Opinion
No. 5273.
December 11, 1934.
Appeal from the District Court of the United States for the Western District of Pennsylvania; Robert M. Gibson, Judge.
Decree (Litzinger v. Butler County Oil Refining Co., 9 F. Supp. 437) affirmed.
H.F. Stambaugh, C. Roy Keitzer, Ralph H. Demmler, and Watson Freeman, all of Pittsburgh, Pa., for appellant.
James E. Marshall and A.R. Cingolani, both of Butler, Pa., Walter Braham, of New Castle, Pa., and Brandon, Brandon Ross, Marshall McCandless, and Zeno F. Henninger, all of Butler, Pa., for appellees.
Before BUFFINGTON, WOOLLEY, and DAVIS, Circuit Judges.
This bill in equity sought to have the proceeds of certain accounts collected, and certain personal property sold, which came into the hands of the receiver of an insolvent company, decreed to belong to the plaintiff in such bill. He alleged such accounts and property had been assigned to him. The receiver claimed the assignment was an attempt to give the plaintiff an unlawful preference, and that neither the accounts nor the property were ever taken possession of by the plaintiff. The case was heard by the judge below, the facts found, and a decree was entered discharging the bill.
The testimony was voluminous, and the law and proofs were discussed at full length by the trial judge. As the case stands on its own facts, as no principles or precedents are involved, and we find no error in the court's decree, we limit ourselves to affirming the case on the trial judge's opinion.