From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Polk's Lessee v. Minner

Supreme Court of Delaware, Sussex County
Oct 1, 1794
1 Del. Cas. 24 (Del. 1794)

Opinion

October, 1794.


Ejectment. Depositions, taken upon a rule for that purpose before the person mentioned in the rule, offered in evidence, upon proof of regular notice to and attendance of Edward Minner, that the witnesses are sick and have been duly summoned.

Objected that all the defendants should have been notified.


The practice over the water is different from the practice in our courts as to notice; notice here is given to the party (unless the rule provides otherwise) because the attorneys are not generally resident. There the attorney is commonly present and the party not resident. Depositions cannot be read against those who have not had a cross examination; but we will not say whether they shall be evidence until in the course of the trial we see whether Mrs. Thorn is interested in this cause. ( N. B. They were not afterwards read.)

Defendant's counsel offered in evidence an old plat of the lands with an explanation signed and sealed by the names of two, whom plaintiff's witness said were the sheriff and surveyor at that time there, but without being able to tell where it was found, without proof of handwriting and without the seal of any office, and objected to for those reasons. Contra. It was said papers gain authenticity by lapse of time and the proof of so ancient a paper will on that account be dispensed with especially because plaintiff's witness give evidence of such a transaction. 1 Morg.Ess. 140, 1 Wils. 170 were read.

PER CURIAM. Plaintiff having given evidence of such a transaction, you may read the paper, the credibility to be left to the jury.

Point of law saved, but verdict for plaintiff; rule to show cause why a new trial should not be had.


Summaries of

Polk's Lessee v. Minner

Supreme Court of Delaware, Sussex County
Oct 1, 1794
1 Del. Cas. 24 (Del. 1794)
Case details for

Polk's Lessee v. Minner

Case Details

Full title:ZEPHEMIAH POLK'S LESSEE v. EDWARD MINNER and BETTY THORN

Court:Supreme Court of Delaware, Sussex County

Date published: Oct 1, 1794

Citations

1 Del. Cas. 24 (Del. 1794)