From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Matter of Ricker

Supreme Court, New York Special Term
Mar 1, 1915
89 Misc. 582 (N.Y. Misc. 1915)

Opinion

March, 1915.

Lloyd Maddox, for petitioner, Marguerite Sawyer.

Phoenix Ingraham, guardian ad litem.

Joline, Larkin Rathbone, for Central Trust Company of New York.


Application for an order for the appointment of the Central Trust Company of New York as committee of the property within the state of an incompetent, adjudged so without the state. The petitioner is now the committee of the person and the property appointed by a court of competent jurisdiction in the state of Massachusetts. Section 2326 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides that she may be appointed the committee in this jurisdiction notwithstanding the fact that she is a nonresident. However, she is unwilling to assume that responsibility. The Central Trust Company is not unwilling to accept the appointment, but it has doubt as to the court's power under section 2326 to appoint any one other than the foreign committee, and, further, as to whether the appointment of another person or corporation must proceed under section 2327 under the direction of the court by an inquisition before a jury. I do not think that the objections raised are all sufficient. The power of the court over property belonging to incompetents within its jurisdiction is broad and inherent. The owner of the property in this proceeding has been judicially declared an incompetent. This is conclusively established by an exemplified copy of a judicial record of a court of proper jurisdiction. This record and the decree which it proves are entitled to full faith and credit in every state of the United States. Matter of Curtiss, 134 A.D. 551; Matter of Neally, 26 How. Pr. 402. The status of the incompetent being established; and the decree establishing it being a decree in rem, of which other courts must take cognizance, I am of opinion that there is no need in this court for an inquisition. An inquisition would be a mere empty form and a needless expense, as the fact of incompetence has been already established by a valid judicial record, adequately proved. As the foreign committee has refused to act, section 2326 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides that in such circumstances the court may choose a resident committee. Matter of Bartelme, 34 Misc. 131. Under the circumstances and on the present papers the motion to appoint the Central Trust Company as committee of the incompetent's property in this state is granted.

Application granted.


Summaries of

Matter of Ricker

Supreme Court, New York Special Term
Mar 1, 1915
89 Misc. 582 (N.Y. Misc. 1915)
Case details for

Matter of Ricker

Case Details

Full title:Matter of ELIZABETH M. RICKER

Court:Supreme Court, New York Special Term

Date published: Mar 1, 1915

Citations

89 Misc. 582 (N.Y. Misc. 1915)
153 N.Y.S. 701

Citing Cases

Dean v. Halliburton

The direction or consent of the trial court that the committee be substituted as defendants in place of…