From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Martin B. Brown Co. v. Yardum

Supreme Court — Appellate Term
May 1, 1898
23 Misc. 762 (N.Y. App. Term 1898)

Opinion

May, 1898.

Theodore A. Swan, for appellant.

Elek J. Ludvigh, for respondent.


The only questions involved upon this appeal arise from a determination of facts upon the trial of this cause. And these were: 1. That the work was done for one D.M. Bedikian, and not the defendant. 2. That the work was defective and not worth the sum charged. The justice determined, as we assume from the judgment, that the 2,000 copies of the Armenian-English Manual or Dictionary, for the printing of which and the materials furnished therefor, this action was brought, were rendered and furnished at the request of the defendant. Although we might have arrived at a different conclusion, yet there was sufficient evidence in the case to support a finding either way, and the justice having found for the plaintiff upon a conflict of evidence, we see no reason for disturbing such determination in the absence of the elements which are requisite to a review of the facts. The justice had the witnesses before him, observed their manner of testifying, and therefore, was undoubtedly better able to judge of their credibility and of the weight to be given to their testimony than is this appellate court.

The defendant claims that the books werre imperfectly cut and bound, but having retained them after discovering such alleged defects, he is bound by his acceptance thereof, and hence is not entitled to any deduction from the price. Moreover, there was a conflict of evidence upon the question as to the cause of such imperfections, which the justice resolved in favor of the plaintiff.

For these reasons the judgment should be affirmed, with costs.

Present: BEEKMAN, P.J., GILDERSLEEVE and GIEGERICH, JJ.

Judgment affirmed, with costs.


Summaries of

Martin B. Brown Co. v. Yardum

Supreme Court — Appellate Term
May 1, 1898
23 Misc. 762 (N.Y. App. Term 1898)
Case details for

Martin B. Brown Co. v. Yardum

Case Details

Full title:THE MARTIN B. BROWN CO., Respondent, v . ARMEN YARDUM, Appellant

Court:Supreme Court — Appellate Term

Date published: May 1, 1898

Citations

23 Misc. 762 (N.Y. App. Term 1898)