From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Isler v. Brown et al

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jun 1, 1873
69 N.C. 125 (N.C. 1873)

Opinion

(June Term, 1873.)

When an appeal is taken from the final judgment of the Superior to the Supreme Court, the whole case is taken up to the latter Court, and if the judgment be affirmed, remains there, so that the Judge of the Superior Court has no power to set aside the judgment upon the ground of mistake, c., under the 133 section of the C. C. P.

This was an APPLICATION under the C. C. P., sec. 133, made to the Judge of the Superior Court of JONES county, to set aside a judgment between the parties upon the ground that it had been obtained by a mistake. His Honor, Clarke, J., made order to set the judgment aside and granted a new trial at the last term of the Court, and the plaintiff appealed. The case is sufficiently stated in the opinion of the Court.

Green, for the plaintiff.

Haughton and Battle Son, for the defendants.


At a former term of the Court below there had been judgment against the plaintiff, and he appealed to this Court, and at _____ Term of this Court there was a new trial granted; and at Spring Term, 1872, of the Court below there was judgment for plaintiff, and the defendant appealed; and at the June Term of this Court the judgment was affirmed, and judgment here for plaintiff; 67 N.C. 175.

At Spring Term, 1873, of the Court below, the defendant moved to vacate the judgment rendered against him at Spring Term, 1872, upon the ground of mistake under C. C. P. sec. 133, and his Honor vacated the judgment and granted a new trial, from which the plaintiff appealed to this Court.

In this there was error. There was no judgment below which his Honor could vacate. The appeal to this Court vacated the judgment below, and then there was judgment in this Court at June Term, 1872, in favor of the plaintiff.

There being no judgment below to vacate, and his Honor having no power to vacate the judgment of this Court, it follows that the order below vacating the judgment and granting a new trial was erroneous.

This will be certified.

PER CURIAM. Order reversed.


Summaries of

Isler v. Brown et al

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jun 1, 1873
69 N.C. 125 (N.C. 1873)
Case details for

Isler v. Brown et al

Case Details

Full title:STEPHEN.W. ISLER v . ISAAC BROWN et al

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Jun 1, 1873

Citations

69 N.C. 125 (N.C. 1873)

Citing Cases

Hinson v. Adrian

The appeal arrests all proceedings in the court below upon the judgment appealed from, but does not withdraw…

State v. Dewey

It is only when the judgment is final and (560) disposes of the entire controversy that an appeal transfers…