Finally, there is no other basis under MCR 2.003 that would require that I be disqualified from participation in this case.          In McCarthy v. Scofield, 486 Mich. 1075, 784 N.W.2d 57 (2010), four justices, including myself, voted to deny plaintiff's application for leave to appeal (although in a separate concurrence, I indicated that I could " understand plaintiff's [488 Mich. 999] frustration with the manner in which the law has operated in his case" ), and plaintiff filed a motion for reconsideration accompanied by a motion to disqualify the four justices who had voted to deny his application. In my statement denying plaintiff's motion for disqualification, I noted

Finally, there is no other basis under MCR 2.003 that would require that I be disqualified from participation in this case. In McCarthy v. Scofield, 486 Mich 1075 (2010), four justices, including myself, voted to deny plaintiffs application for leave to appeal (although in a separate concurrence, I indicated that I could "understand plaintiffs frustration with the manner in which the law has operated in his case"), and plaintiff filed a motion for reconsideration accompanied by a motion to disqualify the four justices who had voted to deny his application. In my statement denying plaintiffs motion for disqualification, I noted