prado ........ 9/16/88 432 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 651, (1988) 544 A.2d 1044

Com. v. Quick ........ 9/29/88 68 W.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 622, (1988) 541 A.2d 32

Com. v. Ramirez ...... 9/19/88 168 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 622, (1988) 541 A.2d 32

Com. v. Reddick ...... 10/6/88 081 M.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 641, (1988) 541 A.2d 793

Com. v. Reese ........ 10/4/88 1005 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 648, (1987) 538 A.2d 943

Com. v. Romanelli .... 9/20/88 182 E.D. Denied 331 Pa. Super. 615, (1988) 479 A.2d 1147

Com. v. Steltz ....... 10/4/88 203 E.D. Granted 376 Pa. Super. 643, (1988) (138 E.D. 541 A.2d 794 1988)

Com. v. Thompson ..... 9/19/88 180 E.D. Denied No. 2011 (1988) Philadelphia 1986

Com. v. Woods ........ 9/29/88 567 W.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 642, (1987) 536 A.2d 830

Com. v. Yacoubian .... 9/20/88 106 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 652, (1988) 538 A.2d 946

Com. v. Zelinka ...... 9/29/88 75 W.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 627, (1988) 541 A.2d 35

Dixon v. Aircomo Corp. .............. 9/26/88 161 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 652, (1988) 538 A.2d 947

Dumé v. Elkcom Co., Inc. .......... 9/29/88 615 W.D. Denied 368 Pa. Super. 280, (1987) 533 A.2d 1063

Ferko v. Spisak ..... 10/17/88 284 W.D. Granted 373 Pa. Super. 303, (1988) (86 W.D. 541 A.2d 327 1988)

Gestewitz v. Shope ... 9/22/88 5 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 649, (1988) 536 A.2d 835

Goldsworthy v. Apple Tours .............. 9/29/88 65 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 653, (1988) 538 A.2d 947

Johnson, Petition of ................ 10/18/88 143 E.D. Granted 369 Pa. Super. 377, (1988) (142 E.D. 535 A.2d 207 1988)

Johnson v. Johnson .. 10/18/88 096 M.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 647, (1988) 541 A.2d 797

Litton Systems, Inc. v. Goodyear Tire and Rubber Co. ................ 9/26/88 445 E.D. Denied 372 Pa. Super. 123, (1988) 539 A.2d 360

M.L.S., In re ....... 10/13/88 110 W.D. Granted 375 Pa. Super. 628 (1988) (87 W.D. 541 A.2d 36 1988)

Ryan v. Johnson ..... 10/18/88 143 E.D. Granted 369 Pa. Super. 377, (1988) (142 E.D. 535 A.2d 207 1988)

Schaffer v. Litton Systems, Inc. ...... 9/26/88 445 E.D. Denied 372 Pa. Super. 123, (1988) 539 A.2d 360

Tolbert v. Cosey .... 10/19/88 130 M.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 659, (1988) 544 A.2d 1049

Verdi v. Magee-Womens Hosp .............. 10/13/88 259 W.D. Granted Nos. 1532, 1533 (1988) (84 W.D. Pittsburgh 1987 1988)

Witmer v. Gestewitz .......... 9/22/88 5 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 649, (1988) 536 A.2d 835

Appeal from the Commonwealth Court

Allocatur Disposition Lower Court Docket and Appeal Docket or Title Date Number Docket Citation

Arta, Inc. v. Ryan Corp. .............. 9/29/88 2 E.D. Denied 110 Pa. Commw. 1, (1988) 531 A.2d 857

Bennett, Petition of ................. 10/4/88 549 W.D. Denied 110 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 566, 532 A.2d 1252

City of Philadelphia, Petition of ........ 9/29/88 2 E.D. Denied 110 Pa. Commw. 1, (1988) 531 A.2d 857

Com. v. Lajevic ...... 10/6/88 243 W.D. Denied No. 324 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Com., Dept. of Environmental Resources v. Blosenski Disposal Service ........... 10/18/88 57 E.D. Granted 110 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (139 E.D. 194, 1988) 532 A.2d 497

Cooper Energy Services v. W.C.A.B. (Toth) ............. 10/5/88 108 W.D. Denied 536 A.2d 519 (1988)

Fenell v. Com., Pa. Bd. of Probation Parole .......... 10/18/88 162 M.D. Denied No. 984 C.D. 1988 (1988)

Gaitens v. Borough of Crafton ............ 9/29/88 42 W.D. Denied 112 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 147, 534 A.2d 1149 Hilton v. Com., Bd. of Probation Parole ............. 9/19/88 240 E.D. Denied No. 406 M.D. 4 (1988)

Kahle, Appeal of ..... 10/7/88 85 W.D. Granted 112 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (85 W.D. 402, 1988) 535 A.2d 304

Kahle, Petition of ... 10/7/88 85 W.D. Granted 112 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (85 W.D. 402, 1988) 535 A.2d 304

Kuber v. W.C.A.B. .... 10/3/88 271 E.D. Denied No. 665 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Michaelson v. Com., Unemployment Compensation Bd. of Review ............. 9/26/88 211 E.D. Denied No. 366 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Philipose v. M. Cardone Industries, Inc ................ 9/19/88 408 E.D. Denied No. 193 C.D. 1988 (1988)

Stofflet v. W.C.A.B. ........... 9/16/88 402 E.D. Denied No. 508 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Visionquest Nat., Ltd. v. Board of Sup'rs of Honey Brook Tp. Chester County ..... 10/5/88 526 E.D. Granted 540 A.2d 995 (1988) (137 E.D. 1988)

Westmoreland County Tax Claim Bureau, Ritz, Inc., In re ........ 10/4/88 549 W.D. Denied 110 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 566, 532 A.2d 1252

SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA DISPOSITIONS OF PETITIONS FOR ALLOWANCE OF APPEAL 551 A.2d 213-218 Appeal from the Superior Court

Allocatur Disposition Lower Court Docket and Appeal Docket or Title Date Number Docket Citation

Alumni Assoc. v. Sullivan .......... 10/27/88 011 M.D. Granted 369 Pa. Super. 596, (1988) (45 M.D. 535 A.2d 1095 1988)

Beary v. Container General Corp. ..... 10/24/88 618 W.D. Denied 368 Pa. Super. 61, (1987) 533 A.2d 716

Cervone, Petition of 10/19/88 179 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 279, (1988) 538 A.2d 16

Cervone v. Reading .. 10/19/88 179 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 279, (1988) 538 A.2d 16

Cervone v. Reading .. 10/19/88 186 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 279, (1988) 538 A.2d 16

Com. v. Atkinson .... 10/24/88 345 W.D. Denied 364 Pa. Super. 384, (1987) 528 A.2d 210

Com. v. Ball ........ 10/17/88 565 E.D. Granted 378 Pa. Super. 643, (1988) (145 E.D. 544 A.2d 1038 1988)

Com. v. Becker ...... 10/24/88 507 W.D. Denied 366 Pa. Super. 54, (1987) 530 A.2d 888

Com. v. Charles ..... 10/11/88 295 E.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 636, (1988) 541 A.2d 789

Com. v. Colozzi ...... 9/26/88 477 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 644, (1988) 544 A.2d 1039

Com. v. Crawford ..... 9/26/88 146 W.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 637, (1988) 541 A.2d 789

Com. v. Delong ....... 11/2/88 064 M.D. Granted 375 Pa. Super. 615, (1988) (46 M.D. 541 A.2d 27 1988)

Com. v. Edkin ........ 11/9/88 084 M.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 650, (1988) 541 A.2d 1150

Com. v. Ferguson ..... 9/22/88 193 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 651, (1988) 541 A.2d 1150

Com. v. Frame ....... 10/17/88 292 W.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 646, (1988) 544 A.2d 1040

Com. v. Gambal ...... 10/17/88 998 E.D. Granted 373 Pa. Super. 633, (1987) (146 E.D. 536 A.2d 824 1988)

Com. v. Giles ....... 10/18/88 82 W.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 616, (1988) 541 A.2d 28

Com. v. Gregory ..... 10/17/88 188 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 551, (1988) 538 A.2d 578

Com. v. Hebel ....... 11/10/88 151 M.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 652, (1988) 541 A.2d 1151

Com. v. Henry ....... 10/18/88 190 W.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 638, (1988) 541 A.2d 791

Com. v. Hollingsworth ..... 10/18/88 681 E.D. Granted No. 21 (1987) (148 E.D. Philadelphia 1987 1988)

Com. v. Hovis ........ 10/5/88 555 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 647, (1988) 544 A.2d 1041

Com. v. Jerry ....... 10/13/88 357 W.D. Denied 380 Pa. Super. 647, (1988) 547 A.2d 437

Com. v. Johns ........ 9/29/88 83 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 643, (1988) 538 A.2d 940

Com. v. Johnson ...... 9/29/88 23 E.D. Denied 368 Pa. Super. 427, (1988) 534 A.2d 511

Com. v. Kiser ....... 10/18/88 61 W.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 644, (1988) 538 A.2d 940

Com. v. Koger ........ 10/5/88 542 E.D. Denied 379 Pa. Super. 660, (1988) 545 A.2d 385

Com. v. Krovich ..... 11/10/88 190 M.D. Denied 380 Pa. Super. 647, (1988) 547 A.2d 438

Com. v. Mahaney ...... 10/5/88 472 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 129, (1988) 540 A.2d 556

Com. v. Marshall ..... 9/21/88 89 W.D. Denied 364 Pa. Super. 647, (1988) 525 A.2d 817

Com. v. Martin ....... 11/9/88 156 M.D. Denied 379 Pa. Super. 661, (1988) 545 A.2d 386

Com. v. Martin ....... 11/9/88 157 M.D. Denied 379 Pa. Super. 661, (1988) 545 A.2d 386

Com. v. Mikesell .... 10/18/88 129 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 209, (1988) 537 A.2d 1372

Com. v. Miller ....... 9/20/88 061 M.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 637, (1988) 536 A.2d 826

Com. v. Mosley ....... 11/9/88 046 M.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 620, (1988) 541 A.2d 31

Com. v. Pastorkovic . 10/18/88 88 W.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 621, (1988) 541 A.2d 31

Com. v. Payne ....... 10/31/88 355 W.D. Denied 380 Pa. Super. 650, (1988) 547 A.2d 439

Com. v. Phillips .... 10/18/88 122 W.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 641, (1988) 541 A.2d 792

Com. v. Reiter ....... 11/2/88 074 M.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 641, (1988) 541 A.2d 793

Com. v. Sanchez ..... 10/20/88 357 E.D. Granted 372 Pa. Super. 369, (1988) (147 E.D. 539 A.2d 840 1988)

Com. v. Shablin ...... 9/16/88 447 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 652, (1988) 544 A.2d 1045

Com. v. Shields ..... 10/21/88 358 W.D. Denied 379 Pa. Super. 665, (1988) 545 A.2d 388

Com. v. Smith ....... 10/31/88 377 W.D. Denied 380 Pa. Super. 652, (1988) 547 A.2d 441

Com. v. Stine ........ 9/15/88 113 M.D. Denied 372 Pa. Super. 312, (1988) 539 A.2d 454

Com. v. Suber ........ 5/18/88 899 E.D. Denied 372 Pa. Super. 642, (1987) 534 A.2d 1121

Com. v. Sye .......... 11/9/88 110 M.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 657, (1988) 541 A.2d 1155

Com. v. Taylor ...... 10/18/88 370 W.D. Denied 379 Pa. Super. 666, (1988) 545 A.2d 389

Com. v. Thomas ...... 10/19/88 258 W.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 653, (1988) 544 A.2d 1045

Com. v. Wagner ....... 9/29/88 334 W.D. Granted 368 Pa. Super. 644, (1987) (82 W.D. 531 A.2d 36 1988)

Com. v. Wheeler ..... 10/18/88 67 W.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 626, (1988) 541 A.2d 34

Com. v. White ....... 10/18/88 121 W.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 626, (1988) 541 A.2d 34

Com. v. Williams ..... 9/22/88 116 W.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 626, (1988) 541 A.2d 35

Com. v. Williams .... 10/21/88 343 W.D. Denied 379 Pa. Super. 666, (1988) 545 A.2d 390

Coyle v. Richardson-Merrell, Inc. .............. 10/17/88 340 E.D. Granted 372 Pa. Super. 118, (1988) (144 E.D. 538 A.2d 1379 1988)

Dellobuono v. Com. ... 9/29/88 98 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 640, (1988) 538 A.2d 937

Driscoll v. Carpenters Dist. Council of Western Pa. ........ 11/2/88 79 W.D. Granted 370 Pa. Super. 295, (1988) (94 W.D. 536 A.2d 412 1988)

Duncan v. Jennings ... 9/29/88 37 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 643, (1988) 536 A.2d 831

Fitch v. Fitch ...... 10/19/88 255 W.D. Denied No. 1763 (1988) Pittsburgh 1987

Flook, In re Estate of ................ 10/31/88 037 M.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 628, (1988) 541 A.2d 36

Freed v. Freed ...... 10/31/88 112 M.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 655, (1988) 544 A.2d 1047

Giampolo v. Nettrour . 11/1/88 289 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 660, (1988) 541 A.2d 1157

Hoyler, Appeal of ... 10/31/88 037 M.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 628, (1988) 541 A.2d 36

Joyce Associates v. Pivirotto ......... 10/31/88 318 W.D. Denied 379 Pa. Super. 669, (1988) 545 A.2d 392

Kim v. Gillotti ..... 10/21/88 359 W.D. Denied 380 Pa. Super. 656, (1988) 547 A.2d 444

McDaniel v. Merck, Sharp Dohme ..... 10/24/88 594 W.D. Denied 367 Pa. Super. 600, (1987) 533 A.2d 436

McGovern, In re ...... 10/4/88 140 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 654, (1988) 538 A.2d 948

Mammolite v. Mercy Hosp. ............. 10/18/88 64 W.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 655, (1988) 538 A.2d 949

Merck, Sharp Dohme, Petition of ....... 10/24/88 594 W.D. Denied 367 Pa. Super. 600, (1987) 533 A.2d 436

Mercy Hosp. v. Hershey ........... 10/18/88 64 W.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 655, (1988) 538 A.2d 949

Nernberg Laffey, P.C., Petition of .. 9/22/88 231 W.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. ___, (1988) 541 A.2d 1159

Nettrour, Petition of 11/1/88 289 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 660, (1988) 541 A.2d 1157

Newman v. Stoecklein . 10/19/88 148 W.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 649, (1988) 541 A.2d 798

Nitkiewicz v. Nitkiewicz ......... 9/21/88 74 W.D. Denied 369 Pa. Super. 504, (1988) 535 A.2d 664

Piazza v. Yamato Japanese Restaurant, Inc. ............... 10/7/88 60 E.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 647, (1988) 536 A.2d 834

Reading v. Cervone .. 10/19/88 186 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 279, (1988) 538 A.2d 16

Rental Car Resources, Inc. v. Pennsylvania Ins. Guar. Ass'n on Behalf of Tabas Enterprises ........ 9/29/88 78 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 657, (1988) 538 A.2d 950

Robar Development Corp. v. Bambery ... 9/22/88 228 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 664, (1988) 541 A.2d 1159

Robar Development Corp. v. Bambery ... 9/22/88 231 W.D. Denied No. 670 Pittsburgh (1988) 1987

Robertson v. Atlantic Richfield Petroleum Products ........... 9/26/88 136 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 49, (1988) 537 A.2d 814

Schwarz v. Thompson . 10/18/88 175 W.D. Denied No. 53 Pittsburgh (1988) 1988

Shaffer v. Kania .... 10/13/88 325 W.D. Denied 216 M.D. 1988 (1988)

Siers v. Hoke ....... 10/20/88 160 M.D. Denied 379 Pa. Super. 671, (1988) 545 A.2d 393

Snyder v. Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. ..... 10/20/88 147 M.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 294, (1988) 541 A.2d 19

Specter Buchwach, P.C. v. Karlin and Fleisher .......... 10/18/88 268 W.D. Denied 210 M.D. 1988 (1988)

Sullivan v. Kappa Chapter of Sigma Chi Fraternity ........ 10/27/88 011 M.D. Granted 369 Pa. Super. 596, (1988) (45 M.D. 535 A.2d 1095 1988)

Thompson v. Royal Ins. 3/1/88 271 E.D. Denied 361 Pa. Super. 78, (1987) 521 A.2d 936

Unterberger, Appeal of ................ 10/27/88 011 M.D. Granted 369 Pa. Super. 596, (1988) (45 M.D. 535 A.2d 1095 1988)

Wolgemuth v. Harleysville Ins. Co. ................ 11/9/88 25 M.D. Denied 370 Pa.Super. 51, (1988) 535 A.2d 1145

Wunder, Appeal of .... 10/4/88 140 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 948, (1988) 538 A.2d 948

Appeal from the Commonwealth Court

Allocatur Disposition Lower Court Docket and Appeal Docket or Title Date Number Docket Citation

Bechtel Power Corp. v. W.C.A.B. (Casey) ............ 10/3/88 487 E.D. Denied 115 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 374, 540 A.2d 10

Charter Hosp. of Bucks County v. Com., Dept. of Health .... 11/2/88 004 M.D. Denied 111 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 576, 534 A.2d 1125

Com. v. Fee^_ ......... 6/20/88 Denied 540 A.2d 1385 (01 W.D. 1988)

_ Reconsideration Granted October 6, 1988.

Com. v. Kelly ........ 11/2/88 101 W.D. Granted 113 Pa. Commw. 1, (1988) (93 W.D. 536 A.2d 465 1988)

Com. v. Meucci ...... 10/21/88 339 W.D. Denied No. 152 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Com., Dept. of Environmental Resources v. Fetterolf Min., Inc. ........ 10/17/88 167 W.D. Denied 112 Pa. Commw. 1, (1988) 534 A.2d 1130

Com., Dept. of Environmental Resources v. Fetterolf Min., Inc. .............. 10/17/88 171 W.D. Denied 112 Pa. Commw. 1, (1988) 534 A.2d 1130

Culp, Petition of .... 9/17/87 363 E.D. Denied 102 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 200, 517 A.2d 1012

Culp v. East Rockhill Tp. ....... 9/17/87 363 E.D. Denied 102 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 200, 517 A.2d 1012

Dalusio, Petition of . 9/20/88 67 E.D. Denied No. 2789 C.D. 1986 (1988)

Duling v. Zoning Hearing Bd. of Thornbury Tp. ...... 9/20/88 67 E.D. Denied No. 2789 C.D. 1986 (1988)

Elizabeth Forward School Dist. v. Poorman ........... 10/17/88 317 W.D. Denied 540 A.2d 1021 (1988)

Fetterolf Min., Petition of ....... 10/17/88 167 W.D. Denied 112 Pa. Commw. 1, (1988) 534 A.2d 1130

Gibbs v. Com., Dept. of Corrections ..... 11/7/88 38 M.D. Denied No. 1598 C.D. 1988 (1988)

Hill v. Port Authority Transit System of Allegheny County .. 10/21/88 331 W.D. Denied No. 2332 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Justice v. Com., Pa. Bd. of Prob. Parole ............. 10/4/88 003 M.D. Denied No. 2421 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Last v. Com., Unemployment Comp. Bd. of Review ...... 10/4/88 054 M.D. Denied No. 2093 C.D. 1986 (1988)

Lellock v. Mellinger 10/31/88 76 W.D. Granted No. 3367 C.D. 1986 (1988) (92 W.D. 1988)

Mastromonaco, Petition of ....... 10/21/88 303 W.D. Denied 542 A.2d 181 (1988)

Mastromonaco v. Calderelli ........ 10/21/88 303 W.D. Denied 542 A.2d 181 (1988)

Monoca v. Com., Unemployment Compensation Bd. of Review ............. 9/20/88 200 M.D. Granted No. 2794 C.D. 1982 (1987) (35 M.D. 1988)

PBS Coals, Inc., Petition of ....... 10/17/88 171 W.D. Denied 112 Pa. Commw. 1, (1988) 534 A.2d 1130

Pfuhl v. Malloy ..... 10/21/88 367 W.D. Denied 542 A.2d 202 (1988)

Popovich to Use of Aetna Cas. and Surety Co. v. Com., Dept. of Transp. ........... 10/21/88 385 W.D. Granted 542 A.2d 1056 (1988) (91 W.D. 1988)

Romagni v. Com., Dept. of Public Welfare . 10/18/88 426 W.D. Denied 96 Pa.Cmwlth. (1986) 446, 507 A.2d 1292

Roman v. Unemployment Compensation Bd. of Review ............ 10/19/88 83 W.D. Granted No. 3203 C.D. 1986 (1988) (89 W.D. 1988)

Scalzi v. City of Altoona ............ 9/21/88 8 W.D. Denied 111 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 479, 533 A.2d 1150

Scranton School Dist. v. Weiss ......... 10/20/88 253 E.D. Granted 113 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (143 E.D. 381, 1988) 537 A.2d 910

Spencer v. McKean Tp. 10/20/88 293 W.D. Denied 113 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 521, 537 A.2d 943

Tokic v. Com., Unemployment Compensation Bd. of Review .......... 9/16/88 377 E.D. Denied No. 1111 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Townsend v. Elizabeth Forward School Dist. 10/17/88 317 W.D. Denied 540 A.2d 1021 (1988)

West Shore School Dist. v. West Shore Educ. Assn. .............. 11/9/88 119 M.D. Denied 113 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 98, 536 A.2d 483

Williams v. Com., Pennsylvania Bd. of Probation and Parole ........ 10/19/88 271 W.D. Denied No. 2255 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Wurster v. East Lycoming School Dist. .............. 10/4/88 068 M.D. Denied No. 2519 C.D. 1986 (1988)

SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA DISPOSITIONS OF PETITIONS FOR ALLOWANCE OF APPEAL 552 A.2d 249-253 Appeal from the Superior Court

Allocatur Disposition Lower Court Docket and Appeal Docket or Title Date Number Docket Citation

Almes v. Martino .... 11/17/88 211 W.D. Denied No. 227 Pittsburgh (1988) 1988

Andreasen v. Andreasen ......... 10/18/88 516 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 641, (1988) 544 A.2d 1037

Burr v. Callwood .... 11/15/88 393 W.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 502, (1988) 543 A.2d 583

Cannavo v. Jan-Dot, Inc. ............... 9/2/88 434 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 642, (1988) 544 A.2d 1037

Carmassi v. Beck ..... 11/2/88 132 W.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 634, (1988) 541 A.2d 788

Carrasquillo by Carrasquillo v. Lawrence .......... 10/24/88 192 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 637, (1988) 538 A.2d 935

Cavalier, In re Estate of .......... 11/2/88 54 W.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 627, (1988) 541 A.2d 35

Cincinnati Mach. Co. v. Majdic .......... 6/28/88 228 E.D. Denied 370 Pa. Super. 611, (1988) 537 A.2d 334

Cohen Cohen, P.C. v. Scharf ......... 10/17/88 507 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 642, (1988) 544 A.2d 1038

Com., Petition of .... 9/6/88 974 E.D. Denied 367 Pa. Super. 321, (1987) 532 A.2d 1167

Com. v. Anderson ..... 8/24/88 14 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 638, (1988) 538 A.2d 936

Com. v. Avdlett ..... 10/18/88 152 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 613, (1988) 541 A.2d 25

Com. v. Battis ...... 10/18/88 110 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 613, (1988) 541 A.2d 25

Com. v. Bazemore .... 11/30/88 124 M.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 643, (1988) 544 A.2d 1038

Com. v. Bogden ...... 11/16/88 402 W.D. Denied 364 Pa. Super. 300, (1987) 528 A.2d 168

Com. v. Bristow ..... 11/16/88 308 E.D. Denied 372 Pa. Super. 48, (1988) 538 A.2d 1343

Com. v. Brown ....... 10/18/88 125 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 614, (1988) 541 A.2d 26

Com. v. Butler ...... 11/16/88 985 E.D. Granted 367 Pa. Super. 453, (1987) (163 E.D. 533 A.2d 105 1988)

Com. v. Byers ....... 11/18/88 406 E.D. Granted 378 Pa. Super. 644, (1988) (164 E.D. 544 A.2d 1039 1988)

Com. v. Caswell ..... 10/21/88 537 E.D. Denied 379 Pa. Super. 655, (1988) 545 A.2d 381

Com. v. Coviello .... 10/20/88 522 E.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 649, (1988) 541 A.2d 1149

Com. v. Cramer ...... 11/15/88 404 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 649, (1988) 547 A.2d 435

Com. v. Delligatti .. 10/31/88 142 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 315, (1988) 538 A.2d 34

Com. v. Douglass .... 11/22/88 198 W.D. Denied 372 Pa. Super. 227, (1988) 539 A.2d 412

Com. v. Edmunds ..... 11/17/88 287 W.D. Granted 373 Pa. Super. 384, (1988) (99 W.D. 541 A.2d 368 1988)

Com. v. Epps ........ 11/16/88 073 M.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 637, (1988) 541 A.2d 790

Com. v. Essig ....... 11/16/88 268 M.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 633, (1987) 536 A.2d 823

Com. v. Evans ........ 9/16/88 419 E.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 650, (1988) 541 A.2d 1150

Com. v. Florio ....... 10/3/88 494 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 646, (1988) 544 A.2d 1040

Com. v. Friend ...... 11/16/88 092 M.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 638, (1988) 541 A.2d 790

Com. v. Harris ...... 10/13/88 230 E.D. Denied 370 Pa. Super. 575, (1988) 537 A.2d 24

Com. v. Hartzell ..... 11/2/88 164 W.D. Denied No. 1582 (1988) Pittsburgh 1987

Com. v. Hill ......... 9/22/88 144 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 617, (1988) 541 A.2d 28

Com. v. Hoopengarner . 10/5/88 379 E.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 652, (1988) 541 A.2d 1151

Com. v. Jamison ...... 9/8/88 524 E.D. Denied 361 Pa. Super. 634, (1987) 517 A.2d 1364

Com. v. Johnson ..... 10/20/88 490 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 648, (1988) 544 A.2d 1042

Com. v. Johnson ..... 10/31/88 561 E.D. Denied 380 Pa. Super. 647, (1988) 547 A.2d 437

Com. v. Johnson ...... 11/2/88 3 W.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 635, (1988) 536 A.2d 825

Com. v. Johnson ..... 11/22/88 283 W.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 312, (1988) 541 A.2d 332

Com. v. Jones ........ 11/16/88 076 M.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 639,

(1988) 541 A.2d 791

Com. v. Karabin ..... 11/17/88 098 M.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 653, (1988) 541 A.2d 1152

Com. v. Kefauver .... 11/30/88 024 M.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 644, (1988) 538 A.2d 940

Com. v. Kirksey ...... 11/9/88 458 E.D. Denied 378 Pa. Super. 648, (1988) 544 A.2d 1042

Com. v. McGriff ..... 10/18/88 142 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 620, (1988) 541 A.2d 30

Com. v. McNamara ..... 10/4/88 164 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 620, (1988) 541 A.2d 30

Com. v. McNeil ...... 10/31/88 532 E.D. Denied 379 Pa. Super. 662, (1988) 545 A.2d 386

Com. v. Maines ...... 10/18/88 172 E.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 619, (1988) 541 A.2d 30

Com. v. Morris ...... 10/24/88 20 W.D. Denied 368 Pa. Super. 237, (1988) 533 A.2d 1042

Com. v. Moore ....... 10/21/88 662 E.D. Denied 380 Pa. Super. 649, (1988) 547 A.2d 439

Com. v. Pfender ..... 11/22/88 239 W.D. Denied 373 Pa. Super. 102, (1988) 540 A.2d 543

Com. v. Pickford ..... 12/1/88 130 W.D. Granted 370 Pa. Super. 444, (1988) (101 W.D. 536 A.2d 1348 1988)

Com. v. Richardson ... 11/9/88 308 W.D. Denied 379 Pa. Super. 664, (1988) 545 A.2d 388

Com. v. Robinson .... 11/29/88 216 M.D. Denied 381 Pa. Super. 660, (1988) 548 A.2d 643

Com. v. Schaeffer .... 12/2/88 017 M.D. Granted 370 Pa. Super. 179, (1988) (53 M.D. 536 A.2d 354 1988)

Com. v. Silverman ... 11/30/88 273 W.D. Granted 373 Pa. Super. 274, (1988) (102 W.D. 541 A.2d 9 1988)

Com. v. Thompson .... 11/17/88 151 W.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 643, (1988) 541 A.2d 794

Dages v. Dages ....... 12/1/88 179 M.D. Denied 380 Pa. Super. 654, (1988) 547 A.2d 442

DeAugustine v. Pennsylvania Dept. of Transp. ............ 10/7/88 108 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 652, (1988) 538 A.2d 946

Duquesne Light Co., Petition of ....... 10/19/88 150 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 183, (1988) 537 A.2d 881

Duquesne Light Co. v. Gregg Sec. Services, Inc. .... 10/19/88 150 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 183, (1988) 537 A.2d 881

Esis, Inc. v. McDevitt ........... 9/21/88 549 E.D. Denied 379 Pa. Super. 667, (1988) 545 A.2d 390

Gerard v. Second Nat. Bank of Masontown .. 11/9/88 152 W.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 646, (1988) 541 A.2d 796

Golden v. Willard Co., Inc. .............. 10/25/88 55 E.D. Granted 374 Pa. Super. 653, (1988) (149 E.D. 538 A.2d 947 1988)

Haynes v. Lyon ...... 11/28/88 43 W.D. Granted 373 Pa. Super. 644, (1988) (100 W.D. 536 A.2d 831 1988)

Kotarsky v. Kotarsky .......... 11/10/88 341 W.D. Denied 380 Pa. Super. 656, (1988) 547 A.2d 444

Larsen v. Philadelphia Newspapers, Inc. .............. 10/31/88 371 W.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 66, (1988) 543 A.2d 1181

Lesh v. Magistri .... 11/16/88 178 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 662, (1988) 541 A.2d 1158

McDevitt, Petition of ........ 9/21/88 549 E.D. Denied 379 Pa. Super. 667, (1988) 545 A.2d 390

Moody, In Interest of ....... 10/18/88 257 E.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 647, (1988) 541 A.2d 797

Moody, Petition of ....... 10/18/88 257 E.D. Denied 376 Pa. Super. 647, (1988) 541 A.2d 797

Musser v. Vilsmeier Auction Co., Inc. .............. 10/12/88 489 E.D. Granted 378 Pa. Super. 657, (1988) (150 E.D. 544 A.2d 1048 1988)

Neill, In re Estate of .......... 11/2/88 91 W.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 654, (1988) 538 A.2d 948

Pennsylvania Dept. of Transp. v. DeAugustine ........ 10/7/88 108 E.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 652, (1988) 538 A.2d 946

Peoples Bank of Western Pennsylvania v. Galliker Dairy Co. ............... 11/14/88 406 W.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 147, (1988) 542 A.2d 539

Philadelphia Newspapers, Inc., Petition of ................ 10/31/88 371 W.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 66, (1988) 543 A.2d 1181

Remas v. Duquesne Light Co. ......... 10/19/88 150 W.D. Denied 371 Pa. Super. 183, (1988) 537 A.2d 881

Ruscitti v. Estate of Ruscitti .......... 11/22/88 248 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 664, (1988) 541 A.2d 1159

Shanaberger, Petition of ........ 11/2/88 54 W.D. Denied 375 Pa. Super. 627, (1988) 541 A.2d 35

Vilsmeier Auction Co., Inc. v. International Harvester Co. ..... 10/12/88 489 E.D. Granted 378 Pa. Super. 657, (1988) (150 E.D. 544 A.2d 1048 1988)

Weaver v. Fitz ...... 11/29/88 146 M.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 665, (1988) 541 A.2d 1160

Willard Co., Inc. v. John F. Harkins Co., Inc. ......... 10/25/88 55 E.D. Granted 374 Pa. Super. 653, (1988) (149 E.D. 538 A.2d 947 1988)

Wilson, Matter of ................. 9/6/88 974 E.D. Denied 367 Pa. Super. 321, (1987) 532 A.2d 1167

Wolfman, Petition of ................. 11/2/88 91 W.D. Denied 374 Pa. Super. 654, (1988) 538 A.2d 948

Woods v. Bailey ..... 11/16/88 219 W.D. Denied 377 Pa. Super. 665, (1988) 541 A.2d 1160

Appeal from the Commonwealth Court

Allocatur Disposition Lower Court Docket and Appeal Docket or Title Date Number Docket Citation

Appeal From the City of Pittsburgh From the Action of Bd. of Property Assessment, Appeals and Review of Allegheny County in Regard to Property Situate in the Second Ward of City of Pittsburgh, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania (Clark Bldg.), In re ............. 11/14/88 334 W.D. Denied No. 2928 C.D. 1986 (1988)

Cherry Valley Associates v. Stroud Tp. Bd. of Sup'rs .......... 8/22/88 919 E.D. Denied 109 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 246, 530 A.2d 1039

City of Pittsburgh, Petition of ....... 11/14/88 334 W.D. Denied No. 2928 C.D. 1986 (1988)

County of Allegheny for Permission to Sell a Certain Hangar at Allegheny County Airport to Corporate Jets, Inc., Petition of .. 11/2/88 100 W.D. Denied No. 2311 C.D. 1986 (1988)

Dallap v. Sharon City School Dist. ............. 11/18/88 225 W.D. Granted 105 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) (103 W.D. 346, 1988) 524 A.2d 546

Deal v. W.C.A.B. (Pullman Standard) ......... 11/15/88 310 W.D. Denied No. 3278 C.D. 1985 (1988)

Eureka Stone Quarry, Inc., Petition of ................. 9/15/88 404 E.D. Denied 539 A.2d 1375 (1988)

Eureka Stone Quarry, Inc. from Decision of the Newtown Area Joint Zoning Hearing Bd., Appeal of .......... 9/15/88 404 E.D. Denied 539 A.2d 1375 (1988)

Eureka Stone Quarry, Inc. from Decision of the Wrightstown Tp. Zoning Hearing Bd., Appeal of ..... 9/15/88 404 E.D. Denied 539 A.2d 1375 (1988)

Fields v. W.C.A.B. (Duquesne Light Co.) ........ 11/18/88 236 W.D. Denied 114 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 645, 539 A.2d 507

Fetherman, Petition of ........ 8/22/88 919 E.D. Denied 109 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 246, 530 A.2d 1039

Fiore, Petition of ... 11/2/88 100 W.D. Denied No. 2311 C.D. 1986 (1988)

Fultz, Appeal of .... 11/18/88 175 M.D. Denied No. 2719 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Hassman McDonalds Enterprises, Inc. v. W.C.A.B. ....... 11/18/88 175 M.D. Denied No. 2719 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Hollywood Social Club v. W.C.A.B. (Ferrell) ......... 11/18/88 398 W.D. Denied No. 1975 C.D. 1987 (1988)

Kulbitsky, Petition of ................ 10/18/88 275 E.D. Denied 112 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 477, 536 A.2d 458

Reefer v. Commonwealth, Unemp. Comp. Bd. of Review ......... 11/16/88 266 W.D. Denied No. 2648 C.D. 1986 (1988)

SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA DISPOSITIONS OF PETITIONS FOR ALLOWANCE OF APPEAL 553 A.2d 964-972 Appeal from the Superior Court

Allocatur Disposition Lower Court Docket and Appeal Docket or Title Date Number Docket Citation

Africa v. Com. ......... 12/2/88 208 E.D. Granted 375 Pa.Super. (1988) (172 E.D. 623, 1988) 541 A.2d 32

Alexander by Alexander v. Aetna Life Cas. Ins. Co. ............. 11/30/88 246 E.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 633, 541 A.2d 787

Cassell v. Gingrich .... 11/16/88 247 E.D. Granted 375 Pa.Super. (1988) (167 E.D. 612, 1988) 541 A.2d 25

Cassell v. Gingrich .... 11/16/88 162 E.D. Granted 374 Pa.Super. (1988) (166 E.D. 637, 1988) 538 A.2d 935

Charters v. Singer Co. .................. 12/27/88 166 M.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 654, 545 A.2d 380

Christo v. Tuscany, Inc. ................. 11/7/88 558 W.D. Discontin- 368 Pa.Super. (1987) ued 9, (78 W.D. 533 A.2d 461 1988)

Chubb Son, Inc., Petition of .......... 11/16/88 286 E.D. Denied 369 Pa.Super. (1988) 547, 535 A.2d 1070

Clodgo v. Johnson ...... 12/15/88 005 M.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 637, 538 A.2d 935

Cluelow v. Marinelli ... 11/9/88 527 E.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 647, 541 A.2d 1148

Com. v. Banks .......... 11/14/88 618 E.D. Quashed 365 Pa.Super. (1988) 639, 526 A.2d 810

Com. v. Brady .......... 12/2/88 133 E.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 638, 538 A.2d 936

Com. v. Brinson ........ 11/22/88 362 E.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 648, 541 A.2d 1148

Com. v. Bristow ........ 11/16/88 308 E.D. Denied 372 Pa.Super. (1988) 48, 538 A.2d 1343

Com. v. Burton ......... 11/18/88 430 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 644, 544 A.2d 1039

Com. v. Caramadre ...... 9/16/88 223 W.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 636, 541 A.2d 789

Com. v. Carbone ........ 12/13/88 390 W.D. Granted 375 Pa.Super. (1988) (106 W.D. 261, 1988) 544 A.2d 462

Com. v. Cellini ........ 11/30/88 463 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 644, 544 A.2d 1039

Com. v. Dickerson ...... 11/30/88 518 E.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 650, 541 A.2d 1149

Com. v. Dobbs .......... 11/16/88 641 E.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 645, 547 A.2d 435

Com. v. Dykes .......... 11/17/88 497 E.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 258, 541 A.2d 1

Com. v. Fenstermaker ... 11/9/88 150 E.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 633

Com. v. Ferraro ........ 11/17/88 270 W.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 657, 545 A.2d 383

Com. v. Fetzner ........ 11/18/88 220 W.D. Denied 372 Pa.Super. (1988) 469, 539 A.2d 890

Com. v. Fickes ......... 11/30/88 444 W.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 654, 548 A.2d 638

Com. v. Gallippi ....... 12/12/88 306 W.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 657, 545 A.2d 383

Com. v. Hicks .......... 11/14/88 596 E.D. Quashed 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 617, 541 A.2d 28

Com. v. Hunt ........... 11/17/88 341 E.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 652, 541 A.2d 1151

Com. v. Jackson ........ 12/1/88 413 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 647, 544 A.2d 1041

Com. v. Jones .......... 11/30/88 247 W.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 648, 544 A.2d 1042

Com. v. Jones .......... 12/2/88 723 E.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 656, 548 A.2d 640

Com. v. Jordan ......... 11/16/88 645 E.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 647, 547 A.2d 437

Com. v. Kimmel ......... 12/22/88 106 M.D. Granted 377 Pa.Super. (1988) (59 M.D. 653, 1988) 541 A.2d 1152

Com. v. King ........... 12/27/88 185 M.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 647, 547 A.2d 438

Com. v. Learn .......... 12/22/88 374 W.D. Granted 379 Pa.Super. (1988) (112 W.D. 660, (1988) 545 A.2d 385

Com. v. Lindsay ........ 11/9/88 505 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 648, 544 A.2d 1042

Com. v. Lodis .......... 11/18/88 681 E.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 157, 543 A.2d 1226

Com. v. McClelland ..... 11/30/88 235 W.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 649, 544 A.2d 1043

Com. v. McEachin ....... 11/17/88 256 E.D. Denied 371 Pa.Super. (1988) 188, 537 A.2d 883

Com. v. Mirabella ...... 12/15/88 430 W.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 658, 548 A.2d 641

Com. v. Mitchell ....... 11/16/88 655 E.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 649, 547 A.2d 439

Com. v. Mott ........... 12/15/88 183 W.D. Granted 372 Pa.Super. (1988) (107 W.D. 133, 1988) 539 A.2d 365

Com. v. Moultrie ....... 9/6/88 1074 E.D. Denied 361 Pa.Super. (1986) 636, 517 A.2d 1366

Com. v. Ortiz .......... 11/18/88 615 E.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 650, 547 A.2d 439

Com. v. Palmer ......... 11/2/88 113 W.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 621, 541 A.2d 31

Com. v. Parker ......... 11/18/88 426 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 650, 544 A.2d 1043

Com. v. Payne .......... 9/12/88 519 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 650, 544 A.2d 1044

Com. v. Phillips ....... 10/5/88 39 E.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 638, 536 A.2d 828

Com. v. Plasterer ...... 12/20/88 097 M.D. Denied No. 664 (1988) Harrisburg 1987

Com. v. Oleynik ........ 12/20/88 114 W.D. Granted 376 Pa.Super. (1988) (108 W.D. 641, 1988) 541 A.2d 792

Com. v. Pletcher ....... 11/17/88 291 W.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 663, 545 A.2d 387

Com. v. Potts .......... 9/29/88 29 E.D. Denied 368 Pa.Super. (1988) 408, 534 A.2d 501

Com. v. Pyett .......... 10/31/88 390 E.D. Denied 372 Pa.Super. (1988) 291, 539 A.2d 444

Com. v. Ranck .......... 11/16/88 169 M.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 664, 545 A.2d 387

Com. v. Rios ........... 10/21/88 540 E.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 655, 541 A.2d 1153

Com. v. Robinson ....... 9/12/88 334 E.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 642, 541 A.2d 793

Com. v. Rohrback ....... 11/18/88 171 M.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 664, 545 A.2d 388

Com. v. Romanelli ...... 11/2/88 210 E.D. Granted 336 Pa.Super. (1988) (155 E.D. 261, 1988) 485 A.2d 795

Com. v. Ruffin ......... 11/2/88 276 E.D. Granted 376 Pa.Super. (1988) (156 E.D. 642, 1988) 541 A.2d 793

Com. v. Ryder .......... 11/4/88 176 E.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 642, 541 A.2d 793

Com. v. Seegrist ....... 11/9/88 175 E.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 655, 538 A.2d 948

Com. v. Sexton ......... 11/17/88 558 E.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 665, 545 A.2d 388

Com. v. Shawley ........ 12/1/88 145 M.D. Granted 378 Pa.Super. (1988) (54 M.D. 652, 1988) 544 A.2d 1045

Com. v. Sierra ......... 10/14/88 520 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 652, 544 A.2d 1045

Com. v. Smith .......... 11/17/88 578 E.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 665, 545 A.2d 388

Com. v. Sparks ......... 11/30/88 225 W.D. Denied 372 Pa.Super. (1988) 463, 539 A.2d 887

Com. v. Spriggs ........ 11/22/88 218 M.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 463, 548 A.2d 643

Com. v. Stano .......... 11/22/88 221 W.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 644, 541 A.2d 795

Com. v. Stewart ........ 12/28/88 201 M.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 585, 544 A.2d 1384

Com. v. Stidfole ....... 10/21/88 152 M.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 665, 545 A.2d 389

Com. v. Stover ......... 11/9/88 350 E.D. Denied 372 Pa.Super. (1988) 35, 538 A.2d 1336

Com. v. Styles ......... 11/18/88 460 E.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 653, 544 A.2d 1045

Com. v. Thomas ......... 11/7/88 446 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 653, 544 A.2d 1045

Com. v. Thomas ......... 11/30/88 486 E.D. Denied 372 Pa.Super. (1988) 349, 539 A.2d 829

Com. v. Thompson ....... 11/2/88 322 E.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 643, 541 A.2d 794

Com. v. Thompson ....... 11/14/88 470 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 653, 544 A.2d 1046

Com. v. Vasquez ........ 12/2/88 134 M.D. Denied No. 233 (1988) Harrisburg 1988

Com. v. Walker ......... 11/22/88 221 W.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 644, 541 A.2d 795

Com. v. Walker ......... 11/2/88 282 E.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 644, 541 A.2d 795

Com. v. Wallace ........ 12/2/88 588 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 653, 544 A.2d 1046

Com. v. Ware ........... 9/7/88 104 E.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 651, 538 A.2d 945

Com. v. Wells .......... 10/5/88 464 E.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 658, 541 A.2d 1156

Com. v. White .......... 11/2/88 494 W.D. Denied 366 Pa.Super. (1987) 538, 531 A.2d 806

Com. v. Williams ....... 10/21/88 595 E.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 666, 545 A.2d 390

Com. v. Wilson ......... 11/17/88 101 M.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 659, 541 A.2d 1156

Com. v. Winstead ....... 11/2/88 342 E.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 659, 541 A.2d 1156

Com. ex rel. Otto v. Wagner ............... 9/29/88 79 E.D. Denied No. 3065 (1988) Philadelphia 1987

Corter v. Amsler ....... 12/12/88 191 M.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 653, 547 A.2d 442

Cropper, Petition of ... 12/12/88 226 W.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 659, 541 A.2d 1156

Cropper v. Ward ........ 12/12/88 226 W.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 659, 541 A.2d 1156

Daughen v. Fox ......... 10/31/88 420 E.D. Denied 372 Pa.Super. (1988) 405, 539 A.2d 858

Deitz v. Hickey ........ 11/17/88 517 E.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 667, 545 A.2d 390

DiLucia v. Clemens ..... 10/17/88 547 E.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 466, 541 A.2d 765

Dinavel Enterprises v. Video Center, Inc .... 11/16/88 370 E.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 659, 541 A.2d 1156

Dubin v. Slutsky ....... 11/17/88 422 E.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 659, 541 A.2d 1156

Eckenrod v. Gaf Corp. .. 12/15/88 436 W.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 187, 544 A.2d 50

Eckenrod v. GAF Corp. .. 12/15/88 437 W.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 187, 544 A.2d 50

Flinchbaugh v. Jiles ... 12/2/88 170 M.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 668, 545 A.2d 391

Grady v. Penjerdel Refrigeration Co ..... 10/31/88 185 E.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 628, 541 A.2d 36

Gruver v. Gruver ....... 11/17/88 397 E.D. Denied 372 Pa.Super. (1988) 194, 539 A.2d 395

Hadley v. Bylsma ....... 6/3/88 1011 E.D. Denied No. 2738 (1987) Philadelphia 1986

Hayes v. Motorists Mut. Ins. Co .............. 11/2/88 147 W.D. Denied 370 Pa.Super. (1988) 602, 537 A.2d 330

Haynes v. Lyon ......... 11/28/88 44 W.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 644, 536 A.2d 831

Hendricks v. Pepperidge Farm, Inc. ........... 8/30/88 309 E.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 646, 541 A.2d 797

Kerstetter v. Mull ..... 11/17/88 132 M.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 228, 540 A.2d 951

Larsen v. Philadelphia Newspapers, Inc ...... 10/31/88 371 W.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 66, 543 A.2d 1181

Larsen v. Philadelphia Newspapers, Inc ...... 10/31/88 372 W.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 66, 543 A.2d 1181

Laub v. Zaslavsky ...... 11/22/88 59 E.D. Granted 369 Pa.Super. (1988) (173 E.D. 84, 1988) 534 A.2d 1090

Lazaro v. Aetna Cas. Surety Co. ........... 10/5/88 198 E.D. Denied 371 Pa.Super. (1988) 119, 537 A.2d 849

Levine v. Shapiro ...... 9/2/88 509 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 656, 544 A.2d 1048

Lewis v. Com. .......... 11/30/88 468 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 648, 544 A.2d 1042

Lohinetz v. Pinto ...... 10/31/88 307 E.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 648, 541 A.2d 798

London v. Coatesville Hosp ................. 10/31/88 241 E.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 648, 541 A.2d 798

McCabe v. McCabe ....... 11/9/88 622 E.D. Granted 374 Pa.Super. (1988) (159 E.D. 451, 1988) 543 A.2d 558

McCabe v. McCabe ....... 11/9/88 666 E.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 451, 543 A.2d 558

McGilley v. Chubb Son, Inc ............. 11/16/88 238 E.D. Denied 369 Pa.Super. (1988) 547, 535 A.2d 1070

McGilley v. Chubb Son, Inc. ............ 11/16/88 286 E.D. Denied 369 Pa.Super. (1988) 547, 535 A.2d 1070

Mackowick v. Westinghouse Elec. Corp. ................ 12/22/88 298 W.D. Granted 373 Pa.Super. (1988) (110 W.D. 434, 1988) 541 A.2d 749

Metzger v. Metzger ..... 11/7/88 122 E.D. Granted 369 Pa.Super. (1988) (157 E.D. 17, 1988) 534 A.2d 1057

Metzger v. Metzger ..... 11/7/88 122 E.D. Granted 369 Pa.Super. (1988) (158 E.D. 17, 1988) 534 A.2d 1057

Munro, In re ........... 12/2/88 158 M.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 448, 541 A.2d 756

Nebistinsky v. Nebistinsky .......... 9/10/87 1156 E.D. Denied 361 Pa.Super. (1986) 640, 517 A.2d 1369

Nivens on Behalf of Nivens v. Chestnut Hill Hosp ............ 10/19/88 451 E.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 377, 541 A.2d 365

Paul v. Lankenau Hosp .. 12/12/88 602 E.D. Granted 375 Pa.Super. (1988) (152 E.D. 1, 1988) 543 A.2d 1148

Piazza v. Yamato Japanese Restaurant, Inc .................. 10/7/88 64 E.D. Denied No. 66 (1988) Philadelphia 1987

Pittsburgh Gage Co., Petition of .......... 12/15/88 437 W.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 187 544 A.2d 50

Powers v. Cherry Creek Sand Specialty Co .... 11/18/88 383 E.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 663, 541 A.2d 1159

Ritt, Inc. v. Josephine Nusl, Inc ............ 11/16/88 089 M.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 647, 541 A.2d 797 State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Zachary .. 11/2/88 242 E.D. Denied 370 Pa.Super. (1988) 386, 536 A.2d 800

Tallman v. Aetna Cas. Surety Co. ......... 12/22/88 120 M.D. Denied 372 Pa.Super. (1988) 593, 539 A.2d 1354

Temple v. Driver ....... 11/18/88 165 M.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 389, 543 A.2d 134

Tenny v. Mihalich ...... 12/22/88 143 M.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 664, 541 A.2d 1160

Waninger v. Flaherty ... 11/2/88 326 E.D. Denied No. 3135 (1988) Philadelphia 1987

Weibley v. Commonwealth Nat. Bank ................. 12/2/88 158 M.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 448, 541 A.2d 756

Appeal from the Superior Court

Allocatur Disposition Lower Court Docket and Appeal Docket or Title Date Number Docket Citation

Antonetti v. Com., Unemployment Compensation Bd. of Review ............... 10/20/88 450 E.D. Denied No. 228 (1988) C.D. 1987

Bethenergy Mines, Inc. v. W.C.A.B. (Sadvary) ............ 12/2/88 424 W.D. Granted 543 A.2d 1268 (1988) (104 W.D. 1988) Bioni v. Canon-McMillan School Dist. ......... 8/23/88 537 W.D. Denied 110 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 584, 533 A.2d 179

Cadogan v. Com. Bd. of Probation Parole ... 11/14/88 150 M.D. Denied 116 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 249, 541 A.2d 832

Camaione v. Borough of Latrobe .............. 11/16/88 109 W.D. Granted 113 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (96 W.D. 113, 1988) 536 A.2d 500

Castagnera v. Com. ..... 11/9/88 483 E.D. Denied No. 227 (1988) C.D. 1986

City of Philadelphia v. District Council 33 .. 11/9/88 71 E.D. Granted 112 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (160 E.D. 90, 1988) 535 A.2d 231

Com., Dept. of Transp., Petition of .......... 12/1/88 415 W.D. Denied 543 A.2d 1251 (1988)

Com., Dept. of Transp. v. Morrow ............... 11/2/88 143 W.D. Denied 113 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 326, 537 A.2d 90

Com., Dept. of Transp. Bureau of Driver Licensing v. Montgomery ........... 10/5/88 266 E.D. Denied 113 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 421, 537 A.2d 111

County of Chester, Bd. of Assessment Appeals v. Herdeg ............... 10/21/88 635 E.D. Denied 114 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 583, 539 A.2d 486

Davis v. Com., Unemployment Compensation Bd. of Review ............... 11/16/88 456 E.D. Denied No. 776 (1988) C.D. 1987

Duncan v. Rochester Area School Bd ............ 12/1/88 515 W.D. Granted 108 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) (105 W.D. 166, 1988) 529 A.2d 48

Evanick v. W.C.A.B. (Fisher Scientific Co.) ................. 11/2/88 104 W.D. Denied 111 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 439, 533 A.2d 1137

Fawber v. Dauphin County Tax Claim Bureau ............... 12/12/88 198 M.D. Denied 543 A.2d 1288 (1988)

Fisher Scientific Co., Petition of .......... 11/2/88 104 W.D. Denied 111 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 429, 533 A.2d 1137

Gates v. W.C.A.B. (George Leck Co.) ............ 11/18/88 411 E.D. Denied No. 3476 C.D. (1988) 1985

Jawhar v. Pytlerz ...... 12/1/88 415 W.D. Denied 543 A.2d 1251 (1988)

Kaminski v. W.C.A.B. (Dobbs House, Inc.) .. 9/6/88 374 E.D. Denied 114 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 484, 539 A.2d 34

Knisch v. W.C.A.B. (Jerome Enterprises) ......... 10/18/88 302 E.D. Quashed 113 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 204, 536 A.2d 856

Koslow v. Com., State Ethics Com'n ......... 11/30/88 440 W.D. Denied 116 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 19, 540 A.2d 1374

Kulbitsky, Matter of ... 10/18/88 275 E.D. Denied 112 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 477, 536 A.2d 458

Kulbitsky v. Com. ...... 10/18/88 275 E.D. Denied 112 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 477, 536 A.2d 458

Latshaw v. Com., Unemployment Compensation Bd. of Review ............... 10/18/88 126 E.D. Denied No. 3470 (1988) C.D. 1985

Levandoski v. W.C.A.B. (Coronet Fashions) ... 9/12/88 304 E.D. Denied No. 2080 (1988) C.D. 1985

Lomax v. Com., Pa. Bd. of Prob. Parole ....... 11/18/88 103 M.D. Granted No. 2144 (1988) (52 M.D. C.D. 1986 1988)

McGill v. Pennsylvania Dept. of Transp ...... 11/17/88 215 E.D. Denied No. 180 (1988) C.D. 1987

Marx Stationery Printing Co. v. City of Philadelphia ......... 12/8/88 583 E.D. Denied 114 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 265, 538 A.2d 648

Mendenhall v. Com., Dept. of Transp ...... 11/22/88 255 E.D. Denied 113 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 550, 537 A.2d 951

Monticello Homeowner's Ass'n v. Township Sup'rs of Tp. of White ................ 11/22/88 208 W.D. Quashed 2460 C.D. 1985, (1988) 2277 C.D. 1986

Moore v. Cuyler ........ 11/29/88 474 E.D. Granted 114 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (174 E.D. 56, 1988) 538 A.2d 111

Moore v. Reid .......... 11/29/88 474 E.D. Granted 114 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (174 E.D. 56, 1988) 538 A.2d 111

Murray v. Pa. Bd. of Probation and Parole ............... 11/14/88 65 M.D. Denied No. 405 (1988) M.D. 1988

Northwood Nursing and Convalescent Home, Inc. v. Com., Dept. of Public Welfare .... 10/6/88 137 E.D. Denied 537 A.2d 374 (1988)

Oommen v. W.C.A.B. (M. Cardone Industries) .. 9/19/88 409 E.D. Denied No. 192 (1988) C.D. 1988

Pennsylvania Public Utility Com'n, Petition of ................... 11/14/88 378 W.D. Granted 116 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (95 W.D. 512, 1988) 542 A.2d 606

Peoples Nat. Gas Co. v. Apollo Gas Co. ....... 11/14/88 378 W.D. Granted 116 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (95 W.D. 512, 1988) 542 A.2d 606

Ramirez v. Com., Dept. of Corrections .......... 12/2/88 115 M.D. Denied No. 2323 (1988) C.D. 1987

Redevelopment Authority of City of Philadelphia, Petition of .......... 12/8/88 583 E.D. Denied 114 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 265, 538 A.2d 648

Sadvary, Petition of ... 12/2/88 424 W.D. Granted 543 A.2d 1268 (1988) (104 W.D. 1988)

Smith v. Com., Pa. Bd. of Probation and Parole ............... 10/17/88 322 W.D. Denied 116 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 239, 541 A.2d 439

Vail v. Com., Pa. Bd. of Probation and Parole ............... 11/2/88 213 W.D. Denied No. 739 (1988) C.D. 1987

Vasquez v. Com., Pa. Bd. of Probation and Parole ............... 12/2/88 135 M.D. Denied No. 566 (1988) C.D. 1988

Weiss v. Lords Valley Country Club ......... 8/30/88 84 E.D. Denied No. 92 (1988) T.D. 1986

Williams v. Com. ....... 11/22/88 212 W.D. Denied No. 1511 (1988) C.D. 1987

York County v. Norris ............... 11/22/88 116 M.D. Denied 113 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 541, 538 A.2d 85

SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA DISPOSITIONS OF PETITIONS FOR ALLOWANCE OF APPEAL 554 A.2d 505-513 Appeal from the Superior Court

Allocatur Disposition Lower Court Docket and Appeal Docket or Title Date Number Docket Citation

Abromaitis v. State Farm Ins. Co .............. 1/6/89 351 E.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 633, 541 A.2d 787

Acceleration Life Ins. Co. of Pennsylvania v. Schroeder ............ 1/6/89 107 W.D. Denied No. 707 (1988) Pittsburgh 1987

Bantam Four Cinemas, Inc. v. Zamias ....... 1/9/89 411 W.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 311, 544 A.2d 487

Barnes v. Lane ......... 11/16/88 492 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 641, 544 A.2d 1037

Bell Fuel Corp. v. Cattolico ............ 1/18/89 768 E.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 238, 544 A.2d 450

Bertha v. Capital Controls Co., Inc. ............ 1/9/89 696 E.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 642, 547 A.2d 433

Blair, In Interest of .. 1/30/89 217 M.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 663, 548 A.2d 645

Blaisure v. Blaisure ... 12/30/88 500 E.D. Denied No. 318 (1988) Phila., 1988

Bold v. Bold ........... 1/11/89 679 E.D. Granted 374 Pa.Super. (1988) (6 E.D. 317, 1989) 542 A.2d 1374

Buchanan v. Federal Nat. Mortg. Ass'n ......... 1/31/89 304 W.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 1, 542 A.2d 117

Carosone v. Schering Corp ................. 1/17/89 487 W.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 651, 548 A.2d 636

Cawley, Appeal of ...... 12/27/88 642 E.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 109, 543 A.2d 1202

Cawley v. Giancristofaro. ...... 12/27/88 642 E.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 109, 543 A.2d 1202

Children and Youth Services of Allegheny County, Petition of .. 2/9/89 25 W.D. Granted 368 Pa.Super. (1988) (14 W.D. 525, 1989) 534 A.2d 782

Com. v. Anderson ....... 1/12/89 277 W.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 642, 544 A.2d 1038

Com. v. Arroyo ......... 1/24/89 122 M.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 642, 544 A.2d 1038

Com. v. Ballard ........ 1/24/89 459 W.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 651, 548 A.2d 637

Com. v. Balliet ........ 1/31/89 182 M.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 235, 542 A.2d 1000

Com. v. Bartlebaugh .... 1/24/89 155 W.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 629, 536 A.2d 820

Com. v. Barto .......... 1/24/89 231 M.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. (1988) ___, 549 A.2d 1336

Com. v. Beason ......... 1/30/89 434 W.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 652, 548 A.2d 637

Com. v. Bell ........... 1/9/89 733 E.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 652, 548 A.2d 637 Com. v. Berkelbaugh .... 1/30/89 443 W.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 652, 548 A.2d 637

Com. v. Brown .......... 1/24/89 326 W.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 655, 545 A.2d 381

Com. v. Burgos ......... 12/28/88 638 E.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super, (1988) 643, 547 A.2d 435

Com. v. Byrd ........... 1/6/89 573 E.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 655, 545 A.2d 381

Com. v. Carr ........... 12/27/88 659 E.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 168, 543 A.2d 1232

Com. v. Celane ......... 1/31/89 210 W.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 644, 544 A.2d 1039

Com. v. Chapman ........ 1/18/89 510 E.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 655, 545 A.2d 381

Com. v. Colpo .......... 2/1/89 477 W.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. (1988) ___, 549 A.2d 1337

Com. v. Comport ........ 1/11/89 402 W.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 644, 547 A.2d 435

Com. v. Craft .......... 1/24/89 514 W.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. (1988) ___, 549 A.2d 1337

Com. v. Crawford ....... 1/6/89 536 E.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 656, 545 A.2d 382

Com. v. Cruz ........... 1/17/89 826 E.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. (1988) ___, 548 A.2d 638

Com. v. Davis .......... 1/23/89 181 W.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 649, 541 A.2d 1149

Com. v. Davis .......... 12/27/88 688 E.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 653, 548 A.2d 638

Com. v. Dennis ......... 1/23/89 164 M.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 656, 545 A.2d 382

Com. v. Dorler ......... 2/6/89 142 M.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 645, 544 A.2d 1040

Com. v. Finsel ......... 12/28/88 762 E.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 654, 548 A.2d 638

Com. v. Freeman ........ 1/30/89 212 M.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 645, 547 A.2d 436

Com. v. Gardner ........ 12/30/88 491 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 646, 544 A.2d 1040

Com. v. Gibbons ........ 2/1/89 327 W.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. (1988) ___, 549 A.2d 1338

Com. v. Glaister ....... 1/20/89 312 W.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 657, 545 A.2d 383

Com. v. Graham ......... 1/18/89 458 W.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 655, 548 A.2d 639

Com. v. Green .......... 1/25/89 363 W.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 658, 545 A.2d 383

Com. v. Harmon ......... 2/9/89 222 M.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. (1988) ___, 549 A.2d 1339

Com. v. Heidelburg ..... 1/24/89 524 W.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. (1988) ___, 550 A.2d 249

Com. v. Heinz .......... 12/29/88 665 E.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 646, 547 A.2d 437

Com. v. Hottinger ...... 12/28/88 265 E.D. Denied 370 Pa.Super. (1988) 527, 537 A.2d 1

Com. v. Hugo ........... 1/27/89 408 W.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 647, 547 A.2d 437

Com. v. Johnson ........ 1/17/89 500 W.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. (1988) ___, 549 A.2d 1340

Com. v. Johnson ........ 1/18/89 449 W.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. (1988) ___, 548 A.2d 640

Com. v. Knowles ........ 12/30/88 535 E.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 203, 540 A.2d 938

Com. v. Kriger ......... 1/9/89 425 W.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 656, 548 A.2d 640

Com. v. La Porte ....... 1/9/89 617 E.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 648, 547 A.2d 438

Com. v. Layne .......... 1/12/89 311 W.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 660, 545 A.2d 385

Com. v. Lehet .......... 12/27/88 488 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 648, 544 A.2d 1042

Com. v. Leistman ....... 1/24/89 399 W.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 648, 547 A.2d 438

Com. v. Lockcuff ....... 1/25/89 187 M.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 648, 547 A.2d 438

Com. v. Longenecker .... 12/28/88 624 E.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 660, 545 A.2d 385

Com. v. Lopez .......... 1/9/89 344 E.D. Granted 377 Pa.Super. (1988) (7 E.D. 653, 1989) 541 A.2d 1152

Com. v. Lowery ......... 1/27/89 167 M.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 661, 545 A.2d 385

Com. v. Lucas .......... 12/28/88 261 E.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 640, 541 A.2d 792

Com. v. McClendon ...... 2/1/89 178 M.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 649, 547 A.2d 438

Com. v. Macey .......... 1/18/89 437 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 649, 544 A.2d 1042

Com. v. McClain ........ 1/17/89 726 E.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 657, 548 A.2d 641

Com. v. Marconi ........ 1/20/89 550 E.D. Granted 379 Pa.Super. (1988) (005 E.D. 661, 1989) 545 A.2d 385

Com. v. Markum ......... 10/20/88 511 E.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 341, 541 A.2d 347

Com. v. Mills .......... 1/30/89 413 W.D. Granted 380 Pa.Super. (1988) (13 W.D. 649, 1989) 547 A.2d 439

Com. v. Moore .......... 1/6/89 791 E.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 658, 548 A.2d 641

Com. v. Morocco ........ 1/17/89 482 W.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 367, 544 A.2d 965

Com. v. Motyl .......... 12/22/88 204 M.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 658, 548 A.2d 642

Com. v. Nethery ........ 2/6/89 021 M.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 647, 538 A.2d 942

Com. v. Owens .......... 1/11/89 403 W.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 650, 547 A.2d 439 Com. v. Perry .......... 12/30/88 323 E.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 641, 541 A.2d 792

Com. v. Petersheim ..... 1/18/89 693 E.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 650, 547 A.2d 439

Com. v. Pratillo ....... 1/30/89 441 W.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 659, 548 A.2d 642

Com. v. Prestidge ...... 11/17/88 349 E.D. Denied 372 Pa.Super. (1988) 282, 539 A.2d 439

Com. v. Quillen ........ 1/10/89 297 E.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 641, 541 A.2d 793

Com. v. Reid ........... 1/13/89 493 W.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. (1988) ___, 549 A.2d 1342

Com. v. Rhoads ......... 12/29/88 224 E.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 622, 541 A.2d 32

Com. v. Richardson ..... 2/7/89 177 M.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 651, 547 A.2d 440

Com. v. Rohrer ......... 1/10/89 592 E.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 664, 545 A.2d 388

Com. v. Roldan ......... 1/31/89 346 E.D. Granted 377 Pa.Super. (1988) (13 E.D. 656, 1989) 541 A.2d 1154

Com. v. Royster ........ 1/24/89 806 E.D. Granted ___ Pa.Super. (1988) (11 E.D. ___, 1989) 549 A.2d 1343

Com. v. Sanders ........ 1/17/89 790 E.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 660, 548 A.2d 643

Com. v. Sawyer ......... 1/31/89 396 W.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 651, 547 A.2d 440

Com. v. Sears .......... 12/20/88 680 E.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 651, 547 A.2d 440

Com. v. Sestina ........ 1/12/89 464 W.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 441, 546 A.2d 109

Com. v. Smith .......... 1/12/89 466 W.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 660, 548 A.2d 643

Com. v. Story .......... 1/20/89 288 W.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 653, 544 A.2d 1046 Com. v. Thomas ......... 1/9/89 660 E.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 661, 548 A.2d 643

Com. v. Thomas ......... 1/17/89 847 E.D. Denied 376 Pa.Super. (1988) 455, 546 A.2d 116

Com. v. Tirado ......... 1/11/89 802 E.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. (1988) ___, 549 A.2d 1343

Com. v. Todaro ......... 1/20/89 254 W.D. Granted 378 Pa.Super. (1988) (11 W.D. 653, 1989) 544 A.2d 1046

Com. v. Waggoner ....... 10/19/88 444 E.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 23, 540 A.2d 280

Com. v. Wagner ......... 7/28/88 178 E.D. Denied 363 Pa.Super. (1987) 643, 522 A.2d 664

Com. v. Williams ....... 12/27/88 649 E.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 653, 547 A.2d 442

Com. v. Willis ......... 1/17/89 469 W.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. (1988) ___, 549 A.2d 1344

Com. v. Winstead ....... 12/30/88 343 E.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 659, 541 A.2d 1156

Com. v. Wolf ........... 4/28/88 1175 E.D. Denied 362 Pa.Super. (1986) 627, 520 A.2d 67

Com. v. Woods .......... 1/11/89 836 E.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. (1988) ___, 549 A.2d 1344

Conway on Behalf of Conway v. Lee ........ 1/11/89 757 E.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 661, 548 A.2d 644

Danko v. Sewickley Valley Hosp. ......... 1/31/89 409 W.D. Denied 380 Pa.Super. (1988) 654, 547 A.2d 442

Driscoll v. Travelers Ins. Co. ............. 12/27/88 584 E.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 76, 542 A.2d 154

Englert, In re Adoption of .......... 1/11/89 329 W.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 668, 545 A.2d 391

Englert, Petition of ... 1/11/89 329 W.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 668, 545 A.2d 391

Federal Nat. Mortg. Ass'n, Petition of ... 1/31/89 304 W.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 1, 542 A.2d 117

Fleming v. State Farm Mut. Ins. Co. ... 2/7/89 245 M.D. Denied ___ Pa.Super. (1988) ___, 550 A.2d 254

Fogal v. Dotan ......... 2/1/89 428 W.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 662, 548 A.2d 644

Ford v. Isdaner ........ 12/29/88 620 E.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 40, 542 A.2d 137

Fremd v. Highlands Hosp. and Health Center ............... 1/24/89 241 W.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 655, 544 A.2d 1047

Garcia v. Bang ......... 1/11/89 752 E.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 356, 544 A.2d 509

G.B., In re Adoption of ................... 1/11/89 566 E.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 653, 545 A.2d 380

Goeller v. Liberty Mut. Ins. Co. ............. 1/24/89 820 E.D. Granted 376 Pa.Super. (1988) (12 E.D. 608, 1989) 546 A.2d 690

Holden v. Holden ....... 12/22/88 554 E.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 184, 542 A.2d 557

Home Helpers, Inc. v. Armstrong ............ 12/30/88 504 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 655, 544 A.2d 1047

Johnson v. Otis Elevator Co. .................. 12/28/88 361 E.D. Denied 377 Pa.Super. (1988) 662, 541 A.2d 1158

Kaplan v. Kaplan ....... 1/11/89 775 E.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 664, 548 A.2d 645

Little v. Allstate Ins. Co. ............. 12/28/88 311 E.D. Denied No. 3129 (1988) Philadelphia 1987

Maliszewski v. Rendon .. 1/13/89 630 E.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 109, 542 A.2d 170

M.B., Petition of ...... 1/11/89 566 E.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 653, 545 A.2d 380

Mellon Bank (East) Nat. Ass'n, Petition of ... 12/30/88 504 E.D. Denied 378 Pa.Super. (1988) 655, 544 A.2d 1047

Miller, Petition of .... 12/29/88 351 W.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 274, 542 A.2d 1019

Misher v. Bo's Auto Parts, Inc. ................. 1/9/89 722 E.D. Denied 381 Pa.Super. (1988) 665, 548 A.2d 646

Moriens v. Albert Einstein Hosp. ....... 1/10/89 599 E.D. Granted 363 Pa.Super. (1987) (8 E.D. 557, 1989) 526 A.2d 1203

Moyston v. Com. ........ 8/7/87 365 E.D. Denied 356 Pa.Super. (1986) 589, 512 A.2d 52

Muhammad v. Strassburger, McKenna, Messer, Shilobod and Gutnick .............. 1/9/89 422 W.D. Granted 374Pa.Super. (1988) (5 W.D. 613, 1989) 543 A.2d 1138

Paul v. Lankenau Hosp. . 12/12/88 640 E.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 1, 543 A.2d 1148

Perry v. Middle Atlantic Lumbermens Associations ......... 12/29/88 651 E.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 554, 542 A.2d 81

Sagan v. Sagan ........ 9/13/88 81 W.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 631, 541 A.2d 38

Seay v. Prudential Property and Cas. Ins. Co. ............. 1/30/89 746 E.D. Granted 375 Pa.Super. (1988) (10 E.D. 37, 1989) 543 A.2d 1166

Singer v. General Motors Corp ................. 12/30/88 454 E.D. Denied 78 Pa.Super. (1988) 658, 544 A.2d 1049

State Mut. Life Assur. Co. of America, Appeal of ................... 12/29/88 651 E.D. Denied 373 Pa.Super. (1988) 554, 542 A.2d 81

Strassburger, McKenna, Messer, Shilobod and Gutnick, Petition of ................... 1/9/89 422 W.D. Granted 374 Pa.Super. (1988) (5 W.D. 613, 1989) 543 A.2d 1138

Tameka M., In re ....... 2/9/89 25 W.D. Granted 368 Pa.Super. (1988) (14 W.D. 525, 1989) 534 A.2d 782

Vihlidal v. Braun ...... 1/31/89 206 W.D. Granted 371 Pa.Super. (1988) (12 W.D. 565, 1989) 538 A.2d 881

Wertz v. Kephart ....... 12/29/88 351 W.D. Denied 374 Pa.Super. (1988) 274, 542 A.2d 1019

Wilco Electronic Systems, Inc. v. Davis ........ 12/27/88 642 E.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 109, 543 A.2d 1202

Williams v. Com. ....... 1/9/89 528 E.D. Denied 379 Pa.Super. (1988) 667, 545 A.2d 390

Woods v. Com. .......... 1/11/89 193 E.D. Denied 375 Pa.Super. (1988) 626, 541 A.2d 35

Appeal from the Commonwealth Court

Allocatur Disposition Lower Court Docket and Appeal Docket or Title Date Number Docket Citation

Armstrong School Dist. v. Armstrong Educ. Ass'n. ............... 1/20/89 337 W.D. Granted 116 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (10 W.D. 571, 1989) 542 A.2d 1047

Berman v. Manchester Twp. Zoning Hearing Bd. .................. 1/27/89 129 M.D. Denied 115 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 339, 540 A.2d 8

Bortulin v. Harley-Davidson Motor Co., Inc. ...... 12/30/88 418 E.D. Denied 115 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 42, 539 A.2d 906

Chester Upland School Dist. v. Com., Pennsylvania Labor Relations Bd. ........ 10/31/88 924 E.D. Denied 110 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 439, 532 A.2d 925

Com. v. State Conference of State Police Lodges of the Fraternal Order of Police by McCommons ............ 2/6/89 210 M.D. Granted 117 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (9 M.D. 564, 1989) 546 A.2d 697

Com. v. State Conf. of State Police Lodges of the Fraternal Order of Pole by McCommons .... 2/6/89 194 M.D. Granted 117 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (8 M.D. 564, 1989) 546 A.2d 697

Comm., Dept. of Transp. v. Cobb .............. 1/9/89 703 E.D. Denied 540 A.2d 5 (1988)

Comm. Dept. of Transp. v. Cobb .............. 1/9/89 703 E.D. Denied 540 A.2d 5 (1988)

Comm., Dept. of Transp. Bureau of Safety v. Hewitt ............... 2/3/89 168 M.D. Denied 116 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 413, 541 A.2d 1183

Danwell Corp. v. Zoning Hearing Bd. of Plymouth Tp. ......... 12/30/88 442 E.D. Denied 115 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 174, 540 A.2d 588

Gallagher v. Bureau of Corrections .......... 2/6/89 228 M.D. Denied 545 A.2d 981 (1988)

Gardner v. Jenkins .... 12/12/88 776 E.D. Denied 116 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 107, 541 A.2d 406

Henry v. W.C.A.B. (Mayer Pollock Corp.) ....... 1/17/89 796 E.D. Denied 545 A.2d 438 (1988)

Hill v. Kamppi ......... 1/17/89 468 W.D. Denied 545 A.2d 975 (1988)

Jamal v. Comm., Dept. of Corrections .......... 1/31/89 55 M.D. Denied 549 A.2d 1369 (1988)

Joseph Ciccone Sons v. Lower Saucon Tp. Zoning Hearing Bd. ... 12/15/88 652 E.D. Denied 115 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 238, 539 A.2d 942

Kamppi v. Koch Asphalt Co. .................. 1/17/89 468 W.D. Denied 545 A.2d 975 (1988)

Kolesar v. Zoning Hearing Bd. of Borough of Bell Acres ................ 1/17/89 405 W.D. Denied 117 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 299, 543 A.2d 246

Kulick v. Com., Pennsylvania State Harness Racing Com'n. ............... 12/2/88 499 E.D. Denied 115 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 408, 540 A.2d 620

Levis v. Owens ......... 1/31/89 57 M.D. Denied No. 1057 C.D. 1988 (1988)

Lukens Steel Co. v. W.C.A.B. ............. 12/28/88 319 E.D. Denied No. 464 C.D. 1987 (1988)

McGill v. W.C.A.B. ..... 1/17/89 502 W.D. Denied No. 2106 C.D. 1987 (1988)

McKinney v. Commonwealth, Unemployment Compensation Bd. of Review (Yellow Freight Systems, Inc.) ....... 12/27/88 670 E.D. Denied 117 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 168, 543 A.2d 598

Marinari v. New Hanover Tp. .................. 1/17/89 783 E.D. Denied 90 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 601, 496 A.2d 121

Martin v. Haggerty ..... 1/24/89 41 M.D. Denied 548 A.2d 371 (1988) Merida v. Comm., Unemployment Compensation Bd. of Review ............... 1/9/89 401 W.D. Granted 543 A.2d 593 (1988) (4 W.D. 1989)

Monsour v. Department of Transp. ........... 1/31/89 263 W.D. Denied No. 425 M.D. 4 (1988)

Murkey v. Corbin ....... 11/16/88 429 E.D. Denied 115 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 258, 539 A.2d 964

National Fuel Gas Supply Corp., Petition of ... 1/17/89 468 W.D. Denied 545 A.2d 975 (1988)

Notofrancesco v. Westinghouse Elec. Corp. ................ 12/29/88 381 E.D. Denied No. 1282 (1988) C.D. 1986

Penn Equipment Tool Corp. v. Chatham 90, Inc. ................. 1/24/89 302 W.D. Denied 115 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 509, 540 A.2d 986

Pennsylvania Sav. Ass'n v. Com., Dept. of Banking .............. 5/9/88 577 E.D. Denied 105 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 175, 523 A.2d 837

Pocono Green, Inc. v. Board of Sup'rs of Kidder Tp. ........... 1/11/89 717 E.D. Granted 117 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) (3 E.D. 396, 1989) 543 A.2d 1253

Powell, Petition of .... 12/28/88 319 E.D. Denied No. 464 (1988) C.D. 1987

Price v. Com., Crime Victim's Compensation Bd. .................. 1/17/89 517 W.D. Granted 546 A.2d 763 (1988) (9 W.D. 1989)

Schreiber v. Tax Claim Bureau of Butler County . ............. 1/11/89 439 W.D. Denied 545 A.2d 950 (1988)

Schurr v. Lower Southampton Tp. Bd. of Sup'rs ............ 12/1/88 294 E.D. Denied 113 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 630, 537 A.2d 978

Seip v. Millcreek Tp. Sup'rs ............... 1/17/89 457 W.D. Denied 544 A.2d 1091 (1988).

Spotts v. W.C.A.B. (Superior Tube Co.) .. 1/9/89 545 E.D. Denied 116 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 304, 541 A.2d 446 Steinberg v. Horace Longacre, Inc. ....... 10/21/88 493 E.D. Denied No. 1739 (1988) C.D. 1986

Stiner v. Workmen's Comp. Appeal Bd. (Harmar Coal Co.) .... 1/12/89 266 W.D. Granted 106 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) (8 W.D. 30, 1989) 525 A.2d 465

Superior Tube Co., Petition of .......... 1/9/89 545 E.D. Denied 116 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 304, 541 A.2d 446 Tax Claim Bureau of Butler County v. Newkirk .............. 1/11/89 439 W.D. Denied 545 A.2d 950 (1988)

Township of Plymouth v. County of Montgomery . 10/4/88 994 E.D. Denied 109 Pa.Cmwlth. (1987) 200, 531 A.2d 49

Upper Darby Tp. v. Gallagher ............ 11/16/88 621 E.D. Denied 114 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 463, 539 A.2d 463

Walters v. Kamppi ...... 1/17/89 468 W.D. Denied 545 A.2d 975 (1988)

Weis Markets, Inc. v. W.C.A.B .............. 2/20/88 291 E.D. Denied 113 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 533, 537 A.2d 393

Yellow Freight Systems, Inc., Petition of .... 12/27/88 670 E.D. Denied 117 Pa.Cmwlth. (1988) 168, 543 A.2d 598