From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Fuller v. Texas Western Financial Corp.

Supreme Court of Texas
Oct 13, 1982
644 S.W.2d 442 (Tex. 1982)

Opinion

No. C-1495.

October 13, 1982.

Appeal from the 115th Judicial District Court, Wood County, Virgil E. Mulanax, J.

Charles H. Clark, Tyler, for petitioner.

Hunter, Stewart, Salzberger, Vineyard Miller, Harry J. Martin, Jr., Dallas, for respondent.


The facts and contentions of the parties are set out in the court of appeals' opinion. 635 S.W.2d 787. We agree with the trial court and the court of appeals the delivery of goods to Fuller was a sale as a matter of law and not a consignment. We also agree, however, with Fuller's contention that section 2.326(c) of the Texas Business and Commerce Code does not apply to transactions between original contracting parties or their assignees. The language of section 2.326(c) indicates the intent of the parties is to be disregarded only when the rights of third-party creditors intervene. See Tex.Bus. Com. Code Ann. § 2.326(c), Comment 2 (Vernon 1968). As between original parties, the proper focus is on subdivision (a) of section 2.326. The trial court should determine from any agreements between the parties whether a sale or return was intended or whether the parties unequivocably "otherwise agreed" to create a consignment. We refuse the writ, no reversible error.


Summaries of

Fuller v. Texas Western Financial Corp.

Supreme Court of Texas
Oct 13, 1982
644 S.W.2d 442 (Tex. 1982)
Case details for

Fuller v. Texas Western Financial Corp.

Case Details

Full title:Danny FULLER, Individually and d/b/a Danny's Factory Outlet, Petitioner…

Court:Supreme Court of Texas

Date published: Oct 13, 1982

Citations

644 S.W.2d 442 (Tex. 1982)

Citing Cases

Tri-State Chemicals, Inc. v. Western Organics, Inc.

Id. Admittedly, there are exceptions to the rule; yet, it is obvious that before the rule can come into play…

J.B. Int'l v. William Noble Rare Jewels, L.P.

. While a different meaning of the term consignment prevails in determining the rights of a third party in…