From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

In re Estate of Pitman

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Oct 14, 1924
107 Okla. 112 (Okla. 1924)

Opinion

No. 15150

Opinion Filed October 14, 1924.

(Syllabus.)

Case Controlling.

Syllabus the same as in case No. 15149, In re Guardianship of Pitman (McMurry Gd'n, v. Cole), ante. p. 108, this day handed down.

Error from District Court, Muskogee County; O.H. Searcy, Judge.

In the matter of the estate of Lucinda Pitman, an incompetent. Petition by Rosella Cole for removal of guardians, Joe McMurry and another. From judgment of removal, the guardians bring error. Affirmed.

Grant Foreman, Guy F. Nelson, and J.D. Simms, for plaintiffs in error.

Neff Neff, E.M. Frye, and J.B.A. Robertson, for defendant in error.


This cause, on appeal to the district court of Muskogee county, was presented on the same state of facts as the matter of the guardianship of Wilson S. Pitman, a minor, Joe McMurry, guardian, No. 15149 on the docket of this court, this day decided. The pertinent facts and law set forth in said cause number 15149 are controlling in this appeal. It was submitted to the district court on the same evidence as said cause was submitted, and the judgment of the district court removing the guardians was based upon the same finding.

The only essential difference in the contentions of the appellants in this case and in cause No. 15149 is that appellants contend that Rosella Cole was not related by blood to Lucinda Pitman, and did not formally prosecute the action as next friend. We think this contention goes to form and not to substance, and that the findings and conclusions in the said cause No. 15149 are fully applicable to this appeal.

The judgment of the trial court in this cause is affirmed.

McNEILL, C.J., and NICHOLSON, HARRISON, JOHNSON, BRANSON, LYDICK, and WARREN, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

In re Estate of Pitman

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Oct 14, 1924
107 Okla. 112 (Okla. 1924)
Case details for

In re Estate of Pitman

Case Details

Full title:In re ESTATE of PITMAN McMURRY et al. v. COLE

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Oct 14, 1924

Citations

107 Okla. 112 (Okla. 1924)
230 P. 506

Citing Cases

SFF-TIR, LLC v. Stephenson

2000 OK 55, ¶ 52, 11 P.3d at 181. The easiest understood example of when attorney fees are recoverable as…

City of Barnsdall v. Curnutt

See, also, Simpson v. Baker, 123 Okla. 118, 252 P. 834; Sterling Milk Products Co. v. Brown, 146 Okla. 302,…