From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Parr-Angell v. City of Northampton

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts
Nov 2, 1960
341 Mass. 729 (Mass. 1960)

Opinion

November 2, 1960.

Melvin Thorner, for the plaintiffs.

Kenneth B. Bowen, City Solicitor, for the defendant.


Decree affirmed with costs of this appeal. The plaintiffs seek by this bill in equity to challenge the legality of proceedings whereby the defendant took by eminent domain a parcel of their land for school purposes. The judge, after finding that the taking was valid, entered a decree dismissing the bill. The plaintiffs appealed. We need not concern ourselves with the correctness of the decision below. It appeared at the argument before us that prior to the commencement of the present suit the plaintiffs brought a petition under G.L.c. 79 for the assessment of damages and that this petition has resulted in a judgment for damages in the plaintiff's favor. It further appeared that execution has issued on the judgment and that on August 26, 1960, it was satisfied in full. In so proceeding the plaintiffs made a final and binding election of their remedy and it is not open to them to pursue the remedy here sought. See Moore v. Sanford, 151 Mass. 285, 287. See also Pinkham v. Chelmsford, 109 Mass. 225, 228-229; Hussey v. Bryant, 95 Maine, 49.


Summaries of

Parr-Angell v. City of Northampton

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts
Nov 2, 1960
341 Mass. 729 (Mass. 1960)
Case details for

Parr-Angell v. City of Northampton

Case Details

Full title:FREDERICK PARR-ANGELL another vs. CITY OF NORTHAMPTON

Court:Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts

Date published: Nov 2, 1960

Citations

341 Mass. 729 (Mass. 1960)
170 N.E.2d 354

Citing Cases

Opinion of the Justices to the Governor

Hatch v. Hawkes, 126 Mass. 177, 181. Parr-Angell v. Northampton, 341 Mass. 729. Acceptance of a settlement…