From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Knice v. Hedges

Supreme Court, New York Trial Term
Jun 1, 1922
119 Misc. 1 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1922)

Opinion

June, 1922.

Samuel Deutsch, for plaintiff.

Winthrop Stimson ( Paul A. McQuaid, of counsel), for defendant.


This is an application to set aside a verdict. Upon an examination of the jurors in this case it appears that one Lyons was accepted by both parties and sworn. Subsequently this juror was again called in the case of Barskop v. Dry Dock, East Broadway Battery Railroad Company, when he was again interrogated by the counsel in that case, and stated very frankly that his father had been injured in a railroad accident, whereupon he was excused. In the case at issue he did not make this statement, although questions were asked by counsel as to whether any of the jurors had been or were interested in any negligence action or had any relative who had been injured. Upon an examination conducted by me this juror was interrogated both by counsel in the case and myself, and he claimed that he did not hear any question asked of that kind; that he was not prejudiced and did not attempt to conceal. Another juror stated that he had a sister who had been injured and was excused. It was the duty of the juror to have informed counsel of the fact that his father had been injured, although the question may not have been directed to him. His failure to do so was concealment. I do not charge the juror with any corrupt act in maintaining silence. It has been repeatedly held that such conduct was prejudicial to the interests of the defendant. See M'Garry v. City of Buffalo, 24 N.Y.S. 16; Slater v. United Traction Co., 172 A.D. 404; Baccelli v. Booth, 75 Misc. 260; Harris v. Eclipse Light Co., 114 id. 399. The motion to set aside the verdict must be granted. Settle order on notice.

Ordered accordingly.


Summaries of

Knice v. Hedges

Supreme Court, New York Trial Term
Jun 1, 1922
119 Misc. 1 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1922)
Case details for

Knice v. Hedges

Case Details

Full title:MARY KNICE, Plaintiff, v . JOB HEDGES, as Receiver, etc., Defendant

Court:Supreme Court, New York Trial Term

Date published: Jun 1, 1922

Citations

119 Misc. 1 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1922)
194 N.Y.S. 657

Citing Cases

Cuneo v. New York Presbyt. Hosp.

It is a cardinal principle of our common law that trial jurors shall be entirely unbiased; and when bias is…

Steubing v. Krischer

Regardless of which party prevailed and what the size of the verdict the question involved on this state of…