From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Orlov v. MacNeil Bros. Company

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts
Mar 22, 1957
335 Mass. 768 (Mass. 1957)

Opinion

March 22, 1957.

Angus M. MacNeil, for the defendant.

Phillip Cowin, for the plaintiffs.


Appeal dismissed. This is a petition by eight of nine defendants in an action by MacNeil Bros. Company against State Realty Company of Boston, Inc., and others, appearing specially, for the discharge of an attachment by trustee process of the goods, effects and credits of three of their number, Messrs. Fox, Orlov and Cowin, in the hands and possession of First National Bank of Boston. G.L. (Ter. Ed.) c. 223, § 114, as appearing in St. 1943, c. 234, § 2. Although no one of the defendants has been served with process the action was entered in the Superior Court on the first Monday of December, 1954. Following a motion to dismiss, judgments were entered in the principal action for Fox, Orlov and Cowin as of February 7, 1955. All petitioners filed a discontinuance of their petition "without prejudice" on March 4, 1955. On March 26, 1956, the respondent (plaintiff in the original action) moved for judgment on the discontinuance. The motion was denied and the petition ordered dismissed as matter of law. From the denial of the motion and the dismissal of the petition the respondent appealed. A motion to dismiss these appeals was allowed and the respondent appealed from the order of dismissal. This appeal is not properly before us. It was from an order entered in a proceeding merely incidental to the principal action which is still pending. Richardson v. Greenhood, 225 Mass. 608. Weiss v. Balaban, 315 Mass. 390, 393.

(The rescript in each of the three companion cases reads: Appeal dismissed. See "brief statement of the grounds and reasons of the decision" accompanying the companion case decided herewith. — REPORTER.)


Summaries of

Orlov v. MacNeil Bros. Company

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts
Mar 22, 1957
335 Mass. 768 (Mass. 1957)
Case details for

Orlov v. MacNeil Bros. Company

Case Details

Full title:MYER L. ORLOV others vs. MacNEIL BROS. COMPANY

Court:Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts

Date published: Mar 22, 1957

Citations

335 Mass. 768 (Mass. 1957)
141 N.E.2d 280

Citing Cases

Levy v. Crawford

The granting of an attachment is incidental to the exploration and determination of the substantive issues in…

Irving Levitt v. Sudbury Management Associates

See W.T. Grant Co. v. Haines, 531 F.2d 671, 678 (2d Cir. 1976), and cases cited; Brastex Corp. v. Allen…