From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Hilton v. Harding

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine. Somerset County
Jul 16, 1938
191 A. 485 (Me. 1938)

Opinion

Decided July 16, 1938.

In this action of negligence, the plaintiff has the verdict and the case comes forward on the defendant's general motion for a new trial.

As the plaintiff was leaving the fair grounds at Skowhegan on August 22, 1936, riding as a guest passenger on the back seat of the automobile which the defendant was driving, she was suddenly thrown forward and down upon the floor with great force breaking her right leg and suffering other serious bodily injuries. The accident occurred as the defendant drove his car into Madison Avenue from an intersecting street and stopped to avoid oncoming traffic.

The printed case discloses a sharp conflict between the evidence on the one side and the other as to the defendant's negligence and the plaintiff's due care. No conclusive presumptions in the defendant's favor appear in the record. A finding for the plaintiff on all issues was not manifestly wrong. Motion overruled.

James H. Thorne, for plaintiff.

Merrill Merrill, for defendant.


Summaries of

Hilton v. Harding

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine. Somerset County
Jul 16, 1938
191 A. 485 (Me. 1938)
Case details for

Hilton v. Harding

Case Details

Full title:EDITH T. HILTON vs. BOOTH H. HARDING

Court:Supreme Judicial Court of Maine. Somerset County

Date published: Jul 16, 1938

Citations

191 A. 485 (Me. 1938)
191 A. 485

Citing Cases

Opinion of the Justices

See also Opinion of the Justices, 125 Me. 529, 539, 133 A. 265, 270 (1926) (Answer of Dunn, J., later Dunn,…

Op. of Justices of Supreme Judicial Court Given Under Provisions of Article VI

In most instances, a challenge to the constitutionality of an existing law will be presented in the…