From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Nelson v. Election Board of King County

The Supreme Court of Washington
Jan 6, 1939
85 P.2d 1045 (Wash. 1939)

Opinion

No. 27321. En Banc.

January 6, 1939.

APPEAL AND ERROR — APPELLATE JURISDICTION — CESSATION OF CONTROVERSY — MOOT QUESTIONS. An appeal involving the validity of proceedings for the submission to the electors of a proposition for the formation of a public utility district will be dismissed as raising only a moot question, when, pending the appeal, the proposition was submitted to the electors and rejected.

See 3 Am. Jur. 308.

Appeal from a judgment of the superior court for King county, McDonald, J., entered September 2, 1938, upon sustaining the validity of proceedings for the formation of a public utility district, after a trial on the merits to the court. Appeal dismissed.

W.E. Heidinger, Robert S. Macfarlane, Dean H. Eastman, A.N. Whitlock, Thos. H. Maguire, Edwin C. Matthias, C.S. Albert, Anthony Kane, Green Burnett, Roy F. Shields, and Hayden, Merritt, Summers Bucey, for appellants.

Houghton, Cluck Coughlin, B. Gray Warner, William Hickman Moore, and Edward E. Henry, for respondents.


These cases involve the validity of proceedings, under Laws of 1931, chapter 1, leading up to the submission to the electors of a proposition for the formation of a utility district designated as utility district No. 1 of King county. Pending the appeal of these cases, the proposition was submitted to the electors of the proposed district and rejected. The questions raised on the appeal have, therefore, become moot.

[1] It is submitted by the parties, nevertheless, that the questions involved are of such public importance that the court should retain jurisdiction and render a decision on the merits. But a majority of the court are of the opinion that a decision of the questions would subserve no private or public interest, in that such a decision would have no authoritative value.

The appeal will, therefore, be dismissed without costs.


Summaries of

Nelson v. Election Board of King County

The Supreme Court of Washington
Jan 6, 1939
85 P.2d 1045 (Wash. 1939)
Case details for

Nelson v. Election Board of King County

Case Details

Full title:HERMAN NELSON, Respondent, v. THE ELECTION BOARD OF KING COUNTY et al.…

Court:The Supreme Court of Washington

Date published: Jan 6, 1939

Citations

85 P.2d 1045 (Wash. 1939)
85 P.2d 1045
197 Wash. 626