From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Lashley v. Centerville-Abington Community Schools

Court of Appeals of Indiana
Mar 20, 1973
155 Ind. App. 556 (Ind. Ct. App. 1973)

Opinion

No. 1-872A57.

Filed March 20, 1973.

1. APPEAL — Assignment of Errors — Appellate Complaint. — The assignment of errors is the appellant's complaint in the appellate tribunal. p. 557.

2. APPEAL — Jurisdiction — Assignment of Errors. — An assignment of errors is necessary to give the appellate tribunal jurisdiction of the appeal; where there is no assignment of error, the case must be dismissed. p. 557.

3. APPEAL — Jurisdiction — Filing of Record and Assignment of Errors. — The timely filing of the record and the assignment of errors is a jurisdictional act. p. 558.

4. APPEAL — Jurisdiction — Motion to Correct Errors — Assignment of Errors. — Where appellant failed to file either a motion to correct errors or an assignment of errors, appellant did not invoke the jurisdiction of the Court of Appeals and did not present any question on appeal. p. 558.

Appeal from an interlocutory order overruling appellant's objection to appellee's complaint for condemnation of real estate for school purposes.

From the Wayne Circuit Court, James C. Puckett, Judge.

Cause dismissed by the First District.

Richard E. Boston, Harlan, Schussler Keller, of Richmond for appellant.

P. Thomas Snow, Willard G. Bowen, Bowen, Cecere, O'Maley Tripp, of Richmond, for appellee.


ON APPELLEE'S MOTION TO DISMISS


This cause is before the Court on the appellee's Motion to Dismiss Appeal, which alleges as cause therefor that the appellant failed to file a Motion to Correct Errors in the trial court as required by TR. 59(G).

This appeal is from an interlocutory order of the trial court overruling appellant's objections to appellee's complaint for condemnation of real estate for school purposes and appointing appraisers. Appellant argues in response to the motion to dismiss, that the order being appealed from is an interlocutory order and therefore by reason of the exclusion provided for in TR. 59(G), a motion to correct errors is not required to be filed, but appellate jurisdiction can be invoked by an assignment of errors filed in the higher court.

It now appears from the record herein that appellant did not file either a motion to correct errors in the trial court or an assignment of errors in this Court. The record of the proceedings in this cause was filed on November 1, 1972, within the time for filing the same as extended by Order of this Court. Thereafter, on January 5, 1973, appellant filed her Petition For Leave To File Assignment of Errors and tendered therewith for filing an Assignment of Errors.

The Assignment of Errors is the appellant's complaint in the appellate tribunal. McCrary v. State (1961), 241 Ind. 518, 173 N.E.2d 300. An Assignment of Errors is necessary to [1, 2] give the appellate tribunal jurisdiction of the appeal. Where there is no Assignment of Error, the case must be dismissed. McCrary v. State, supra; State ex rel. Spelde v. Minker (1963), 244 Ind. 421, 193 N.E.2d 365; Indiana State Personnel Board v. Parkman (1968), 142 Ind. App. 255, 233 N.E.2d 798.

The timely filing of the record and the Assignment of Errors has long been held to be a jurisdictional act. In re Estate of Meredith; Alt v. Skidmore, Admx. (1966), 138 Ind. App. [3] 458, 214 N.E.2d 659; Wiltrout, Indiana Practice, Vol. 3, § 2471, p. 252 and cases cited; Bobbitt, Indiana Appellate Practice and Procedure, Vol. 1, pp. 504, 505, and cases cited.

Having failed to file either a Motion to Correct Errors or an Assignment of Errors, the appellant has not invoked the jurisdiction of this Court and has not presented any [4] question on appeal. Accordingly, the appellee's Motion to Dismiss is sustained, and this cause is dismissed.

NOTE. — Reported at 293 N.E.2d 519.


Summaries of

Lashley v. Centerville-Abington Community Schools

Court of Appeals of Indiana
Mar 20, 1973
155 Ind. App. 556 (Ind. Ct. App. 1973)
Case details for

Lashley v. Centerville-Abington Community Schools

Case Details

Full title:ELIZABETH LASHLEY v. CENTERVILLE-ABINGTON COMMUNITY SCHOOLS

Court:Court of Appeals of Indiana

Date published: Mar 20, 1973

Citations

155 Ind. App. 556 (Ind. Ct. App. 1973)
293 N.E.2d 519

Citing Cases

Moore v. Spann

" Numerous cases since January 1, 1970 have recited that the timely filing of a motion to correct errors with…

Costanzi v. Ryan

Hospital argues that Costanzi's failure to include an assignment of errors in the record at time of filing…