From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Lockley v. Robie

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Jul 11, 1950
93 N.E.2d 895 (N.Y. 1950)

Opinion

Argued May 17, 1950

Decided July 11, 1950

Appeal from the Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Fourth Department, VAN DUSER, J.

W. Clyde O'Brien for appellant.

William MacFarlane for respondents.


In this action, which involves primarily the two principal stockholders of the corporate defendant, and wherein plaintiff seeks restoration of his former status and rights in said corporation, based largely upon the oral agreement of August 1, 1941, we are of the opinion that the weight of the evidence supports the findings and determination of Special Term, excepting with respect to the failure to declare dividends (Special Term's findings 51 and 53; subdivision 6 of first decretal paragraph of its judgment). The Appellate Division properly reversed said findings and ruled that upon this record the refusal of the directors to declare dividends cannot be said to have been arbitrary or in bad faith ( City Bank Farmers Trust Co. v. Hewitt Realty Co., 257 N.Y. 62). Special Term also erred (subdivision 8 of first decretal paragraph of its judgment) in directing defendant George F. Robie, in this action, to repay to the corporate defendant "the sum of fourteen hundred dollars ($1400) heretofore paid to him out of corporate funds as a payment on the purchase price of an automobile personally purchased by George F. Robie", as this is not a stockholder's derivative action.

Accordingly, the judgment of the Appellate Division and that of Special Term should be modified in accordance with the opinion herein and, as so modified, affirmed, with costs in this court and in the Appellate Division.

LEWIS, CONWAY and DYE, JJ., concur with FROESSEL, J.; LOUGHRAN, Ch. J., DESMOND and FULD, JJ., dissent on the ground that the findings of the Appellate Division are in accord with the weight of the evidence.

Judgment accordingly. [See 301 N.Y. 731.]


Summaries of

Lockley v. Robie

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Jul 11, 1950
93 N.E.2d 895 (N.Y. 1950)
Case details for

Lockley v. Robie

Case Details

Full title:LLOYD F. LOCKLEY, Appellant, v. GEORGE F. ROBIE et al., Respondents

Court:Court of Appeals of the State of New York

Date published: Jul 11, 1950

Citations

93 N.E.2d 895 (N.Y. 1950)
93 N.E.2d 895

Citing Cases

Weber v. Sidney

Certainly, the defendant Sidney, reaping and retaining over the years the advantages and benefits of the…

Teperman v. Amron

This defense is insufficient, since fact issues are not a bar to such relief (see Rules Civ. Prac., rule 213,…