From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Keenan v. Perrault

Supreme Court of New Hampshire Strafford
Feb 2, 1904
57 A. 335 (N.H. 1904)

Opinion

Decided February 2, 1904.

An action of trespass to the person is not to be dismissed merely because the trustee blank in the original writ was filled out with a fictitious name, with no intention of having the process served upon a trustee and with no such service in fact made.

TRESPASS, for assault. The action was commenced by trustee writ, in which the name of John Smith was inserted as trustee. The writ was not served upon any one as a trustee, and there was no such person as Smith intended. The name was inserted in the writ simply to fill out the blank and for no other purpose. Upon the defendant's motion, the court dismissed the action upon the ground that it was improperly begun by trustee process, and the plaintiff excepted. Transferred from the September term, 1904, of the superior court by Stone, J.

Felker Gunnison, for the plaintiff.

Elmer J. Smart, for the defendant.


As the trustee blank in the writ was filled out with a fictitious name, with no intention of having it served as a trustee writ, and as it was not in fact served upon a trustee, the action was not "begun by trustee process" within the meaning of section 1, chapter 345, Public Statutes. Clement v. Clement, 18 N.H. 611, Cole v. Smith, 61 N.H. 643. It is as though the trustee part of the writ had been left entirely blank, in which case the officer would have performed his duty by serving it as a writ of summons and attachment. P. S., c. 219, s. 2; Laws 1893, c. 67, s. 6. The order dismissing the action, therefore, on the ground that it was begun by trustee process, was error.

Exception sustained.

All concurred.


Summaries of

Keenan v. Perrault

Supreme Court of New Hampshire Strafford
Feb 2, 1904
57 A. 335 (N.H. 1904)
Case details for

Keenan v. Perrault

Case Details

Full title:KEENAN v. PERRAULT

Court:Supreme Court of New Hampshire Strafford

Date published: Feb 2, 1904

Citations

57 A. 335 (N.H. 1904)
57 A. 335

Citing Cases

LaCoss v. Lebanon

tever is reasonably necessary to do justice between the parties, for the question of the result any given…