Opinion
MDL No. 3:10-md-2143 RS
10-27-2011
IN RE OPTICAL DISK DRIVE PRODUCTS ANTITRUST LITIGATION
HAGENS BERMAN SOBOL SHAPIRO LLP JEFF D. FRIEDMAN Steve W. Berman (Pro Hac Vice) George W. Sampson (Pro Hac Vice) HAGENS BERMAN SOBOL SHAPIRO LLP Interim Lead Counsel for Indirect Purchaser Plaintiffs Thomas V. Girardi (36603) Robert W. Finnerty (119775) GIRARDI & KEESE Charles E. Tompkins Robert E. Ditzion SHAPIRO HABER & URMY LLP Steve D. Larson Mark A. Friel STOLL STOLL BERNE LOKTING & SHLACHTER P.C. Additional Counsel for Indirect Purchaser Plaintiffs DEWEY & LEBOEUF LLP DAVID L. GREENSPAN Jeffrey L. Kessler (admitted pro hac vice) A. Paul Victor (admitted pro hac vice) James F. Lerner (admitted pro hac vice) DEWEY & LEBOEUF LLP Attorneys for Defendants Panasonic Corporation of North America and Panasonic Corporation
Jeff D. Friedman (173886)
Shana E. Scarlett (217895)
HAGENS BERMAN SOBOL SHAPIRO LLP
Steve W. Berman (Pro Hac Vice)
George W. Sampson (Pro Hac Vice)
HAGENS BERMAN SOBOL SHAPIRO LLP
Interim Lead Counsel for Indirect
Purchaser Plaintiffs
[Additional Counsel Listed on
Signature Page]
This Document Relates to:
ALL INDIRECT PURCHASER ACTIONS
STIPULATION AND [PROPOSED]
ORDER REGARDING BRIEFING
SCHEDULE FOR DEFENDANTS'
PANASONIC CORPORATION AND
PANASONIC CORPORATION OF
NORTH AMERICA MOTION TO
DISMISS
DATE ACTION FILED: Oct. 27, 2009
WHEREAS, the Indirect Purchaser Plaintiffs filed a Second Amended Class Action Complaint on September 23, 2011, and a Corrected Second Amended Class Action Complaint on October 18, 2011;
WHEREAS, on October 19, 2011, Indirect Purchaser Plaintiffs and Panasonic Corporation and Panasonic Corporation of North America ("Panasonic Defendants") stipulated to a different briefing schedule;
WHEREAS, all Defendants, including the Panasonic Defendants filed motions to dismiss on October 24, 2011; and
WHEREAS, the Indirect Purchaser Plaintiffs request, and the Panasonic Defendants agree, that the Indirect Purchaser Plaintiffs and Panasonic Defendants will now follow the same briefing schedule as the other parties.
IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED AND AGREED by and between the Indirect Purchaser Plaintiffs and the Panasonic Defendants as follows:
• The deadline for Indirect Purchaser Plaintiffs to file any opposition to the motion to dismiss filed by the Panasonic Defendants is November 21, 2011; and
• The deadline for the Panasonic Defendants to file a reply in support of their motion to dismiss is December 7, 2011.
HAGENS BERMAN SOBOL SHAPIRO LLP
JEFF D. FRIEDMAN
Steve W. Berman (Pro Hac Vice)
George W. Sampson (Pro Hac Vice)
HAGENS BERMAN SOBOL SHAPIRO LLP
Interim Lead Counsel for Indirect
Purchaser Plaintiffs
Thomas V. Girardi (36603)
Robert W. Finnerty (119775)
GIRARDI & KEESE
Charles E. Tompkins
Robert E. Ditzion
SHAPIRO HABER & URMY LLP
Steve D. Larson
Mark A. Friel
STOLL STOLL BERNE LOKTING
& SHLACHTER P.C.
Additional Counsel for Indirect
Purchaser Plaintiffs
DEWEY & LEBOEUF LLP
DAVID L. GREENSPAN
Jeffrey L. Kessler (admitted pro hac vice)
A. Paul Victor (admitted pro hac vice)
James F. Lerner (admitted pro hac vice)
DEWEY & LEBOEUF LLP
Attorneys for Defendants Panasonic Corporation of
North America and Panasonic Corporation
I, Jeff D. Friedman, am the ECF User whose ID and password are being used to file this STIPULATION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER REGARDING BRIEFING SCHEDULE FOR DEFENDANTS' PANASONIC CORPORATION AND PANASONIC CORPORATION OF NORTH AMERICA MOTION TO DISMISS. In compliance with General Order 45, X.B., I hereby attest that all counsel listed above have concurred in this filing.
ORDER
IT IS SO ORDERED.
THE HONORABLE RICHARD SEEBORG
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on October 27, 2011, I electronically filed the foregoing with the Clerk of the Court using the CM/ECF system which will send notification of such filing to the e-mail addresses registered, as denoted on the attached Electronic Mail Notice List, and I hereby certify that I have mailed the foregoing document or paper via the United States Postal Service to the non-CM/ECF participants indicated on the attached Manual Notice List.
JEFF D. FRIEDMAN
Mailing Information for a Case 3:10-md-02143-RS
Electronic Mail Notice List
The following are those who are currently on the list to receive e-mail notices for this case.
• Lee Albert
lalbert@murrayfrank.com
• Joseph M. Alioto , Sr
jmalioto@aliotolaw.com,esexton@aliotolaw.com,jmiller@aliotolaw.com
• Mario N. Alioto
malioto@tatp.com
• U.S. Department of J Antitrust Division
sidney.majalya@usdoj.gov
• Arthur Nash Bailey , Jr
abailey@hausfeldllp.com
• David H. Bamberger
david.bamberger@dlapiper.com,jessica.green-johnson@dlapiper.com
• Brian Joseph Barry , Esq
bribarry1@yahoo.com
• Steve W. Berman
steve@hbsslaw.com,robert@hbsslaw.com,heatherw@hbsslaw.com
• John Dmitry Bogdanov
jdb@coopkirk.com
• W. Joseph Bruckner
wjbruckner@locklaw.com,sipeem@locklaw.com,amhorningnygren@locklaw.com,pottehn@locklaw.com
• Cullen Byrne
whparish@parishsmall.com
• Deana Louise Cairo
deana.cairo@dlapiper.com
• William G. Caldes
bcaldes@srkw-law.com
• Bruce G. Chapman bchapman@cblh.com,dkt@cblh.com,ddellisanti@cblh.com
• Craig C. Corbitt
ccorbitt@zelle.com
• Joseph W. Cotchett
jcotchett@cpmlegal.com
• John F. Cove , Jr
jcove@bsfllp.com,dscott@bsfllp.com,brichardson@bsfllp.com,sphan@bsfllp.com,aloeb@bsfllp.com,vpooni@bsfllp.com,cduong@bsfllp.com,dnasca@bsfllp.com,jlipton@bsfllp.co
• Michael E. Criden
meriden@cridenlove.com
• Thad Alan Davis
Thad.Davis@ropesgray.com,michelle.visser@ropesgray.com,mark.popofsky@ropesgray.com,jane.willis@ropesgray.com,CourtAlert@RopesGray.com,rachel.rubenson@ropesgray.
• Manuel Juan Dominguez
jdominguez@cohenmilstein.com,mwade@cohenmilstein.com
• Robert G. Eisler
reisler@gelaw.com,cnevers@gelaw.com,mwinchell@gelaw.com
• Mary Jane Edelstein Fait
fait@whafh.com,battaglini@whafh.com
• Eric B. Fastiff
efastiff@lchb.com,aruiz@lchb.com,btroxel@lchb.com
• Robert William Finnerty
rfinnerty@girardikeese.com,tfaust@girardikeese.com
• Linda M. Fong
lfong@kaplanfox.com,kweiland@kaplanfox.com
• Keith Douglas Fraser
kfraser@cblh.com,ddellisanti@cblh.com,aduplessis@cblh.com
• Erin Gail Frazor
erin.frazor@dlapiper.com
• Jeff D Friedman
jefff@hbsslaw.com,jeanethd@hbsslaw.com,sf_filings@hbsslaw.com
• Mark A. Friel
mfriel@stollberne.com,dhaner@stollberne.com,slarson@stollberne.com
• Qianwei Fu
qfu@zelle.com
• Jeffrey B. Gittleman
jgittleman@barrack.com,cbowers@barrack.com
• Brendan Patrick Glackin
bglackin@lchb.com
• Michael M. Goldberg
mmgoldberg@glancylaw.com
• David L. Greenspan
dgreenspan@dl.com,courtalert@dl.com
• Marc Jeffrey Greenspon
mgreenspon@bermandevalerio.com
• Francis M. Gregorek
gregorek@whafh.com
• Paul R. Griffin
pgriffin@winston.com,DocketSF@winston.com
• Terry Gross
terry@gba-law.com,monique@gba-law.com,joann@grossbelsky.com,sarah@gba-law.com,adam@gba-law.com
• Laura Ann Guillen
lguillen@winston.com,lschuh@winston.com,docketsf@winston.com,ndelich@winston.com
• Daniel E. Gustafson
dgustafson@gustafsongluek.com,dnoss@gustafsongluek.com
• Amy Harrington
amy@amyharringtonlaw.com
• Casey Ann Hatton
chatton@wilkesmchugh.com
• Michael D. Hausfeld
mhausfeld@hausfeldllp.com,firmfilings@hausfeldllp.com
• Christopher T. Heffelfinger
cheffelfinger@bermandevalerio.com,ysoboleva@bermandevalerio.com
• Christopher B. Hockett
chris.hockett@dpw.com,angela.quach@davispolk.com,ecf.ct.papers@dpw.com,felicia.yu@davispolk.com
• Steven Christopher Holtzman
sholtzman@bsfllp.com,jchavez@bsfllp.com,irivera@bsfllp.com,cseki@bsfllp.com,cduong@bsfllp.com,sphan@bsfllp.com,sjones@bsfllp.com
• Derek G. Howard
dhoward@minamitamaki.com,jlee@minamitamaki.com,byamauchi@minamitamaki.com,grafal@minamitamaki.com,cparker@minamitamaki.com,janderson@minamitamaki.com,se
• Patrick Howard
phoward@smbb.com,cdfonda@smbb.com
• Matthew J. Jacobs
mjacobs@velaw.com,ychen@velaw.com,llee@velaw.com
• Lisa Marie Kaas
KaasL@dicksteinshapiro.com,AndersonP@dicksteinshapiro.com
• Robert N. Kaplan
rkaplan@kaplanfox.com
• Sherman Kassof
heevay@att.net,heevay@yahoo.com
• Jeffrey L. Kessler
jkessler@dl.com,rskridul@dl.com,kcullen@dl.com,mlo@dewey.ballantine.com,courtalert@dl.com
• Jason Kilene
jkilene@gustafsongluek.com,dgustafson@gustafsongluek.com
• Laurence D. King
lking@kaplanfox.com,kweiland@kaplanfox.com
• Andrew Scirica Kingsdale
akingsdale@lchb.com
• Joel Barry Kleinman kleinmanj@dsmo.com
• Kimberly Ann Kralowec
kkralowec@kraloweclaw.com,ggray@kraloweclaw.com,enewman@kraloweclaw.com
• James G. Kress
james.kress@bakerbotts.com
• Lara Meredith Kroop
Lara.Kroop@usdoj.gov
• Manish Kumar
manish.kumar@usdoj.gov,jennie.ngo-tanaka@usdoj.gov
• Susan Gilah Kupfer
skupfer@glancylaw.com,jbarton@glancylaw.com,sfreception@glancylaw.com
• Christopher L. Lebsock
clebsock@hausfeldllp.com,celder@hausfeldllp.com
• Belinda S. Lee
Belinda.Lee@lw.com,#SFDocket@LW.com
• Jack Wing Lee
jlee@MinamiTamaki.com,grafal@minamitamaki.com,janderson@minamitamaki.com,pdomin@MinamiTamaki.com,cparker@MinamiTamaki.com,seant@MinamiTamaki.com
• Michael Paul Lehmann
mlehmann@hausfeldllp.com
• James F. Lerner
jlerner@dl.com
• Adam J. Levitt
levitt@whafh.com,aronowitz@whafh.com
• Aron K. Liang
aliang@cpmlegal.com,edetert@cpmlegal.com,oszeto@cpmlegal.com,jperez@cpmlegal.com
• Alexis Jane Loeb
aloeb@bsfllp.com
• Sarah Robin London
slondon@lchb.com
• Kevin Bruce Love
klove@cridenlove.com
• Zhun Lu
zlu@cblh.com
• Donald Scott Macrae
smacrae@bamlawlj.com
• Sidney A. Majalya
sidney.majalya@usdoj.gov,jennie.ngo-tanaka@usdoj.gov,liliana.vallejo@usdoj.gov
• Timothy Charles McHugh
timmchugh@wilkesmchugh.com
• Brendan Andrew McShane
brendan.mcshane@lw.com,coleen.byrne@lw.com,#sfdocket@lw.com,gina.tercero@lw.com
• Sean D. Meenan
smeenan@winston.com
• Douglas A. Millen doug@fklmlaw.com
• Samuel R. Miller
srmiller@sidley.com,hebalogi@sidley.com
• Theresa Driscoll Moore
TMoore@aliotolaw.com
• Paolo Morante
paolo.morante@dlapiper.com,grissell.kessler@dlapiper.com
• Elizabeth R. Odette
erodette@locklaw.com,sjgutknecht@locklaw.com
• Niki B. Okcu
nokcu@cpmlegal.com
• Matthew C Oxman
moxman@dl.com
• Simon Bahne Paris
sparis@smbb.com,cdfonda@smbb.com,alafontaine@smbb.com
• William Henry Parish
whparish@parishsmall.com,jschwab@parishsmall.com,toup@parishsmall.com
• Robert M. Partain
rpartain@oslaw.com,aowen@oslaw.com
• Joseph Mario Patane
jpatane@tatp.com
• Mark Samuel Popofsky
Mark.Popofsky@ropesgray.com
• Robert Benard Pringle
rpringle@winston.com,jmlopez@winston.com
• Elizabeth Cheryl Pritzker
ecp@girardgibbs.com,tie@girardgibbs.com,smq@girardgibbs.com,amv@girardgibbs.com,ale@girardgibbs.com,cme@girardgibbs.com
• Julio J Ramos
ramosfortrustee@yahoo.com
• Beko Osiris Ra Reblitz-Richardson
brichardson@bsfllp.com
• Rosemary M. Rivas
rrivas@finkelsteinthompson.com,srenwick@finkelsteinthompson.com,bassad@finkelsteinthompson.com,mpunzalan@finkelsteinthompson.com,arivas@finkelsteinthompson.com,tti
• Matthew W Ruan
mruan@bermandevalerio.com,ysoboleva@bermandevalerio.com
• Lauren Clare Russell
laurenrussell@tatp.com
• George W. Sampson
george@hbsslaw.com
• Jennifer Sarnelli
jsarnelli@gardylaw.com
• Guido Saveri
guido@saveri.com
• Joseph Richard Saveri
jsaveri@lchb.com,dclevenger@lchb.com
• Richard Alexander Saveri
rick@saveri.com
• Shana E. Scarlett
shanas@hbsslaw.com,jeanethd@hbsslaw.com,sf_filings@hbsslaw.com
• Francis Onofrei Scarpulla
fscarpulla@zelle.com,mdavis@zelle.com
• Minda R. Schechter
mschechter@cblh.com,dkt@cblh.com,czukowski@cblh.com,kfraser@cblh.com
• Haidee L. Schwartz
hschwartz@omm.com
• Todd Anthony Seaver
tseaver@bermandevalerio.com,ysoboleva@bermandevalerio.com
• Craig P. Seebald
cseebald@velaw.com,jlevnie@velaw.com,kvinson@velaw.com
• Aaron M. Sheanin
asheanin@pswplaw.com
• Ian T Simmons
isimmons@omm.com,phein@omm.com
• Bruce Lee Simon
bsimon@pswplaw.com,nhalpern@pswplaw.com,bpouya@pswplaw.com,rretana@pswplaw.com,yberry@pswplaw.com,dwarshaw@pswplaw.com,jwatkins@pswplaw.com,wnewsom
• Joshua D. Snyder
jsnyder@bonizack.com
• Sylvia M. Sokol
sokol@mesllp.com,torrise@mesllp.com
• Eugene A. Spector
espector@srkw-law.com
• Jeffrey Lawrence Spector
jspector@srkw-law.com
• Allan Steyer asteyer@steyerlaw.com,lrorem@steyerlaw.com
• Jonathan Edward Swartz
jswartz@winston.com,pstruble@winston.com,DocketSF@winston.com,ndelich@winston.com
• Jon Vensel Swenson
jon.swenson@bakerbotts.com,paras.patel@bakerbotts.com,evan.werbel@bakerbotts.com,donna.loop@bakerbotts.com,william.lavery@bakerbotts.com,cynthia.short@bakerbotts.co
• Joseph J. Tabacco , Jr
jtabacco@bermandevalerio.com,lcuesta@bermandevalerio.com,ysoboleva@bermandevalerio.com
• John M. Taladay
john.taladay@bakerbotts.com
• Casandra Leann Thomson
casandra.thomson@lw.com
• Charles E. Tompkins
ctompkins@shulaw.com,lwolahan@shulaw.com,dwoulfe@shulaw.com
• Susannah P. Torpey
storpey@dl.com
• A. Paul Victor
pvictor@dl.com,courtalert@dl.com
• Daniel Murray Wall
dan.wall@lw.com,#sfdocket@lw.com
• Lawrence Walner
walner@walnerlawfirm.com
• Matthew McDonnell Walsh
mwalsh@dl.com,courtalert@dl.com
• Ernest Warren
walwar@qwestoffice.net
• Sandra D West
sandra.west@davispolk.com,micah.block@davispolk.com
• Jonathan Whitcomb
JWhitcomb@dmoc.com
• James Lewis Wilkes
jwilkes@wilkesmchugh.com
• Steven Noel Williams
swilliams@cpmlegal.com,jverducci@cpmlegal.com,cwalker@cpmlegal.com,aliang@cpmlegal.com,edetert@cpmlegal.com,medling@cpmlegal.com,pmenzel@cpmlegal.com,lclark
• Jane E. Willis
Jane.Willis@ropesgray.com
• Lingel Hart Winters
sawmill2@aol.com
• Brad Yamauchi
byamauchi@MinamiTamaki.com,pdomin@MinamiTamaki.com,cparker@MinamiTamaki.com,grafal@minamitamaki.com,kallen@minamitamaki.com,dhoward@minamitamaki.co
• Cadio R. Zirpoli
zirpoli@saveri.com
Manual Notice List The following is the list of attorneys who are not on the list to receive e-mail notices for this case (who therefore require manual noticing). You may wish to use your mouse to select and copy this list into your word processing program in order to create notices or labels for these recipients.
Daniel Bushell
Berman DeValerio
4280 Professional Center Drive, Ste 350
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
William Lavery
Baker Botts LLP
1299 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20004
Michelle L. Visser
Ropes & Gray LLP
Prudential Tower
800 Boylston Street
Boston, MA 02119
Clinton Paul Walker
Damrell Nelson Schrimp Pallios Pache
1601 I Street, 5th Floor
Modesto, CA 95354
Evan Werbel
Baker Botts LLP
1299 Pensylvania Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20004
Michael D Yanovsky
Wolf Haldenstein Adler Freeman Herz LLC 55 West Monroe Street, Ste 1111 Chicago, IL 60603