Argued November 13, 1878
Decided December 10, 1878
George N. Kennedy for appellant.
Isaac D. Garfield for respondent.
FOLGER, J., reads for affirmance of order and for judgment absolute against defendant on stipulation.
CHURCH, Ch. J., RAPALLO and MILLER, JJ., concur; EARL and HAND, JJ., dissent; ANDREWS, J., absent.
Order affirmed and judgment accordingly.
Full title:JOHN HOFFMAN, Administrator, etc., Respondent, v . THE NEW YORK CENTRAL…
Court:Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Date published: Dec 10, 1878
Mr. Justice TALCOTT, writing the unanimous opinion of the court, declared: "In this case the leaving of the…
Boyce v. Manhattan Railway Co.We think that the evidence required the submission of the case to the jury for them to determine whether,…