From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Jones v. Shoemaker

Supreme Court of Alabama
Jun 18, 1970
237 So. 2d 103 (Ala. 1970)

Opinion

3 Div. 451.

June 18, 1970.

Appeal from the Circuit Court of Conecuh County, In Equity, T. Werth Thagard, Special Judge.

J. B. Nix, Jr., Evergreen, for appellants.

Edwin C. Page, Jr., Evergreen, for appellees.

In an equity case appealed to the Supreme Court the transcript must be filed in the Clerk's office within sixty (60) days from the taking of the appeal, unless the time is extended. 2 Ala. Digest, Appeal and Error, 627(1); Supreme Court Rule 37; Code of Alabama, Tit. 7, § 769; Arthur H. Bodiford v. Dave L. Ganus, 281 Ala. 244, 201 So.2d 400; State for Use of Russell County v. Fourth Natl. Bank of Columbus, Ga., 270 Ala. 135, 117 So.2d 145; Smith v. Alverson, 270 Ala. 628, 120 So.2d 898; Duke v. Barth, 273 Ala. 178, 136 So.2d 927. A decree fixing the right of the parties is the final decree, and appeal must be made within six (6) months, thereof. 2 Ala. Digest, Appeal Error, 80(1); 2A Ala. Digest, Appeal Error, 870(1); O'Rear v. O'Rear, 227 Ala. 403, 150 So. 502; Stokes v. Hart, 273 Ala. 279, 139 So.2d 300; Foshee v. Mims, 279 Ala. 414, 186 So.2d 129; Williams et als. v. Knight, 233 Ala. 42, 169 So. 871; Code of Alabama 1940, Tit. 7, § 788; Bedwell et al. v. Dean et als., 221 Ala. 224, 128 So. 389.


This is an attempted appeal from a decree rendered in a boundary line dispute.

On January 9, 1970, the respondents below (appellants here) filed a notice of appeal, and applied for an order fixing the amount required for a supersedeas bond which was fixed by the court on that same day at $2,000.00.

On January 20, 1970, the appellants filed security for costs of appeal, and also filed a supersedeas bond in the amount of $2,000.00.

The transcript of the record was filed in this court on April 9, 1970. Appellants' brief was filed on May 25, 1970, within the extension of time granted by this court. No oral argument was requested.

On June 4, 1970, counsel for appellees filed a motion to dismiss this appeal on two grounds, (1) that the transcript of the record was not filed in this court within sixty days from the time of taking the appeal as required by Supreme Court Rule 37, and (2) that the appeal was not taken within six months from the rendition of the decree in the lower court as required by Section 788, Title 7, Code of Alabama 1940.

The cause was submitted on June 4, 1970 on motion to dismiss, and on the merits.

The date of the taking of the appeal in this case was January 20, 1970, the day on which security for costs of appeal was filed. Danley v. Danley, 263 Ala. 390, 82 So.2d 534.

The transcript of the record therefore should have been filed in this court within sixty days after January 20, 1970, or on or before March 21, 1970, no extensions of time for filing the record in this court having been sought, nor in the court below. Supreme Court Rule 37; Section 769, Title 7, Code of Alabama 1940; Bodiford v. Ganus, 281 Ala. 244, 201 So.2d 400.

It is clear that Ground 1 of appellees' motion to dismiss this appeal is valid, and necessitates a dismissal of this appeal. Nettles v. Nettles, 283 Ala. 457, 218 So.2d 269.

This being so, no need arises to consider Ground 2 of the motion.

Record stricken; appeal dismissed.

LIVINGSTON, C. J., and LAWSON, MERRILL and McCALL, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

Jones v. Shoemaker

Supreme Court of Alabama
Jun 18, 1970
237 So. 2d 103 (Ala. 1970)
Case details for

Jones v. Shoemaker

Case Details

Full title:Ethel JONES and Thelma Jones v. Joseph P. SHOEMAKER and Tralice M…

Court:Supreme Court of Alabama

Date published: Jun 18, 1970

Citations

237 So. 2d 103 (Ala. 1970)
237 So. 2d 103