From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Gengler v. Hooper

Supreme Court of Illinois
Dec 23, 1926
154 N.E. 450 (Ill. 1926)

Opinion

No. 17717. Reversed and remanded.

Opinion filed December 23, 1926.

APPEAL from the Circuit Court of Cook county; the Hon. FRANCIS WILSON, Judge, presiding.

JAMES H. HOOPER, pro se.


Appellees filed their bill of complaint in chancery in the circuit court of Cook county alleging that they were the owners of certain real estate in that county, praying that a bailiff's deed issued to Bertha F. Hooper, and a quit-claim deed from her to James H. Hooper, be set aside and canceled. Answers were filed thereto, and upon a hearing a decree was entered setting aside the deeds in accordance with the prayer of the bill. The record is now before this court upon appeal.

No findings of fact were made by the court in the decree, and the transcript of the record of the circuit court does not show that the evidence was preserved by a certificate of evidence or report of a master in chancery, nor is it supported by a verdict of a jury. Appellant assigns as error the entry of a decree for affirmative relief not based upon any findings of fact contained therein or upon evidence properly preserved.

In chancery it is incumbent upon the party in whose favor a decree granting relief is entered, to preserve in the record the evidence justifying the decree. The general finding that all the material allegations in the bill are proved and that the equities of the case are with the complainant will not sustain a decree granting relief where there is no finding of specific facts and the evidence is not preserved in the record by a certificate of evidence, the report of a master in chancery finding the facts, or the verdict of a jury. Ohman v. Ohman, 233 Ill. 632; VanMeter v. Malchef, 276 id. 451; Akin v. Akin, 268 id. 324.

The decree of the circuit court must therefore be reversed and the cause remanded.

Reversed and remanded.


Summaries of

Gengler v. Hooper

Supreme Court of Illinois
Dec 23, 1926
154 N.E. 450 (Ill. 1926)
Case details for

Gengler v. Hooper

Case Details

Full title:JULIANNA GENGLER et al. Appellees, vs. JAMES H. HOOPER et al. — (JAMES H…

Court:Supreme Court of Illinois

Date published: Dec 23, 1926

Citations

154 N.E. 450 (Ill. 1926)
154 N.E. 450

Citing Cases

Vette v. Brown

A general finding that all of the material allegations of the bill are proved and that the equities of the…

Quigley v. Quigley

A party in whose favor relief is decreed in a chancery case must in some way preserve in the record the…