From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Giannini v. Bd. of Elections

Supreme Court of Rhode Island
Aug 24, 1966
101 R.I. 285 (R.I. 1966)

Opinion

August 24, 1966.

PRESENT: Roberts, C.J., Paolino, Powers, Joslin and Kelleher, JJ.

ELECTIONS. Candidate for State Senate. Eligibility. Respondent board found petitioner to be ineligible as candidate for state senate concluding he was not a qualified voter in the city which encompassed the senatorial district when he filed his declaration. Held, that board acted illegally. G.L. 1956, § 17-14-2.

CERTIORARI to review decision of board of elections, petition granted, decision of board quashed with direction.

McGee, Gifford Giannini, William G. Gilroy, Thomas F. Farrelly, for petitioner.

John P. Bourcier, for respondents.


This is a petition for certiorari brought to review a decision of the board of elections rejecting the petitioner's declaration of candidacy for the office of senator for the fifth senatorial district. The petitioner's motion for special assignment for oral argument was denied. However, permission was granted all interested parties to file a memorandum of law with the court by August 22, 1966. The cause was considered on said memoranda and a copy of the decision of the respondent board submitted by the parties.

It appears that the board rejected petitioner's declaration on the ground that he was not a person eligible to file such a declaration within the purview of the pertinent provisions of G.L. 1956, § 17-14-2. That section, as amended, reads: "No person shall be eligible to file a declaration of candidacy, or be eligible to be a candidate or be eligible to be voted for or to be nominated or elected in a party primary, unless such person shall, at the time of filing such declaration, be a qualified voter eligible to vote at the primary of said political party."

The board found petitioner ineligible and rejected his declaration for candidacy on its conclusion that he "was not a qualified voter in the City of Providence on June 27, 1966, the date that he filed his declaration and thus does not comply with the provisions of Chapter 17-14-2, and therefore is ineligible to be a candidate to be voted for in the Democratic primary to be held on September 13, 1966."

We are aware of the need for an expeditious disposition of this petition because of the time element involved in the preparation of ballots for the Democratic primary. Therefore, we will not extend this opinion by discussing the arguments advanced by the parties. It is our opinion that the statute is not susceptible of any reasonable construction that would in the circumstances sustain the validity of the board's action. We are therefore constrained to hold that the board acted illegally in rejecting the petitioner's declaration of candidacy.

The petition for certiorari is granted, the decision of the board of elections rejecting the petitioner's declaration of candidacy is quashed, and the board of elections is directed to accept for filing the petitioner's declaration of candidacy.


Summaries of

Giannini v. Bd. of Elections

Supreme Court of Rhode Island
Aug 24, 1966
101 R.I. 285 (R.I. 1966)
Case details for

Giannini v. Bd. of Elections

Case Details

Full title:ANTHONY A. GIANNINI vs. BOARD OF ELECTIONS et al

Court:Supreme Court of Rhode Island

Date published: Aug 24, 1966

Citations

101 R.I. 285 (R.I. 1966)
222 A.2d 193

Citing Cases

Conrad v. Town of Narragansett Board of Canvassers

It does not constitute an argument distinct from those dealt with hereafter in this opinion. However,…

Collins v. State Bd. of Elections

Other provisions of chapter 11 of title 17 reveal that a municipal ward or any one of the state's one hundred…