From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Hurley v. Childers

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Feb 15, 1921
195 P. 755 (Okla. 1921)

Opinion

No. 11744

Opinion Filed February 15, 1921.

(Syllabus by the Court.)

Appeal and Error — Case-Made — Extension of Time — Validity of Orders.

When the time fixed for making and serving a case-made is allowed to elapse, the trial court thus loses jurisdiction of the cause, and an order subsequently made by the trial court extending the time for making and serving a case-made is a nullity; and a case-made, made and served by virtue of such order of extension, is a nullity, and confers no jurisdiction upon this court.

Error from District Court, Tillman County; Frank Mathews, Judge.

Action by W.W. Childers and W.T. McWilliams against J.S. Hurley for injunction. From a judgment for plaintiffs, defendant brings error. Dismissed.

Mounts Williams, for plaintiff in error.

Wilson Roe, for defendants in error.


The motion to dismiss, to which there has been no response, urges that the case-made was not served within the time allowed by law or within any legal extension thereof.

The record in the case discloses that the last valid extension of the time within which to serve the case-made expired August 27, 1920; the case-made was not served on defendants in error until the 22nd day of September, 1920; on September 20, 1920, and September 22, 1920, plaintiff in error procured orders from the trial court purporting to extend the time for making and serving a case-made, but these orders, being after the expiration of the time allowed by law or any legal extension thereof, are nullities. It has been held that when the time fixed for making and serving a case-made is allowed to elapse, the trial court thus loses jurisdiction of the case, and an order subsequently made by the trial court extending the time for making and serving a case-made is a nullity; and a case-made, made and served by virtue of such order of extension, is a nullity, and confers no jurisdiction upon this court. Whitaker v. Wilkinson, 80 Okla. 21, 193 P. 735; Cook v. Cook, 79 Okla. 222, 191 P. 215; Cripple Creek Oil Co. v. King, 76 Okla. 316, 185 P. 439; Walker v. Reginald, 51 Okla. 10, 151 P. 680.

This appeal is therefore dismissed.

HARRISON, C. J., and PITCHFORD, McNEILL, and ELTING, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

Hurley v. Childers

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Feb 15, 1921
195 P. 755 (Okla. 1921)
Case details for

Hurley v. Childers

Case Details

Full title:HURLEY v. CHILDERS et al

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Feb 15, 1921

Citations

195 P. 755 (Okla. 1921)
195 P. 755

Citing Cases

Furniture Company v. Oklahoma Discount Corp.

This court is without jurisdiction to review the appeal. The order of the trial court entered November 28,…