From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

People v. Kohler

Supreme Court of California
Jan 1, 1855
5 Cal. 72 (Cal. 1855)

Opinion

         Appeal from the Tenth Judicial District, Nevada County.

         The prisoner was tried and found guilty of murder. The facts pertinent to the issue are contained in the opinion of the Court.

         COUNSEL:

         Rowe & Dunn, for Appellant.

         The Attorney General, for the People.


         JUDGES: Heydenfeldt, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. Bryan, J., concurred.

         OPINION

          HEYDENFELDT, Judge

         The bill of exceptions shows that after the jury retired, they returned and asked to hear read two depositions of witnesses of the defendant. The depositions were read to them, and this was done during the absence of the prisoner. The rule is familiar that the prisoner, in a case of felony, must be present during the whole of his trial; and reading evidence taken by deposition, although it was done after the jury had retired, is a part of the trial as much as any other. In favor of life, the strictest rule which has any sound reason to sustain it, will not be relaxed.

         The judgment is reversed, and a new trial ordered.


Summaries of

People v. Kohler

Supreme Court of California
Jan 1, 1855
5 Cal. 72 (Cal. 1855)
Case details for

People v. Kohler

Case Details

Full title:The People of the State of California, Respondents, v. Ernest Kohler…

Court:Supreme Court of California

Date published: Jan 1, 1855

Citations

5 Cal. 72 (Cal. 1855)

Citing Cases

People v. O'Brien

ould have been granted. (Pen. Code, secs. 1043, 1181; Benton v. State , 30 Ark. 328-348; State v. Bertin, 24…

People v. Isby

(14 Am.Jur., § 189, p. 898; 7 Cal.Jur., § 75, p. 928; Pen. Code, § 1043.) Accordingly, it has been held in…