From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Greene v. Atlantic Coast Line Railroad

Supreme Court of South Carolina
Mar 12, 1929
150 S.C. 239 (S.C. 1929)

Opinion

12609

March 12, 1929.

Before SHIPP, J., Hampton, February, 1927. Affirmed.

Action by Willie Greene, as administrator of Daniel Edwards against Atlantic Coast Line Railroad Company. From order of nonsuit plaintiff appeals.

Messrs. W.D. Connor and Thos. M. Boulware, for appellant, cite: Duty of railroad to license: 61 S.C. 556; 70 S.C. 183; 89 S.C. 161; 97 S.C. 61; 125 S.C. 478. Distinguished: 120 S.C. 473. Failure to give statutory signals evidence of negligence: 142 S.E., 336. As to acts under sudden emergency: 82 S.C. 71. Nonsuit improper here on grounds of no beneficiary: 70 S.C. 297.

Mr. J.W. Manuel, and Hagood, Rivers Young, for respondent, cite: Duty of track walker: 104 S.C. 107; 120 S.C. 473; 98 S.C. 492; 94 S.C. 143.


March 12, 1929. The opinion of the Court was delivered by


Action for tort, tried in the Court of Common Pleas for Hampton County, growing out of the killing of plaintiff's intestate by a railroad train of the defendant, while the deceased was walking on a track of the defendant. At the close of plaintiff's testimony, the presiding Judge, Hon. S.W.G. Shipp, granted a nonsuit, on the ground that the testimony showed, and the only inference which could be drawn therefrom was, that the injury to and death of plaintiff's intestate was due to his own negligence as a proximate cause thereof. The plaintiff has appealed to this Court.

We do not think it necessary to state all the testimony. We have examined it carefully, and agree with the presiding Judge in his ruling. The facts in the case of Davis v. Payne, Director General, 120 S.C. 473, 113 S.E., 325, are very much similar to the facts of this case, and we think it is controlling here. The judgment of this Court is that the order of nonsuit be, and the same is hereby, affirmed.

MR. CHIEF JUSTICE WATTS and MESSRS. JUSTICES COTHRAN, STABLER, and CARTER, concur.


Summaries of

Greene v. Atlantic Coast Line Railroad

Supreme Court of South Carolina
Mar 12, 1929
150 S.C. 239 (S.C. 1929)
Case details for

Greene v. Atlantic Coast Line Railroad

Case Details

Full title:GREENE, ADMINISTRATOR, v. ATLANTIC COAST LINE RAILROAD COMPANY

Court:Supreme Court of South Carolina

Date published: Mar 12, 1929

Citations

150 S.C. 239 (S.C. 1929)
147 S.E. 927

Citing Cases

Pryor v. Atlanta-Charlotte Airline Ry. Co.

essrs. Leppard Leppard and W.E. Bowen, for appellant, cite: As to amount of care owed trespassers: 61 S.C.…

Dobson v. Henrietta Mills

Messrs. Dobson Dobson, for appellant, cite: Scintillarule: 95 S.C. 347; 78 S.E., 1026; 98 S.C. 381; 14 Rich.,…