From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Matter of Allen

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Apr 2, 1912
205 N.Y. 158 (N.Y. 1912)

Opinion

Argued March 19, 1912

Decided April 2, 1912

Clarence King, George H. Stover and David O. Decker for appellant.

Archibald R. Watson, Corporation Counsel ( Terence Farley and George P. Nicholson of counsel), for respondent.


This case differs essentially from Matter of Egan (decided herewith), in which we have held that a taxpayer is entitled under section 51 of the General Municipal Law to an inspection of the public documents upon which the commissioners of water supply of the city of New York acted in awarding a contract for the construction of a tunnel under the Hudson river at Storm King. In the opinion in that case it was pointed out that the far-reaching right of inspection conferred upon taxpayers by section 51 of the General Municipal Law might be limited by special statutes relative to public documents in particular departments, such as the board of health in New York. Section 1175 of the Greater New York charter is such a special statute. It provides that the board of health may establish as it shall deem wise and to promote the public good and public service, reasonable regulations "as to the publicity of any of the papers, files, reports, records and proceedings of the department of health." This empowers the board to determine whether any particular document falling within the prescribed category shall or shall not be made public. Pursuant to the authority thus conferred upon it the board has established certain regulations as to the inspection of its records which in our judgment do not exceed its discretionary power under the section cited. The petitioner failed to comply with these rules, and the Appellate Division was, therefore, right in holding that he was not entitled to have his application granted. For these reasons the order appealed from should be affirmed, with costs.

CULLEN, Ch. J., HAIGHT, VANN, HISCOCK, CHASE and COLLIN, JJ., concur.

Order affirmed.


Summaries of

Matter of Allen

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Apr 2, 1912
205 N.Y. 158 (N.Y. 1912)
Case details for

Matter of Allen

Case Details

Full title:In the Matter of the Application of WILLIAM H. ALLEN, Appellant, to…

Court:Court of Appeals of the State of New York

Date published: Apr 2, 1912

Citations

205 N.Y. 158 (N.Y. 1912)
98 N.E. 470

Citing Cases

People ex Rel. Higgins v. Emerson

Such a resolution was adopted by the board on October 28, 1903. This resolution regulates the right of…

McGowan v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Co.

But we think that a greater degree of protection may properly be required for records of the department of…