From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Hale v. St. Clair

Supreme Court of Alabama
Oct 16, 1930
130 So. 917 (Ala. 1930)

Opinion

7 Div. 961.

October 16, 1930.

Appeal from Circuit Court, Cherokee County; A. E. Hawkins, Judge.

Hugh Reed, of Center, for appellants.

Irby A. Keener, of Center, for appellee.


Appellee had a decree in accordance with the prayer of his bill that a certain deed of trust or mortgage which he had executed and delivered to appellants' intestate, along with two promissory notes secured thereby, be canceled as having been paid in full. Appellants, as administrators of the estate of the deceased mortgagee, claimed that there was a balance due on the debt evidenced by the two promissory notes made to their intestate, and prayed for a decree of foreclosure.

The difference between the parties is a difference of fact only, and, after careful consideration, the court here is in agreement with the trial court that the debt between appellants' intestate and appellee had been satisfied in full in the lifetime of decedent and before the bill was filed. This we say after excluding from consideration any and every part of the testimony of complainant which is affected by section 7721 of the Code, providing, inter alia, that "no person having a pecuniary interest in the result of the suit or proceeding shall be allowed to testify against the party to whom his interest is opposed as to any transaction with, or statement by, the deceased person whose estate is interested in the result of the suit or proceeding." There is no need to indulge a more intimate discussion of the evidence. The court is of opinion that the evidence not affected by the statute suffices to sustain the decree in the court below.

Affirmed.

ANDERSON, C. J., and THOMAS and BROWN, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

Hale v. St. Clair

Supreme Court of Alabama
Oct 16, 1930
130 So. 917 (Ala. 1930)
Case details for

Hale v. St. Clair

Case Details

Full title:L. D. HALE et al. v. W. L. ST. CLAIR

Court:Supreme Court of Alabama

Date published: Oct 16, 1930

Citations

130 So. 917 (Ala. 1930)
222 Ala. 706