From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Johnson v. Augsbury Organization, Inc.

Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York, Third Department
Nov 29, 1990
167 A.D.2d 783 (N.Y. App. Div. 1990)

Summary

holding that a real estate mortgage “is collateral security for the payment of a debt; it is person property, not real property” and does not create “an interest or estate in the mortgaged real property”

Summary of this case from Stillwater Liquidating LLC v. Net Five at Palm Pointe, LLC (In re Stillwater Asset Backed Offshore Fund Ltd.)

Opinion

November 29, 1990

Appeal from the Supreme Court, Franklin County (Plumadore, J.).


Plaintiffs hold mortgages on real property located on Lake Street in the Village of Tupper Lake, Franklin County. Tupper Lake Supply, Inc. had previously conveyed this property to Keith Lawrence and Kathleen Lawrence, who purchased the property subject to a mortgage subsequently assigned to plaintiffs Joan Ann Delair, Stanley M. Johnson, Marjorie A. Johnson, William C. Johnson, Jr., and Jane O. Johnson. Additionally, the Lawrences obtained a second mortgage on the property from Daniel Dattola and plaintiffs James P. Dattola and Ricky J. Dattola.

In 1986, judgments obtained by defendants against Daniel Dattola were entered in the County Clerk's office. Shortly thereafter, Daniel Dattola assigned his mortgage interest to James Dattola and Ricky Dattola.

When their business failed, the Lawrences conveyed their interest in the property to plaintiff David W. Johnson, as trustee for the holders of the first and second mortgages as their mortgage interests may appear. Then, in an effort to prevent defendants from asserting any claim to the subject real property, David Johnson, as trustee for the mortgagees and the mortgagees individually, commenced this RPAPL article 15 action and moved for summary judgment. Defendants countered, arguing that their interest in the mortgage, assertedly fraudulently conveyed by Daniel Dattola, should not be summarily extinguished without the benefit of discovery to determine whether his transfer of his one-third mortgage interest to Ricky Dattola and James Dattola constituted a fraudulent conveyance in violation of Debtor and Creditor Law §§ 273, 273-a, 275 and 276. Supreme Court disagreed and determined that because the judgments were liens on personal indebtedness, defendants held no RPAPL article 15 interest in the subject realty. And even accepting, for purposes of this argument, defendants' claim that Daniel Dattola fraudulently assigned his mortgage interest, we agree.

A lien is nothing more than a right or claim against a property interest (see, Black's Law Dictionary 922 [5th ed 1990]). Entering a money judgment creates a lien on any real property of the judgment debtor (CPLR 5203). A real estate mortgage is collateral security for the payment of a debt; it is personal property, not real property. Mortgages convey no title. They "giv[e] rise only to a lien upon the land" (3A Warren's Weed, New York Real Property, Mortgages, § 1.08 [4th ed 1987]). For this reason, defendants' lien on Daniel Dattola's mortgage interest is simply a lien on a lien and is insufficient to create an interest or estate in the mortgaged real property (see, Stickler v. Ryan, 270 App. Div. 962, lv. dismissed 296 N.Y. 735).

Order and judgment affirmed, with costs. Mahoney, P.J., Casey, Yesawich, Jr., Levine and Harvey, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

Johnson v. Augsbury Organization, Inc.

Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York, Third Department
Nov 29, 1990
167 A.D.2d 783 (N.Y. App. Div. 1990)

holding that a real estate mortgage “is collateral security for the payment of a debt; it is person property, not real property” and does not create “an interest or estate in the mortgaged real property”

Summary of this case from Stillwater Liquidating LLC v. Net Five at Palm Pointe, LLC (In re Stillwater Asset Backed Offshore Fund Ltd.)
Case details for

Johnson v. Augsbury Organization, Inc.

Case Details

Full title:DAVID W. JOHNSON, as Trustee for STANLEY M. JOHNSON and Others, et al.…

Court:Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York, Third Department

Date published: Nov 29, 1990

Citations

167 A.D.2d 783 (N.Y. App. Div. 1990)
563 N.Y.S.2d 339

Citing Cases

N.Y.C. Energy Efficiency Corp. v. Suria

These cases all relate to issues regarding lis pendens and ownership of corporate shares, which is distinct…

Thomas v. Thomas

At Section IV (Assets), (G) Real Estate of the statement of networth as provided at 22 NYCRR 202.16(B) Subch…