From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

People v. Grider

Supreme Court of California
Mar 14, 1884
3 P. 492 (Cal. 1884)

Opinion

         Department 2. Appeal from the superior court of Sonoma county.

         The defendant in this case was accused of the crime of grand larceny. Defendant pleaded not guilty. He admitted the taking of money from the pocket of one Carmody, but denied any intent to steal the same. Evidence as to this intent was introduced on both sides. The court ruled that the question of intent was one for the jury, and instructed them if they found a felonious intent, to render a verdict of guilty. The jury found defendant guilty, and from the above ruling and instruction defendant appealed.

          SYLLABUS

         In a prosecution for grand larceny, if the act of taking the property is admitted, but a felonious intent denied, the question of intent is one for the jury.

         Henley & Oates, for appellant.

         The Attorney General, for respondent.


         MYRICK, J., THORNTON, J.; SHARPSTEIN, J.

          OPINION

          MYRICK, J.

         The information accused the defendant and one Donovan of the crime of grand larceny. That the defendant Grider took the money from the pocket of Carmody, when the latter was intoxicated, is admitted. The proposition of Grider was that certain persons engaged in a "game" were endeavoring to obtain the money by means of the game, and that he (Grider) took it as a friend of Carmody to protect it for him. On the other hand, the theory of the prosecution seems to have been that Grider took the money feloniously, with intent to steal it, making use of the other idea as a pretext, or as an afterthought. In that view the ruling of the court and the instructions were correct.

         No error appearing, the judgment and order are affirmed.

         We concur: THORNTON, J.; SHARPSTEIN, J.


Summaries of

People v. Grider

Supreme Court of California
Mar 14, 1884
3 P. 492 (Cal. 1884)
Case details for

People v. Grider

Case Details

Full title:PEOPLE v. GRIDER

Court:Supreme Court of California

Date published: Mar 14, 1884

Citations

3 P. 492 (Cal. 1884)

Citing Cases

People v. Ross

          MYRICK, Judge          [3 P. 492] The remaining facts are stated in the opinion of the court.…