From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Holden v. Holden

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts
May 24, 2002
768 N.E.2d 547 (Mass. 2002)

Opinion

SJC-08399

May 24, 2002.

Mark A. Leahy for the trustee.



Trust, Reformation, Settlor, Mistake.

Nancy P. Holden, sole trustee of the Holden Family Trust, commenced this action in the county court, seeking reformation of the trust by insertion of a provision granting her — as the surviving spouse of the trust's settlor, William E. Holden — the right to receive the trust's annual income and certain principal payments during her lifetime. According to her, omission of such a provision was due to a scrivener's error and does not reflect the intent of her late husband. The defendants, beneficiaries of the trust, assented to the relief sought. A single justice of this court reserved and reported the case to the full court.

This case is virtually identical to Pond v. Pond, 424 Mass. 894 (1997) (reforming trust in same manner based on construction of highly similar trust agreement and will). For the reasons stated in that case, we remand this case to the county court for entry of a judgment reforming the trust as proposed. So ordered.

We take this opportunity to remind litigants and attorneys bringing trust reformation cases before this court of their obligation to provide "a full and proper record and the requisite degree of proof that they are entitled to the relief they seek." Walker v. Walker, 433 Mass. 581, 582 n. 5 (2001).

The case was submitted on briefs.


Summaries of

Holden v. Holden

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts
May 24, 2002
768 N.E.2d 547 (Mass. 2002)
Case details for

Holden v. Holden

Case Details

Full title:NANCY P. HOLDEN, trustee, v. NANCY P. HOLDEN, executrix, others

Court:Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts

Date published: May 24, 2002

Citations

768 N.E.2d 547 (Mass. 2002)
437 Mass. 1004

Citing Cases

John v. Ryan

However, we once again "remind litigants and attorneys bringing trust reformation cases before this court of…

Booth v. Kornegay

We do, however, "once again `remind litigants and attorneys bringing trust reformation cases before this…