From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

McGuire v. Ciprioni

Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York, Third Department
Jul 15, 1999
263 A.D.2d 751 (N.Y. App. Div. 1999)

Opinion

July 15, 1999

Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Ceresia Jr., J.), entered May 11, 1998 in Rensselaer County, which granted defendants' motions for summary judgment dismissing the complaint.

Roemer, Wallens Mineaux (Matthew J. Kelly of counsel), Albany, for appellant.

Michael Emminger (David E. Winans of counsel), Albany, for City of Rensselaer, respondent.

Before: CARDONA, P.J., MIKOLL, CREW III, YESAWICH JR. and SPAIN, JJ.


MEMORANDUM AND ORDER


On May 24, 1995, plaintiff tripped and fell on a public sidewalk in front of 211 Washington Street in defendant City of Rensselaer, Rensselaer County, injuring her knee. Alleging that her fall was caused by several loose bricks which had fallen onto the sidewalk from a wall on the adjoining private property, plaintiff commenced this negligence action against the City, as owner of the sidewalk, and defendant John J. Ciprioni, as the owner of the adjoining property. Following discovery, the City moved for summary judgment dismissing the complaint on the ground that it had not received the requisite prior written notice of the defect, and that it had neither actual nor constructive notice thereof. Ciprioni cross-moved for the same relief on the latter ground. Supreme Court granted defendants' motions, and this appeal by plaintiff ensued.

We affirm. As to the City's summary judgment motion, Rensselaer City Charter § 78 (1) provides that no civil action in consequence of an injury resulting from, inter alia, a dangerous or defective sidewalk may be maintained unless the City had prior written notice of the condition and failed to remedy it within a reasonable time thereafter (see, Second Class Cities Law § 244). The City presented uncontroverted evidence that it neither received written notice of the claimed sidewalk defect prior to plaintiff's accident nor had any actual knowledge of the presence of bricks thereon. As to plaintiff's contention that the City had constructive notice of the dangerous condition, there is no longer any such exception to the prior written notice rule (see, Amabile v. City of Buffalo, 93 N.Y.2d 471 [June 8, 1999]).

Turning to Ciprioni's motion, we note that he supported his motion for summary judgment with his own testimony and an affidavit averring that he had no actual knowledge of the claimed defect. He also supplied an affidavit from his tenant at 211 Washington Street, Valerie Green. Green averred that she and her husband were responsible for general maintenance of the property, including mowing the lawn and trimming the hedges, and that in the 12 years she resided there she had never seen any bricks lying on the sidewalk or received complaints concerning same.

Plaintiff failed to rebut this showing with evidence establishing Ciprioni's actual or constructive notice of the claimed defect. Plaintiff relies exclusively on a photograph taken four days after the accident, purportedly depicting weeds and bricks on the sidewalk, from which she speculates that the bricks had been present for a sufficient length of time to raise a question of fact as to constructive notice. We are not persuaded. Notably, plaintiff testified in her deposition that the photograph does not depict the position of the bricks on the night of her fall, explaining that "somebody moved them over". With no other evidence to show the length of time the bricks were on the sidewalk, especially in view of the transitory nature of the defect (see, Horton v. City of Schenectady, 194 A.D.2d 973), plaintiff has not established the existence of a triable issue of fact and, therefore, Ciprioni's motion for summary judgment was also properly granted.

ORDERED that the order is affirmed, with costs.


Summaries of

McGuire v. Ciprioni

Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York, Third Department
Jul 15, 1999
263 A.D.2d 751 (N.Y. App. Div. 1999)
Case details for

McGuire v. Ciprioni

Case Details

Full title:THERESA M. McGUIRE, Appellant, v. JOHN J. CIPRIONI et al., Respondents

Court:Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York, Third Department

Date published: Jul 15, 1999

Citations

263 A.D.2d 751 (N.Y. App. Div. 1999)
692 N.Y.S.2d 865

Citing Cases

Weissman v. City of New York

The cases cited by the City in support of its argument that all sidewalk defects are, as a matter of law,…

Miller v. City of Albany

Nevertheless, plaintiffs rely on Second Class Cities Law § 244 which, unlike Local Law No. 1, precludes an…