From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

McLean v. Mackay

Court of Errors and Appeals
Jan 25, 1940
10 A.2d 733 (N.J. 1940)

Opinion

Submitted October 27, 1939 —

Decided January 25, 1940.

On appeal from the Supreme Court.

For the appellant, Abram Waks ( Paul Rittenberg, of counsel).

For the appellees, George S. Sauerbrey ( Milton T. Lasher, of counsel).


The facts in the instant appeal and the procedure below are substantially similar to those in Town of Irvington v. Schneider, 120 N.J.L. 460 ; 121 Id. 542, the latter being the opinion of this court. In that case the conviction of defendant was affirmed in this court. Upon appeal to the United States Supreme Court, the judgment of conviction was reversed. Clara Schneider, Petitioner, v. State ( Town of Irvington), ( United States Supreme Court, No. 11, 1939 Term), 84 L.Ed. Advance Opinions 115. We consider the judgment of the United States Supreme Court in that case to be conclusive upon us in the instant appeal and that we must, therefore, reverse the judgment of our Supreme Court herein.

The judgment appealed from is reversed.

For affirmance — None.

For reversal — THE CHANCELLOR, TRENCHARD, CASE, DONGES, PERSKIE, PORTER, HETFIELD, DEAR, WELLS, WOLFSKEIL, RAFFERTY, HAGUE, JJ. 12.


Summaries of

McLean v. Mackay

Court of Errors and Appeals
Jan 25, 1940
10 A.2d 733 (N.J. 1940)
Case details for

McLean v. Mackay

Case Details

Full title:KATHERINE McLEAN, PROSECUTRIX-APPELLANT, v. HOWARD MACKAY, JUDGE OF THE…

Court:Court of Errors and Appeals

Date published: Jan 25, 1940

Citations

10 A.2d 733 (N.J. 1940)
10 A.2d 733

Citing Cases

Taylor v. State

sissippi and Amendments 1 and 14 of the United States Constitution. City of Blue Island v. Kozul, 379 Ill.…

E.L. Kerns Co. v. Landgraf

If a merchant may freely, fairly, honestly and peacefully compete with other merchants, as is the common…