From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Landon v. First National Stores

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts
Dec 1, 1967
353 Mass. 756 (Mass. 1967)

Opinion

December 1, 1967.

John P. Donovan for the plaintiff.

Robert D. Callahan for the defendant.


The minor plaintiff brought this action in tort to recover for injuries sustained in a fall in the defendant's store. She is here on her exception to the allowance of the defendant's motion that the court enter a verdict for the defendant in accordance with leave reserved. The plaintiff was observed to fall in an aisle in the store, and contemporaneously a cardboard carton, which had been stacked with others similar in type in the aisle some thirty-five or forty minutes before by an employee of the defendant, was seen "spinning Page 757 in a circle rather fast" within two feet of the plaintiff's feet. There was no evidence of the direct cause of the plaintiff's fall which could be assigned only through conjecture or speculation. The record discloses no evidence of a failure of the defendant in its duty to the plaintiff as a business invitee.

Exceptions overruled.


Summaries of

Landon v. First National Stores

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts
Dec 1, 1967
353 Mass. 756 (Mass. 1967)
Case details for

Landon v. First National Stores

Case Details

Full title:MELANIE E. LANDON vs. FIRST NATIONAL STORES, INC

Court:Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts

Date published: Dec 1, 1967

Citations

353 Mass. 756 (Mass. 1967)
231 N.E.2d 575

Citing Cases

Shahzade v. C.J. Mabardy, Inc.

In the absence of any such evidence, the judge properly refused to submit the issue to the jury, as the jury…

Murray v. Greene

This showing must be supported by something other than conjecture or speculation. See Borden v. BettyGibson…