From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Phillips v. Marianna Ford Tractor, Inc.

Supreme Court of Arkansas
Sep 29, 1986
716 S.W.2d 763 (Ark. 1986)

Opinion

No. 86-112

Opinion delivered September 29, 1986

APPEAL ERROR — FAILURE TO ORDER TRANSCRIPT — DISMISSAL PROPER. — Where the appellant files a notice of Appeal and designates the entire record, but makes no mention of ordering a transcript, nor does he order the transcript or explain why it was not ordered, even though an extension was granted for filing the transcript, the appeal will be dismissed because of the appellant's unexplained failure to substantially comply with the requirements of Rule 3(e), Arkansas Rules of Appellate Procedure.

Motion to dismiss appeal; motion granted.

Wilson, Bell Neal Law Office, by: J. L. Wilson, for appellant.

Daggett, Van Dover, Donovan Cahoon, by: Robert J. Donovan, for appellee.


Appellee Marianna Ford Tractor, Inc. has moved to dismiss the appeal of Leon Phillips, Jr. for failure to comply with Rule 3(e) of our Rules of Appellate Procedure. Phillips's Notice of Appeal, filed on December 31, 1985, made no mention of having ordered a transcript of the testimony. The Designation of the Contents of the Record, filed the same day, designated all the pleadings, all testimony, all evidence, and all rulings and orders of the trial court as the record on appeal.

Appellee further alleges that on February 28, 1986 Phillips filed a motion for an extension of time for filing the record, and on March 4, an order was entered extending the time for six months. According to a letter from the court reporter, Phillips still had not ordered the transcript as of March 5.

The allegations of appellee's motion to dismiss, filed on July 10, 1986, have not been denied by Phillips, the only response is a motion to file a belated brief filed July 31, 1986.

In Hudson v. Hudson, 277 Ark. 183, 641 S.W.2d 1 (1982), we dismissed an appeal where the entire record was designated, the Notice of Appeal (filed September 21, 1981) failed to state the transcript had been ordered, and the transcript was not in fact ordered from the court reporter until December 7, 1981. The exact situation exists here. There having been an unexplained failure to substantially comply with the requirements of Rule 3 (e) of the Arkansas Rules of Appellate Procedure, the appeal is dismissed.


Summaries of

Phillips v. Marianna Ford Tractor, Inc.

Supreme Court of Arkansas
Sep 29, 1986
716 S.W.2d 763 (Ark. 1986)
Case details for

Phillips v. Marianna Ford Tractor, Inc.

Case Details

Full title:Leon Phillips, Jr. v. Marianna Ford Tractor, Inc

Court:Supreme Court of Arkansas

Date published: Sep 29, 1986

Citations

716 S.W.2d 763 (Ark. 1986)
716 S.W.2d 763

Citing Cases

McElroy v. American Medical

But where the facts show that the appellant has failed to order the transcript in a timely manner we have…