From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Lagerveld v. Nathan Doblin Corp.

Supreme Court of New Jersey
Jun 28, 1948
59 A.2d 809 (N.J. 1948)

Opinion

Submitted May 3, 1948 —

Decided June 28, 1948.

Held, in this case, that the petitioner had suffered a heart attack and had not sustained the burden of establishing an accident arising out of and in the course of his employment.

On certiorari.

Before Justices DONGES, COLIE and EASTWOOD.

For the prosecutor, David Cohn ( Abram Simon, of counsel).

For the respondent, Toner, Speakman Crowley ( G. Dixon Speakman, of counsel).


This is a workmen's compensation case. The Bureau entered an award in favor of the petitioner, which, on appeal, the Passaic County Court of Common Pleas reversed. A writ of certiorari was allowed and the matter is now before us for determination.

Taking the most favorable view of the testimony from the prosecutor's point of view, it discloses, and we find as a fact, that on the date of the heart attack, petitioner was doing his ordinary work. While carrying a basket weighing approximately 60 pounds, he felt a pain and shortly thereafter broke into a sweat and sat down. He reported to the office and was given a drink of whiskey and after resting for a few moments, went home. His attending physician diagnosed his condition as a heart attack. The Court of Common Pleas found that the petitioner had not sustained the burden of establishing an accident arising out of and in the course of his employment. With this finding we are in complete accord. Gilbert v. Gilbert Machine Works, 122 N.J.L. 533. Moreover, we find that the petitioner has not shown an accident within the meaning of the statute. Lohndorf v. Peper Bros. Paint Co., 134 Id. 156; affirmed, 135 Id. 352.

The writ is dismissed, with costs.


Summaries of

Lagerveld v. Nathan Doblin Corp.

Supreme Court of New Jersey
Jun 28, 1948
59 A.2d 809 (N.J. 1948)
Case details for

Lagerveld v. Nathan Doblin Corp.

Case Details

Full title:SEBASTIAN LAGERVELD, PROSECUTOR, v. NATHAN DOBLIN CORPORATION, RESPONDENT

Court:Supreme Court of New Jersey

Date published: Jun 28, 1948

Citations

59 A.2d 809 (N.J. 1948)
59 A.2d 809

Citing Cases

Swan v. Williamson

Sec. 72-1013, I.C.; In re Carrie (Carrie v. Carrie), 73 Idaho 503, 254 P.2d 410; Le Viness v. Mauer, Fla., 53…

Seiken v. Todd Dry Dock, Inc.

The court said that even conceding that on that day, the rolling up of pony wheels was hard labor, it was…