From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Great Western Coal Coke Co. v. Belcher

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Mar 3, 1914
143 P. 36 (Okla. 1914)

Opinion

No. 4461

Opinion Filed March 3, 1914. Rehearing Denied September 22, 1914.

Error from District Court, Latimer County; W. H. Brown, Judge.

Action by Mary E. Belcher against the Great Western Coal Coke Company, a corporation, and others. Judgment for plaintiff, and defendant named brings error. Affirmed.

Gordon McInnis, for plaintiff in error.

H. H. Smith and C. R. Hunt, for defendant in error.


On August 26, 1910, Mary E. Belcher, defendant in error, in the district court of Latimer county, sued the Great Western Coal Coke Company, plaintiff in error, and W. P. Thomas and Dan Hughes, in damages for the negligent killing of her husband, George Belcher, who was one of the coal diggers that met death in the explosion of which we spoke in the McMahan case against the same defendants, ante, 143 P. 23. As the record here discloses substantially the same issues and the same state of facts as in that case and the cases of Coffman, ante, 143 P. 30, and Cunningham, ante, 143 P. 26, also coal diggers, killed at the same time, and the assignments of error here involved were there decided, what we said in those cases is equally applicable here.

As in those cases, finding no error in the record, the judgment of the trial court is affirmed.

All the Justices concur, except WILLIAMS, J., absent and not participating.


Summaries of

Great Western Coal Coke Co. v. Belcher

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Mar 3, 1914
143 P. 36 (Okla. 1914)
Case details for

Great Western Coal Coke Co. v. Belcher

Case Details

Full title:GREAT WESTERN COAL COKE CO. v. BELCHER

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Mar 3, 1914

Citations

143 P. 36 (Okla. 1914)
143 P. 36

Citing Cases

Whitehead Coal Mining Co. v. Schneider

" The allegations of the plaintiff in his petition in substance and effect are that he received the injuries…

Quapaw Mining Co. v. Cogburn

The operator must not only furnish timbers and a timber man to timber the mine, but he must see that the mine…