From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Palmer v. Murray

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
May 8, 1923
215 P. 195 (Okla. 1923)

Opinion

No. 12429

Opinion Filed May 8, 1923.

(Syllabus.)

Appeal and Error — Case-Made — Filing Below — Necessity.

A case-made filed in this court which does not show that it has been filed in the office of the clerk of the trial court is a nullity, and where such a case-made remains in this court after the expiration of the statutory time in which to perfect an appeal, on motion, the appeal will be dismissed.

Error from District Court, Atoka County; J.H. Linebaugh, Judge.

Action between Wilson and Elias Palmer, minors, by their guardian, Watson Palmer, and J.I. Murray and Peter Homer. From the judgment, the former bring error. Dismissed.

I.O. Correll, for plaintiffs in error.

George Trice and J.G. Ralls, for defendants in error.


Came on to be heard in the above-entitled and numbered cause defendants in error's motion to dismiss the appeal herein, upon the grounds that the petition in error does not have attached to it any case-made or certified transcript of the record that was filed in the office of the court clerk of the district court of Atoka county where said cause was originally tried.

The record discloses that the above cause was tried and judgment rendered on the 7th day of January, 1921, in said district court of Atoka county, and that more than six months have expired since rendition of the judgment therein, and that no petition in error with copy of case-made or duly certified copy of the transcript, as required by law, has been filed in this court.

Record discloses that the purported case-made was never filed in the trial court. It, therefore, follows that the motion to dismiss is well taken, and the same must be sustained. Butler v. Chateau et al., 83 Okla. 259, 201 P. 660; Bank v. Watson, 40 Okla. 450, 139 P. 306; Gibbs v. Tanner, 43 Okla. 477, 143 P. 189; Wagnon v. Davidson, 79 Okla. 209, 192 P. 565.

It is ordered that the appeal herein be dismissed.


Summaries of

Palmer v. Murray

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
May 8, 1923
215 P. 195 (Okla. 1923)
Case details for

Palmer v. Murray

Case Details

Full title:PALMER et al. v. MURRAY et al

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: May 8, 1923

Citations

215 P. 195 (Okla. 1923)
89 Okla. 232