Opinion
October 20, 1954.
Appeal from Albany County Court.
Appellant was indicted for the crime of robbery in the first degree and, upon his plea of guilty, he was sentenced as a second offender for a term of from thirty to sixty years. The appellant contends that counsel had not been assigned to him pursuant to section 308 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, despite his request for counsel. The record shows one Pierce J. Ryan had been assigned as counsel for the appellant. Both a notice of assignment of counsel and a notice of trial had been directed to Pierce J. Ryan and acknowledgment of their receipt had been signed by him. However, the clerk's minutes of the proceedings state that one John J. Ryan appeared as counsel for appellant. In an affidavit procured by the appellant, John J. Ryan categorically denied ever having represented appellant. Pierce J. Ryan made an affidavit in which he stated that he had no present recollection of ever having represented appellant but he did not deny that he had represented him nor did he deny the authenticity of his signatures upon the notice of assignment and the notice of trial. The notation of the name John J. Ryan in the clerk's minutes was obviously a clerical error. The record establishes that the appellant had been represented by counsel assigned to him, in the person of Pierce J. Ryan. Appellant has raised no issue which entitles him to a hearing on his motion. Order unanimously affirmed. Bergan, J.P., Coon, Halpern, Imrie and Zeller, JJ., concur.