From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Murphy v. St. Paul Goodwill Industries

Supreme Court of Minnesota
Jun 6, 1969
168 N.W.2d 505 (Minn. 1969)

Opinion

No. 41522.

June 6, 1969.

Workmen's compensation — heart attack — causal relationship between attack and employment — resolution of conflicts in medical testimony.

Certiorari upon the relation of St. Paul Goodwill Industries, employer, and Travelers Insurance Company, its insurer, to review a decision of the Workmen's Compensation Commission awarding compensation against said relators to Marie Murphy, widow of Arthur Murphy, deceased employee. Affirmed.

Michael J. Baglio and Ronald O. W. Ylitalo, for relators.

Daniel B. Gallagher, for respondent.

Heard before Knutson, C. J., and Murphy, Rogosheske, Sheran, and Peterson, JJ.


Certiorari to review a decision of the Workmen's Compensation Commission awarding benefits to the widow and minor dependent children of decedent employee, who died as a result of heart failure while on the job as a driver's helper for relator employer. The commission found from the factual circumstances surrounding decedent's employment at that time and the medical opinion of a cardiologist testifying on behalf of respondent that, notwithstanding his preexisting acute coronary sclerosis, "the employee's work exertion was a precipitating cause of his heart failure." Because we cannot hold that this determinative finding of causal relationship is without evidentiary support, even though equally qualified medical specialists testified on behalf of relators to a different opinion, we affirm. Dudovitz v. Shoppers City, Inc. 282 Minn. 322, 164 N.W.2d 873.

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Murphy v. St. Paul Goodwill Industries

Supreme Court of Minnesota
Jun 6, 1969
168 N.W.2d 505 (Minn. 1969)
Case details for

Murphy v. St. Paul Goodwill Industries

Case Details

Full title:MARIE MURPHY v. ST. PAUL GOODWILL INDUSTRIES AND ANOTHER

Court:Supreme Court of Minnesota

Date published: Jun 6, 1969

Citations

168 N.W.2d 505 (Minn. 1969)
168 N.W.2d 505

Citing Cases

Murphy v. Minnesota Mining Mfg. Co.

Since the commission had before it credible testimony on which to base its findings, and the findings are not…