From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Henry v. Sweeney

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts. Essex
Nov 12, 1913
103 N.E. 85 (Mass. 1913)

Opinion

November 6, 1913.

November 12, 1913.

Present: RUGG, C.J., MORTON, LORING, BRALEY, De COURCY, JJ.

Practice, Civil, Jurisdiction of person, Motion to dismiss. Pleading, Civil, Answer to merits. Waiver.

The objection of a want of jurisdiction of the person of the defendant in an action at law cannot be raised by a motion to dismiss after the defendant has submitted himself to the jurisdiction of the court by filing a general answer to the merits.

D.B. Beard, for the defendant.

T.A. Henry, for the plaintiffs.


Plainly no error is disclosed on this record.

The defendant's contention is that since the actions are against an executor who did not reside in the county wherein was the district court out of which the writs issued, that court had no jurisdiction. He did not file seasonably a proper pleading setting out this objection. He waived it by general answers to the merits in each case more than a year before he filed a motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction. The district court had jurisdiction of the subject matter of the actions. It acquired jurisdiction of the person of the defendant through his answer to the merits of the actions. Brown v. Webber, 6 Cush. 560, 564, and cases there reviewed. Bishop v. Donnell, 171 Mass. 563, 566. McManus v. Thing, 208 Mass. 55, 58.

Order overruling defendant's motion to dismiss affirmed with costs.


Summaries of

Henry v. Sweeney

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts. Essex
Nov 12, 1913
103 N.E. 85 (Mass. 1913)
Case details for

Henry v. Sweeney

Case Details

Full title:THOMAS F. HENRY vs. JOHN J. SWEENEY, executor. JEREMIAH F. DALEY vs. SAME

Court:Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts. Essex

Date published: Nov 12, 1913

Citations

103 N.E. 85 (Mass. 1913)
103 N.E. 85

Citing Cases

Woodbury v. Commonwealth

He became subject to the jurisdiction of the court. Henry v. Sweeney, 216 Mass. 112. Paige v. Sinclair, 237…

Universal Supply Co. v. Hildreth

By filing a general appearance in the District Court and by taking the necessary steps to remove the case to…