From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Irwin v. Downie

Supreme Court of Georgia
Sep 24, 1968
163 S.E.2d 749 (Ga. 1968)

Opinion

24827.

SUBMITTED SEPTEMBER 12, 1968.

DECIDED SEPTEMBER 24, 1968.

Habeas corpus. Montgomery Superior Court. Before Judge O'Connor.

Hal Irwin, pro se. Arthur K. Bolton, Attorney General, Marion O. Gordon, Mathew Robins, Assistant Attorneys General, for appellee.


His petition seeking discharge by writ of habeas corpus having been dismissed, Hal Irwin appeals to this court. The petition, filed in the Superior Court of Montgomery County, named as respondent J. L. Downie, Warden of the Montgomery Prison Branch. It alleged, insofar as necessary to recite here, that, pursuant to sentences not specified, he is confined within a prison unit which is unhealthy, injurious and dangerous to his health by reason of specified conditions, which constitutes cruel and inhumane punishment forbidden by the State and Federal Constitutions. The petition prayed, in addition to service and rule nisi, that he be discharged from custody of the respondent.

The trial court properly dismissed this petition for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted.

Nowhere does it allege that the sentences under which the applicant is detained are void for any reason. Rather, the petition urges that the conditions of the prison where he is confined are unsanitary. Assuming for the sake of the argument that this is true, correction is not to be had by discharging applicant, upon habeas corpus, from serving the sentences imposed upon him. The rule is well established that the writ of habeas corpus "is an appropriate remedy only when the sentence under which the applicant is being detained is for some reason absolutely void..." Archer v. Grimes, 222 Ga. 8, 9 ( 148 S.E.2d 395), and citations.

Judgment affirmed. All the Justices concur.

SUBMITTED SEPTEMBER 12, 1968 — DECIDED SEPTEMBER 24, 1968.


Summaries of

Irwin v. Downie

Supreme Court of Georgia
Sep 24, 1968
163 S.E.2d 749 (Ga. 1968)
Case details for

Irwin v. Downie

Case Details

Full title:IRWIN v. DOWNIE, Warden

Court:Supreme Court of Georgia

Date published: Sep 24, 1968

Citations

163 S.E.2d 749 (Ga. 1968)
224 Ga. 616

Citing Cases

Grant v. State

Two exceptions are noted — an extraordinary motion for new trial and habeas corpus. Code Ann. § 70-303 (Code…