From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Jen-Pac Travel Service, Inc. v. Fung Lee Kwong Co.

Supreme Court of Hawaii
Jun 20, 1991
814 P.2d 393 (Haw. 1991)

Opinion

NO. 14831

June 20, 1991

APPEAL FROM THE FIRST CIRCUIT COURT.

LUM, C.J., PADGETT, HAYASHI, WAKATSUKI, AND MOON, JJ.

Phillip J. French ( Grant K. Kidani and Robert S.N. Young, Kidani-Crudele, on the opening brief; and David C. Schutter and Paul D. Hicks with him on the reply brief, Schutter Glickstein) for appellant.

Jack C. Morse for appellee.


This is an appeal from a summary judgment entered below in a contract action. We reverse because the trial court did not have jurisdiction of the case.

The principal amount of the loan sued on was alleged to be $3,459.60. Counsel for the appellee concedes, and we hold, that since the principal amount was less than $5,000, the circuit court had no jurisdiction under HRS § 604-5(a). That section specifically provides that interest, attorney's fees and costs cannot be included in calculating the jurisdictional amount. Reversed and remanded with instructions to dismiss the case.


Summaries of

Jen-Pac Travel Service, Inc. v. Fung Lee Kwong Co.

Supreme Court of Hawaii
Jun 20, 1991
814 P.2d 393 (Haw. 1991)
Case details for

Jen-Pac Travel Service, Inc. v. Fung Lee Kwong Co.

Case Details

Full title:JEN-PAC TRAVEL SERVICE, INC., Plaintiff-Appellee, v. FUNG LEE KWONG…

Court:Supreme Court of Hawaii

Date published: Jun 20, 1991

Citations

814 P.2d 393 (Haw. 1991)
814 P.2d 393

Citing Cases

Wong v. General Telcourier, Inc.

We conclude that the district court had jurisdiction. The only relevant Hawaii precedent is Jen-Pac Travel…