From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Gallagher v. Dolan

Supreme Court, New York Special Term
Apr 1, 1899
27 Misc. 122 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1899)

Opinion

April, 1899.

Hamilton Griffing, for motion.

Louis Steckler, opposed.


The defendant being held under a body execution, issued upon a judgment in an action for negligence, this motion is made to set it aside, upon the ground that the negligence in suit consisted of an omission rather than a willful wrong, and the case of Lasche v. Dearing, 23 Misc. 722, is cited as authority for the distinction. Examination of the case referred to shows that the reasoning adopted would oppose the issuance of an execution against the person in any case where the cause of action is for negligence, as distinguished from an unlawful trespass against the person, and this is contrary to controlling authority. Ritterman v. Ropes, 52 N.Y. Super. Ct. 236, and cases cited; Miller v. Woodhead, 52 Hun, 127.

Motion denied, with $10 costs.


Summaries of

Gallagher v. Dolan

Supreme Court, New York Special Term
Apr 1, 1899
27 Misc. 122 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1899)
Case details for

Gallagher v. Dolan

Case Details

Full title:JOHN GALLAGHER, an Infant, by ANTHONY GALLAGHER, his Guardian ad Litem…

Court:Supreme Court, New York Special Term

Date published: Apr 1, 1899

Citations

27 Misc. 122 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1899)
57 N.Y.S. 334

Citing Cases

Davids v. Brooklyn Heights R.R. Co.

The case of Ritterman v. Ropes, 7 Civ. Pro. 392, holds that the personal injury need not be willful; this,…